Top Pizza Restaurants in Lake Mary, FL Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Lake Mary: a local guide

Lake Mary may not be the first city to come to mind when you think of the best places to get pizza—but genuinely, it should be. The city is home to different kinds of pizza styles. There is no shortage of spots to taste and experiment. Tomato, thick square, New York-style, and even upside-down pies can be found here, and there is an increase in new options almost every day. That being said, New-York style pizza is considered the most popular in Lake Mary. This pizza style is the closest to the Neapolitan style pizza. It usually has a thin crust with the ideal balance of tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The ratio is essential to ensure the crust is not overloaded and soggy. Experts eat the pizza folded in half and the slices are always large. There is an abundance of upscale pizza restaurants that serve nothing but the best New York-style pizzas in Lake Mary.

Best Delivery Pizza in Lake Mary

Giovanni's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria does not just offer crispy pies but gives the option to mix and match to make the pizza of your choice. Giovanni's offers mouth-watering calzones, subs, and other fresh dishes, but the real star is, of course, the pizza. One of the neighborhood favorites is the signature Giovanni’s Special Pizza which contains pepperoni, peppers, fresh mushrooms, and black olives. This amazing pizza place can do literally any pizza style, from Sicilian to stuffed pizza to gourmet pizza. They even offer pizza by the slice if you’re not too hungry. Not only does Giovanni's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria offer fresh ingredients atop unique signature pizzas, but customers can also opt for gluten-free pies. Try their classic gluten-free cheese pizza and add your desired tasty toppings. If you want, you can easily recreate Giovanni's Special Pizza in a gluten-free version. Don’t forget to order a slice of cheesecake or tiramisu for dessert.

Best Takeout Pizza in Lake Mary

1000 Degrees in Lake Mary is famous for its Neapolitan pizza. This made-to-order, fast-casual restaurant creates pizza that can go crust-to-crust against some of Lake Mary’s top pizza restaurants. They offer classic and unique Neapolitan pizza variations like the one with marinara sauce, olive oil, and fresh mozzarella. Another has spicy sriracha marinara, Canadian bacon, pineapple, and banana peppers, called the Hawaiian Fire. The same Neapolitan pizza flavors are also available in the more oblong Roman pizza style. Before you sink your teeth into one of their delicious pizzas, start with equally impressive cheesy breadsticks or one of the signature salads. If you want to test the limits of your stomach, tack on the traditional wings tossed in one of six flavorful sauces, like bourbon BBQ, honey garlic, and pesto sauce. 1000 Degrees is family-friendly and even offers a kid’s menu, and the cinnamon sticks for dessert are easy to share among the whole family.

Best Pizza near Lake Mary


Sanford, one of Central Florida’s oldest cities, is known for its elegant store-fronts, towering oaks, and brick-lined streets. It is home to the Sanford Museum, Central Florida Zoo, and Seminole State College of Florida. The Original Christo’s is an American restaurant that opened in 1971, specializing in pizza and burgers in a family-friendly environment. This neighborhood favorite is famous for its Two Toppings Pizza, available in three different sizes. Over a dozen house specialties also include the Greeks Gone Wild Pizza, which contains gyro, feta, kalamata olives, and fresh tomatoes.

Winter Springs

Under ten miles from Lake Mary, Winter Springs is a beautiful city in Florida with natural suburban communities. Destiny’s Big City Pizza sells some of the best pizza in the city. Among its variations are New York-style pizzas and Chicago-style pizzas. There are also daily specials on certain days of the week. Destiny’s also has a great selection of salads, strombolis, and appetizers, like the Gulf Coast Crab Cakes.


Casselberry is known for thriving businesses, community, and cultural activities. Casselberry’s favorite pizzeria, Zippoz Pizza, offers an array of pizza choices. With over 15 years of experience in pizza-making, Zippoz Pizza offers Sicilian pizza by the slice and an array of specialty pizzas, such as the Vegetarian and Meat Lovers. The Subs, calzones, and salads all feature heavily on their menu.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconFloridachevron right icon Pizza Places in Lake Mary, FL