Top Pizza Restaurants in Winter Garden, FL Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Winter Garden: a local guide

The first-ever pizza restaurant in Florida was opened on Valentine’s Day in 1955 by an Italian man called Frank Pasquerella. This happened after Frank visited Miami with his wife for their honeymoon and instantly fell in love with the city. He then relocated from Ohio and opened a pizza restaurant called Frankie’s Pizza. Frankie’s Pizza introduced the square type pizza to Miami. The typical Sicilian style pizza has a thick crust and square shape. Sicilian style pizza is often topped with herbs, tomatoes, anchovies, and onions. Coupled with longevity, Frankie’s Pizza has withstood the test of time, and its influence is still very present today in the city. Frankie’s pizza is still regarded as one of the best pizzerias in Florida. It satisfies fans living miles away by offering unique “half-baked” pizzas that can be shipped all over the country. They have consistently preserved the traditions they started with, as everything is made from scratch daily. Their pizzas start with handmade dough and finish with the perfect crunch.

Best Delivery Pizza in Winter Garden

Italian Garden Pizzeria is an Italian restaurant in Winter Garden with the best brick-oven pies, subs, pasta, and pizza in a relaxed atmosphere. The classic cheese and Sicilian thick crust pizzas, which are favorites of many customers, are a gold standard of pizza in the whole City. Customers are given the option of choosing from classics or creating their pizza from various ingredients. New flavors of products are added from time to time to the already varied menu. There are also beverages like soda, milk, iced tea, and coffee available to help wash down your pizza. Italian Garden Pizzeria is a perfect destination for holiday dinners as the special seasonal menus are available depending on the holiday being celebrated. Place an order to satisfy your cravings and get good value for your money.

Best Takeout Pizza in Winter Garden

Winter Garden Pizza Company is a multiple award-winning Italian restaurant located right in the heart of Historic Downtown Winter Garden. They take advantage of the scenic atmosphere with their playful décor, offering New York style pizzas, pasta, calzones, and sandwiches. They take pride in providing healthy and quality food in a comfortable location. There are exciting vegan and gluten-free options available to serve the special needs of their customers. They even provide outside dining for customers with pets. Winter Garden Pizza brings the Italian flavor to Winter Garden by using fresh and tasty ingredients. They also have the best staff to complement their amazing atmosphere. The chefs are well trained, and the waiters are very responsive and prompt.

Best Pizza Near Winter Garden

Altamonte Springs

Altamonte Springs, 22 miles away from Winter Garden, is a city with about 41,000 people. It is known for its low tax rate and debt-free status, which it has successfully maintained over the years. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza features charred-crust pizza, subs, and classic Italian dishes in a modern setting. They offer any dining option you can think of, including lunch, dinner, catering, and dessert.


Stavro's and Sons Pizza, about 30 miles from Winter Garden, is a family restaurant in Eustis that has provided fresh homemade pizza, salads, and Italian dishes since 1974. They have a full menu with classic Greek, Mediterranean, and Italian dishes served in a warm atmosphere. Stavro's and Sons Pizza offers a wonderful assortment of pizza menus to choose from, like the Stavros Special Pizza and the Stavros Deluxe Pizza.

Mount Dora

Do you want amazing, family-style Italian dishes? Mount Dora Pizza & Subs is the perfect place for you. They offer fresh pizza, hearty subs, calzones, and pasta. Fresh, made-to-order food is prepared with great care. Their highly responsive, friendly service and amazing food are always a great combo for customers.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconFloridachevron right icon Pizza Places in Winter Garden, FL