If you want to try different pizza styles, head to East Brunswick, and you won't be disappointed. The town makes delicious New York-style, Sicilian, New Jersey-style, Grandma, and deep-dish pizzas. However, Grandma Pizza is the leading light in East Brunswick since it's the most ordered pizza in many pizzerias. Grandma pizza was first prepared in East Brunswick in 1979 when Brothers Pizza was opened by Italian immigrants who wanted to share their traditional fare. Nowadays, you can order the dish from most pizzerias around town, and the meal will be delightful. Grandma pizza emerged from Long Island, New York, where Italian American housewives prepared it at home because they wanted to make Sicilian pizzas but didn't have proper pizza ovens. Grandma pizza has a thin crust which is topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The pizza is prepared either in square or rectangular pans coated with olive oil. It is cooked in a regular oven. When you order a Grandma pizza, it is cut into square slices. It also has a more pungent garlic taste than a Sicilian pizza. Make sure you try it when you visit East Brunswick.

Best Delivery Pizza in East Brunswick, New Jersey

Michelangelo's Pizza is an East Brunswick's treasure that serves the town, the South River, and nearby areas. The locals have enjoyed exceptional service and food from the pizzeria for over 15 years. In 2003, Michelangelo's Pizza was voted the Best Thin-crust Pizza in the East Village NY City Festival. The restaurant serves homemade creations prepared by skilled chefs using fresh and high-quality ingredients. You should try a delivery order of Michelangelo's Special Neapolitan Pizza to enjoy one of the pizzeria’s best sellers. You will get a tantalizing taste of mushrooms, pepperoni, peppers, and sausage. You can also try something different like the Meat Lover's Neapolitan Pizza, with five meat toppings. If you want a few slices instead of a whole pizza, Michelangelo's Pizza has got you covered. The variety of slices is great when you can’t decide on a single pizza topping. Remember to add a salad to complete the order, and Michelangelo’s offers an enticing chef salad dressed with provolone, ham, and turkey.

Best Takeout Pizza in East Brunswick, New Jersey

You can grab a quick takeout order from Giddy's Pizzeria in East Brunswick, and whatever you order will be heavenly. The pizzeria opened in 2014, and it has been serving mouth-watering pizza ever since. The menu is extensive, and they offer almost everything you would expect in a pizzeria. If you prefer something other than pizza, you can try their seafood dishes such as fish and chips, served with tartar sauce and fries. For your next family meal, you can order off the kid's menu with options like the Kid’s Mac and Cheese, a favorite no matter your age or even the Kid's Baked Ziti. The highlight of any takeout order from Giddy's Pizzeria has to be the pizza. Their Margherita Pizza on a thin Sicilian crust is topped with basil pesto, parmesan, fresh garlic, and mozzarella. The basil pesto has pine nuts to enhance the flavor. You can also opt for the local's favorite of Grandma Pizza to further enhance your order. Giddy’s also does deep-dish pizza if the Sicilian and Grandma options don’t tempt you.

Best Pizza Near East Brunswick

South River

The town of South River lies roughly two miles from East Brunswick, and it's a perfect place to enjoy Italian cuisine. J&J Restaurant & Pizzeria offers some of the best pizzas in town. Order a Caesar Salad Pizza for something unique. It has grilled chicken, romaine, croutons, and Caesar dressing. It’s the perfect way to make pizza “healthy”. Another great menu item is the J&J Famous Special Pizza, which will arrive almost overloaded with meat and veggie toppings. The restaurant also serves some special dishes such as Chicken and Eggplant Parmigiana.

Sayreville

If you don't mind driving about four miles northeast of East Brunswick to Sayreville, then you should visit the town and sample some of the pizzas offered at Rustoni's Pizza. The pizzeria has over ten gourmet pizzas which you can customize when making a takeout or delivery order. Rustoni's Pizza serves flavorsome pan pizzas with interesting toppings. The chicken alone comes in a variety of flavor profiles. You can get in on a pizza with BBQ sauce, lemon and wine sauce, ranch dressing, or buffalo sauce.

North Brunswick Township

Leone's Trattoria is a hidden gem in North Brunswick Township, serving delectable Italian food to the locals and visitors. The pizzeria has chefs with over 30 years of experience in pizza-making, and they ensure every order is prepared to perfection. You can find tasty appetizers to start your order with, and the Mozzarella in Carroza Francaise Style is the most popular in the restaurant. You can request a Sicilian pizza or New York-style pizza with plentiful toppings combined for you or ones you choose yourself.