New Port Richey may not have a celebrated regional style of pizza that rivals Chicago deep-dish, Detroit’s square-cut gems, or New York thin-crust. Still, this city entirely holds its ground when it comes to producing mouthwatering pizza. Always keep in mind the pizzerias in New Port Richey are strong contenders for the best New York-style pizza around. The competition among the pizzerias in New Port Richey keeps them all on their toes and makes them want to meet or exceed customers’ expectations every time. With its crispy crust, hand-tossed base, melted cheese dripping off the sides, a balanced layer of homemade sauce, and the most delicious toppings — New York-style pizza is one of the greatest gifts from New York to New Port Richey. New York-style pizza can easily be identified by its thin hand-tossed base, crispy crust, and characteristically large size.

Best Delivery Pizza in New Port Richey

Sam’s New York Pizza is a neighborhood favorite that turns out excellent New York-style pizza year after year in a cozy atmosphere. Sam’s New York Pizza opened to outstanding reviews and instantly became a bustling business in 2006. You can’t go wrong with any of the pizzas at Sam’s New York Pizza but start with one of the neighborhood favorites: Sam’s Favorite Pizza, made with tomato, feta, garlic, and spinach. With pizza inspired by both Italy and New Port Richey, it's known for its crispy crust and seriously delicious toppings. Other offerings include homemade rolls, a wide selection of starters and sides, and a robust beverage menu. High-quality New York-style pizza and more can always be found at Sam’s New York Pizza, where fresh and healthy ingredients are prioritized, and the dough is treated with the utmost care.

Best Takeout Pizza in New Port Richey

Joey’s New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant features an extensive menu filled with entrees, pasta, salads, and pizzas, but the pizzas are the real star. With different pizza varieties on the menu in various sizes, Joey’s New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant offers something for every taste and mood. This longstanding Italian favorite, located on Little Road, has long been a neighborhood favorite for classic New York-style pies that boast the perfect combination of crunch and chew. Pretty much all the pizza choices in their menu are good, and that’s because they make sure to get the best Italian ingredients. Simplicity is key at Joey’s New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant, but there is surely nothing plain about their New York classic pies. This legendary spot has two branches in New Port Richey and excels in producing both square and round pies topped with high-quality ingredients.

Best Pizza near New Port Richey

Tarpon Springs

Tarpon Springs, also known as the sponge capital of the world, is a city on central Florida’s gulf coast with many restaurants, bars, and parks. Back Draughts Pizza is a modern restaurant that home-made Italian dishes to locals. You can grab thin crust, wood-fired pizza, plus salads. If you’re up for trying new things, Back Draughts Pizza is here to give you just about every topping combination imaginable.

Odessa

Odessa is a suburb of Tampa in Pasco County, Florida, known for its lakes, natural beauty, calmness, and privacy. As Odessa’s best pizza restaurant, Ceparano’s Too NY Style Pizza provides Odessa with fresh pies prepared with the best ingredients. The menu runs the Margarita Pizza and Meatza Pizza to Cauliflower Pizzas like White Cauliflower Pizzas and Veggie Cauliflower Pizzas. Ceparano’s Too NY Style Pizza provides pizza that screams authenticity and fills the belly satisfyingly.

Hudson

Yet another landmark in Florida, Hudson is home to Bruno’s Pizzeria. This family-owned restaurant serves Sicilian Pizza alongside subs, entrees, and calzones. They have incorporated some new menu items over the years, but nothing beats the OG Cheese Bruno’s Special Pizza, which comprises pepperoni, sausage, onions, and meatballs. There are also nice beverage options so you can enjoy your meal while sipping espresso or soda.