Top Pizza Restaurants in Jacksonville, NC Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Jacksonville: a local guide

New York-style pizza originates in New York City and is a spin-off from Neapolitan pizza made in Italy. The pizza is baked in coal or wood-fired ovens, layered with low-moisture, shredded, full-fat mozzarella cheese, and a light layer of sauce under the cheese. You don't have to travel miles and miles into the big city when you can get the taste of the best NY pizza in Jacksonville.
The water used to make the New York pizza dough should ideally come from New York. The specific minerals in that water are said to change the crust’s taste subtly. The crust itself is thin, crispy, and full of flavor. The middle of the pizza is firm yet pliable in order to fold it for eating. New York pizza is served by the slice or as a whole pie, and the slices are enormous. With high-quality cheese, rich tomato sauce, and the toppings of your choosing, what’s not to like?

Best Delivery Pizza in Jacksonville

When you don’t feel like cooking, order delivery from BPW'S. If you happen to walk in, you'll be pleased to find a small, simple seating area. The restaurant walls are decorated with local art and football memorabilia that combine flawlessly to provide an element of comfort. At BPW'S, you get delicious meals served with a friendly attitude. The staff is always welcoming and professional. If you like to see your meal being prepared, catch a glimpse by looking just past the front counter.
The food served at BPW'S is excellent all around. You won’t be disappointed with your delivery order from here with their tasty calzones, large wings that are crisp yet tender, and their authentic pizzas. Their pizzas are prepared with a golden crust and topped with a generous amount of toppings. The menu has a great selection of items to suit your preference. You will get perfect thick, chewy Sicilian pizza or a tailor-made thin, crispy New York-style pizza.

Best Takeout Pizza in Jacksonville

Cicis Pizza is a family-oriented restaurant that guarantees you delicious pizza without having to break the bank. Located along Western Boulevard, its location makes it a coveted takeout point. A unique feature here is the attractive buffet option that allows you to taste different pizza styles for less. You might fall in love with this restaurant for its food and customer service. They will consistently deliver the best of both worlds with excellent staff and management. Takeout orders come out quickly, and the pickup process is easy. Cicis has a varied menu with tons of different types of pizza. You can get stuffed crust pizza, flatbread pizza, pan pizzas, and New York-style pizzas all from one place. Why not try something different? Order their Zesty Ham and Cheddar Pizza. With a crust brushed with garlic butter that will melt in your mouth and zesty parmesan ranch sauce, you can’t go wrong. They also have sides like wings and dipping sauce as well as desserts.

Best Pizza Near Jacksonville

New Bern

New Bern is a city in Craven County offering residents a refreshing sense of community. The city has a calm and quiet atmosphere in a more rural setting. Mario’s Pizza is a great start if you need pizza in New Bern. From authentic thin-crust New York-style pizza to buttery and cheesy garlic knots and delicious cheesesteak sandwiches or calzones, their menu caters to all your cravings.


Kinston is located in Lenoir County, northwest of Jacksonville. The small city has been revitalizing over the past few years, but it continues to have some great pizza. You can always rely on Sugar Hill Pizzeria when it comes to pizza. Adorned with homey wood accents, they serve perfect crust pizza with numerous toppings and a rich homemade sauce. Pizzas are served by the slice or as a whole pie. Additionally, you can order one of the best gluten-free meat lover's pizzas here.

North Topsail Beach

North Topsail Beach is a small city in the heart of Pender County, southwest of Jacksonville. Home to one of the most undiscovered beaches in North Carolina, it’s a wonderful tourist spot if you like to avoid crowds. Beach Bum’s Pizza Bar & Grill is a breezy pub serving pizzas in a relaxed outdoor setting. Located close to the beach, the restaurant provides a range of perfectly crisp pizzas layered with melty cheese and in-house sauce alongside a cold cocktail. A classic combination for a relaxed day at the beach!

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNorth Carolinachevron right icon Pizza Places in Jacksonville, NC