When considering the pizza scene in the northeast, New York City is usually the first place that comes to mind, but New Jersey is home to a city called Brick that has its own pizza culture. In fact, the oldest pizzeria in New Jersey is still standing today and has been open since 1912. At its origin, the pizza scene entered the Brick area with a classic Italian tomato pie. This unique type of pizza is made in a quadrilateral shape with the toppings and cheese underneath the sauce rather than on top of it, though New Jersey has created its own local variation. Though the city of Brick offers a variety of local pizzerias, they have far less chain pizza restaurants. This is because they attempt to keep their pizza in the authentic New Jersey tomato pie style, and there is clear favoritism towards rustic preparation in low to moderate-class settings.
The most popular type of pizza in the Brick area is the Trenton (or New Jersey) tomato pie. It got its name from the first tomato pie establishment that opened in 1910 in the city of Trenton. This pizza preparation is in direct contrast with its Italian counterpart in that it features a circular, thin crust, but it maintains the Italian layering of the toppings on the bottom and sauce on top. Compared to the nearby New York, this moderately sized town in the Garden State has a much smaller selection of pizzerias, but they are often well-loved and protect their craft. There is a noticeable preference for not only tomato pies but also oven-fired pizzas, as they are featured at most of their pizzerias. Plus, nearly all of their pizza venues offer delivery because of the city’s manageable size, so people are able to enjoy a classic local tomato pie in any of Brick’s neighborhoods.
Located just north of Lake Riviera, LG’s Pizza & Pasta has a menu that spans several pages and contains a variety of items. These include different types of pizzas, including gourmet, grandma, Sicilian, and square-cut, though oddly they do not offer the quintessential tomato pie. They also have a wide variety of toppings available to customize your own, including some seafood toppings and even a mac and cheese pizza. Other than the pizza, their chicken-based dishes seem to be among the fan favorites. Aside from their vast menu, they offer delivery for only $2 on top of a $10 minimum. The relatively small interior has a casual setting, though most opt for their delivery or takeout services. They have over 1000 Slice reviews and they are one of the most popular pizzerias that offers delivery in the entire Brick area. Plus, they offer numerous deals and specials that are very family-friendly.
Azzurro Pizzeria & Italian Grill may be located on a street with a long stretch of Italian restaurants, but it has soared to the top of the competition with its wide variety of pizzas, sandwiches, pastas, and house specialties. Their dishes range from low to moderately priced, which makes it perfect for people on a budget. They have many affordable specials and catering options. They also offer many customizable options, including toppings and some that are gluten-free. Because it has been open for over 30 years, it has gained an upstanding reputation among locals. Their pizzas and sandwiches are the most popular and readily available for takeout. Even though it is located in a shopping plaza, the exterior is simple and well-maintained. The interior has a modern, tasteful atmosphere, with much of the kitchen being visible in the dining room. Their other entrees and dishes have impeccable presentation, and the restaurant is a local fan-favorite.
Located near Trenton, Papa’s Tomato Pies is the oldest and most famous family-run pizza place in not just New Jersey, but in the entire United States. It has been open since 1912, and is the most famous for its traditional tomato pies and their very own mustard pie. This unique specialty pie is made with spicy brown mustard that is baked into the crust and topped with cheese and tomato, and all their pizzas are customizable.
In close proximity to the Manasquan River, Little Mia’s Pizza II is a very popular restaurant that features primarily delivery and takeout. They offer many Italian dishes for lunch and dinner, along with more vegetarian options than most local Italian establishments. They offer moderate pricing, and their Sicilian pizza is one of their most-ordered items. Having fresh ingredients is a major selling point among their clientele, especially when it comes to pizza dough and toppings.
Medusa Stone Fired Kitchen is situated near the oceanfront on the upper east side of New Jersey and is an incredibly upscale establishment. They have a seasonal menu and are most known for their meals made in an authentic wood burning oven. There is a beautiful selection of gourmet pizzas, including a vegan pizza loaded with vegetables and another with all local mushrooms. Additionally, they have fresh soups, salads, and sandwiches available for delivery or takeout.
Q: 🍕What Restaurant Has the Best Stuffed Crust Pizza in Brick?
Q: 🍕What Restaurant Has the Best New York Pizza in Brick?
Q: 🍕What Restaurant Has the Best Sicilian Pizza in Brick?
Q: 🍕What Restaurant Has the Best Grandma Pizza in Brick?