Top Pizza Restaurants in Venice, FL in 2024 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Only 18 miles from bustling Sarasota, Venice, Florida is a quaint little town that is alive with sweetness and charm. A quiet seaside region, the majority of the residents of Venice are in their senior years. The city is both clean and safe, making it a wonderful place to raise a family. One of Venice’s biggest drawing cards is its wide sampling of incredibly scenic Gulf Coast beaches, making this spot a haven for those who enjoy spending time in the sand and the surf. The primary attraction in this popular city is Venice Beach, a spot renowned for its immense coral reef located off the coast. Casperson Beach also draws a large number of visitors each year. It is at this popular seaside attraction that shark teeth are often discovered along the shore.

For avid hikers, there are many different trails to choose from; many of which contain beautiful water features or that wander through lush, green vegetation that is home to many species of wildlife including the well-renowned Florida scrub jays. Its fishing pier, measuring 700-feet in total length, is a big draw for amateur and professional anglers as well as those who simply enjoy the magnificent view of the city’s coast from its wooden planks.

Venice is the ideal place for those who truly love great food. The city boasts every kind of dining you could possibly hope for including seafood by the sea, divine pub fare while out clubbing with the elite, authentic southern bbq, fine dining, and much more. But a city named Venice would not be complete without a healthy dose of America’s favorite Italian staple: pizza! When it comes to your ideal slice, you’re spoiled for choice in Venice. Choose from elegant Italian bistros with romantic décor, traditional trattorias complete with red and white checked tablecloths and a rustic ambiance, or a family-style mom and pop joint. Whatever your heart desires, you’re sure to find the ideal place for your perfect slice in Venice!

The best pizza in Venice: a local guide

A city named Venice wouldn’t seem right without access to a wide array of pizza styles to suit the tastes of every true pizza pie lover. But if there is one type of pizza this city claims as its own, it is the much-beloved New York-style. In keeping with the pizzas found in the Big Apple, Venice’s take on the New York-style pie includes the traditional crust with a thin, leathery bottom and a soft, billowy handle. Cut into large, triangular pieces, the ideal New York-style slice can be folded in half, making it the perfect lunch for people on the go.

Venice offers New York-style pies and slices in the classic type with a generous slathering of fragrant, sweet tomato sauce and salty, elastic mozzarella cheese, but you can also add as many toppings to this popular pizza as you like, customizing it to your own unique tastes. Buy it by the slice or the whole pie, from a street vendor, corner shopfront, or an upscale pizzeria; whatever you choose, Venice pizza will not disappoint.

Best Delivery Pizza in Venice

An elegant little spot with sophistication and flair, Made in Italy is the ideal place to enjoy a delicious slice for eat-in, takeout, or delivery. Nestled along West Venice Avenue in the heart of the city, Made in Italy takes great pride in serving handcrafted Italian fare. As the perfect complement to its delectable pies, the restaurant is also complete with a popular martini bar.

Made in Italy’s cuisine is hand prepared from the finest quality ingredients selected at the peak of their freshness. Their pizzas are cooked in wood-burning ovens to yield the perfect crust that is the ideal blend of crispy and smoky. Even the pastas at Made in Italy are handmade daily to ensure exceptional flavor, authenticity, and quality.

In business for more than five years, Made in Italy has become synonymous with excellent customer service, exquisite food, and exceptionally fast delivery. With a wide selection of true Italian classics to choose from, you’re spoiled for choice with the menu options on offer at this charming, upscale pizzeria.

For top-quality cuisine delivered at lightning-fast speeds, place your dinner order with Made in Italy today!

Best Takeout Pizza in Venice

Mama Maria’s Pizzeria and Subs earns top marks the best place for takeout pizza in Venice. Located in the heart of a popular strip mall, Mama Maria’s Pizzeria and Subs offers ample parking through its on-site lot. The décor found inside this small pizzeria is cozy and inviting. Its ambiance is warm and welcoming, making it the ideal spot to enjoy a quick slice or a family meal.

A pizzeria renowned for its excellent customer service and friendly staff, a visit to Mama Maria’s Pizzeria and Subs feels like a visit with an old familiar friend. The menu selections offer lots of variety with everything from pizza pies to calzones, salads, soups, subs, appetizers, and more available for in-house dining, takeout, or delivery. Among the most popular takeout options are the sauceless white roman pizza featuring olive oil, oregano, and a combination of Romano and mozzarella cheeses, the traditional antipasto platter, the broccoli and ricotta sub, and the steak bomb sub.

Feeling like a pie might hit the spot but too tired to sit through a meal in a restaurant? Not a problem! Let Slice do the work for you; place an order through Slice today for amazing takeout pizza from Mama Maria’s Pizzeria and Subs!

Best Pizza Near Venice


Only a short drive from Venice, you will discover one of Nokomis’ best-kept secrets: Cucina Gloria. This romantic trattoria has old-world style and flair and is the home of the best New York-style pizza in the region. The ideal spot for a romantic dinner for two, a family meal, or even just to grab a quick order to go, Cucina Gloria is well-renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine and intensely fresh flavors. Both vegan and vegetarian pizza options are available upon request.


For incredible pizza with unique flavor combinations, it is well worth the 12-mile drive to Bobarino’s Pizzeria in Englewood. The house specialty at Bobarino’s is Sicilian-style pizza available with a wide variety of different toppings. Choose from sizes starting at 10” and ranging as high as 18” for those feeding a crowd.

Bobarino’s Pizzeria has a wide set of menu selections to ensure something to suit the tastes of every member of the family. A dish that is not to be missed is Bobarino’s Special Sicilian, a pizza pie prepared on a double-thick crust and featuring green peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs.

Bobarino’s Pizzeria also offers several specialty toppings which can be added to your pizza for an additional cost. These include anchovies, roasted peppers, capicola, shrimp, provolone, feta, and ricotta cheese.


Village Pizzas by Emma is located 18 miles from Venice in Sarasota. This charming pizzeria proudly offers a wide array of authentic Italian fare prepared by hand from the finest quality ingredients. Pizza is the specialty of the house featuring a homemade dough and aromatic and sweet secret sauce cooked from vine-ripened tomatoes and a unique blend of fragrant herbs. Gluten-free crusts are available for those with sensitivities to gluten-based products.

Village Pizzas by Emma is pleased to offer outdoor dining, allowing you to enjoy the warmth of the sun while feasting on some of the region’s best pizza. For those looking for a little something to complement their slice, Village Pizzas by Emma also offers an excellent selection of appetizers, salads, and wings. Stop by to eat on the patio or place an order for takeout or delivery.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconFloridachevron right icon Pizza Places in Venice, FL