Cumming, Georgia, is a northern suburb of Atlanta located near Lake Lanier. This is a smaller town, comprised almost entirely of a local community of families. Most folks live and work in Cumming, although some commute to the Atlanta Metro Area.

Because of its proximity to Lake Lanier, residents have a wide variety of beaches, parks, and other outdoor recreation available to them. Cumming also has a small but vibrant downtown area where most shops, restaurants, cafes, and pizzerias are located. The culinary scene in Cumming skews local, with a few high-end chain restaurants operating alongside numerous small businesses.

There is a vibrant pizza scene in Cumming, with many locally owned and operated shops in town. These are generally restaurants that feature classically-inspired pizza and Italian food. The vibe in Cumming’s restaurant scene favors no-frills, welcoming, and family-oriented settings. Approachability is valued highly in Cumming, and the town’s pizzerias showcase this.

Cumming is Known for New York-Style Pizza

New York City’s influence on pizza culture in America is monumental. Every town in the country has a pizzeria that uses the iconography, recipes, and baking methods that New York pizzerias made famous. Perhaps New York had a particularly frigid winter because driving around Cumming, you would assume dozens of pizza chefs got up and moved to Georgia for the warm weather! Numerous pizzerias reference New York’s pizza culture in everything from the restaurant name to menu items.

New York-style thin-crust is particularly popular in Cumming. You will even find pizza-by-the-slice, which is an iconic New York institution. It’s hard to argue with the straightforward and approachability of a slice of New York-style pizza. The crust is thick on the edge but thin and chewy towards the middle, with soft, melted mozzarella that blends perfectly with the tomato sauce. Folding a slice and taking a bite, you’re transported from Georgia to the five boroughs.

Best Delivery Pizza in Cumming

Five Boroughs Pizza Tavern directly references its New York City inspiration. Throughout its menu, you’ll find New York City name-drops for its exquisite pizza offerings. These pizzas have a thoughtful combination of toppings to accompany the New York-based names. The Greenwich Village Pizza is a notable option with grilled chicken, pesto, spinach, tomato, feta cheese, and sundried tomatoes. The Big Apple Pizza is big indeed, with just about every topping available packed onto this substantial pizza. All of these pizzas have a gluten-free cauliflower crust option.

The appetizers at Five Boroughs are absolutely must-try menu items. The Diavolo Peppers are made with a fiery sauce of red peppers, honey, and basil with goat cheese and crostini for dipping. The garlic knots are to die for, with Five Boroughs’ sweet and zesty marinara sauce on the side.

Best Takeout Pizza in Cumming

Alessio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Cumming is an outstanding local restaurant just outside downtown Cumming. This pizzeria focuses on classic Italian flavors in both their pizza and their exquisite menu of pasta entrees.

Try the White Tomato Basil Pizza if you want subtle, refined flavors. This is a traditional olive oil and garlic-based white pizza topped with sliced tomatoes and the freshest basil. If that sounds good, then get ready for their Margherita Pizza. It has all of your classic and familiar flavors and is prepared perfectly. The lightly charred thin-crust provides the right counterpoint to the sweet and tangy tomato sauce, fresh basil, and creamy mozzarella.

If you want a taste of Italy, try their Carbonara, Baked Ziti, or Ravioli. In need of something substantial? Try Mama’s Special Lasagna. All of these items are prepared to order and go perfectly with pizza and garlic knots for the whole family.

Best Pizza Near Cumming

Milton

Flippin Pizza’ in nearby Milton is a classic pizzeria focused on using hand-tossed pizza dough and the freshest ingredients to create traditional pizzas worthy of the word “authentic.” Their Tomato Basil Garlic Pie, which is a white pizza using 100% whole milk mozzarella, is topped with sliced Roma tomatoes, garlic, basil, and shaved pecorino romano. With this pie, the chefs at Flippin’ Pizza have accomplished their pursuit of recreating the flavors of Italy.

Alpharetta

Mangia Ristorante is an approachable pizzeria and restaurant that specializes in using classic Italian ingredients in creative ways to create specialty pies that will excite foodies and please purists. Try their extra-cheesy New Yorker Pizza with four different types of meat, tons of fresh veggies, and garlic. On the other hand, for a truly inspired creation, go for their Baked Ziti Pizza if you’re as obsessed with meatballs as their chefs. They also have a variety of outstanding white pizzas to choose from.

Buford

Italian Pie Pizza & Wings is a no-frills pizzeria located in nearby Buford. This is your typical neighborhood pizza joint serving up classic Italian and New York-inspired favorites. Try their traditional thin-crust pizza with cheese; you haven’t had a slice this good since your last visit to Manhattan! Their crispy calzones are to die for, especially if they are loaded with pepperoni and mozzarella and dipped in their homemade marinara.