Find Pizza Near You in Tallahassee, Florida

Tallahassee is built on some of the highest ground in Florida. That prime position was one worth fighting for in the 16th to17th century. The city, which is now the state capital, had a turbulent early history peppered with continual battles between the indigenous tribes of the area, Spanish conquerors, and the American armies of the First Seminole War. Tallahassee grew in importance during the era of cotton production, but it wasn't until after the Civil War and the abolition of slavery that life began to improve for many of its residents. Tallahassee's tumultuous history continued during its involvement in the Civil Rights Movement in the 20th century. The unrest and lack of suitable employment in the city didn't attract many European migrants. Italians were and still are a minority ethnic group in Tallahassee and while pizza was a late arrival on the city's culinary scene, it did eventually appear in the early 1970s and has remained a favorite ever since.

Recommended Pizzerias in Tallahassee

caret icon

Solle's Pizza logo

Brooklyn Pizza logo

Munchies Pizza logo

Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen logo

Isabella's Pizzeria Napoletana logo


Pizzerias in Tallahassee with Discounts

caret icon

Brooklyn Pizza logo

Munchies Pizza logo

Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen logo

Village Pizza & Pasta  logo


Pizzerias in Tallahassee with Fastest Delivery

caret icon

Solle's Pizza logo

Brooklyn Pizza logo

Munchies Pizza logo

Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen logo

Munchies Pizza logo


Pizzerias in Tallahassee with Free Delivery

caret icon

Barnaby's Family Inn logo

Decent Pizza logo

Munchies Pizza logo


Tallahassee in Florida is known for New York-style pizza

With a district in the city named Lipona which is an anagram of Napoli, you might expect Tallahassee to be known for Naples-style pizza, but it’s not. The name was given to the district by the nephew of Napoleon Bonaparte who came to the area with a group of French Settlers. He purchased land to farm as a plantation and called it after the Italian city he expected to be ruler of one day. Tallahassee is known for New York-style pizza and it's a pie that features heavily on most of the city's pizzeria menus. Why New York-style pizza is popular in Tallahassee is a mystery as the Big Apple is over a thousand miles north. It's the over-sized, thin-based pizza that's the number one seller though and even when it's covered to the max with multiple ingredients, as it tends to be in Tallahassee, it's still the easiest and best, foldable slice going for a satisfying snack.

Best delivery pizza in Tallahassee, Florida

When you're at home or at work and start to feel peckish, that means it's time to order in a pizza. New York-style pies don't appreciate being kept in a box for long, so you need to order from a pizzeria with a swift delivery service to make sure you get a pizza that's in optimum conditions. Not only do Munchie's on Apalachee Avenue bake a fantastic pizza they're fast on delivery too. Munchies Pizza occupies a bright, modern premise that's neat, uncluttered, and ready for action. Their smart, open-plan, stainless-steel-equipped kitchen shows they mean business when it comes to making pies. Get your delivery pizza from Munchies and you'll receive a pie made from fresh dough and smothered in sauce and ingredients. For a mega gastronomical treat don't miss trying their Pineapple Express pizza. It has chicken, pulled pork, peppers, pineapple, banana and is finished with an unusual mango habanero drizzle.

Best takeout pizza in Tallahassee, Florida

When you want to pick up the best take-out pizza in Tallahassee go to Brooklyn Pizza on West Pensacola Street. They're so appreciative of their passing trade they have parking spaces reserved for their clients only right outside their door. That's exceptionally considerate and very convenient when you don't have much time to spare. You might not be overly wowed with the internal decor of Brooklyn's as it's sort of 1970's, or before, diner-style and a little on the dark side, but that won't matter as you won't be eating in if you're getting a take-out. Their pizzas are not dated by any means and definitely tastier than their interior decoration. If you want to impress a date or your partner, they'll even make you a heart-shaped pie to take away. Choose the right toppings to go with the loved-up dough and you could be onto a winner.

Best pizza near Tallahassee, Florida

Ochlockonee


Drive ten miles northeast of Tallahassee and you'll come to a small community called Ochlockonee. There's not much in Ochlocknee other than a fast-flowing section of the Ochlockonee River and a live music venue called the Warrior on the River, but it's the gateway to the Lake Talquin State Park and Recreational Area. After a hike through the countryside or an ear-blasting concert, head to Mama DeLuca's on Blue Star Highway for a pizza.

Monticello


Head in the direction of Monticello, a city just under thirty miles east of Tallahassee, and you'll find some fascinating places to visit. The Letchworth Love Mounds Archaeological State Park with its prehistoric hillocks of earth is also a great spot for hiking as is the shoreline of Lake Miccosukee which borders it. When you've had your fill of the outdoors, pick up a pie from the Mafia Pizza and Speakeasy Sportsbar on Monticello's North Jefferson Street.

Wakulla Beach


Escape to the Florida coast by motoring directly south from Tallahassee for around forty minutes until you reach Wakulla Beach. You'll be amazed by its sand-rimmed shore, the nearby Wakulla State Forest, and the Wakulla River Outstanding Florida Water area. It's a super scenic spot and a pleasant change from the city. Stop off on the way back at Papa John's on the Preston Circuit for a pizza.

FAQ

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Chicago-style pizza in Tallahassee?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best veggie pizza in Tallahassee

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Sicilian-style pizza in Tallahassee?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best half and half pizza in Tallahassee?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Even More in Tallahassee

Slicechevron right iconAll Citieschevron right icon Restaurants in Tallahassee