Elizabeth, a city on the outskirts of the Big Apple, has a long tradition of pizza culture. With many different varieties of pizza from which to choose, one type reigns supreme in this eclectic city: tomato pie. Elizabeth is the birthplace of this unique type of pizza and bears the distinction of being home base for the first two operations to proudly offer this type of pie on their menus.

Tomato pie is a unique type of pizza. Its hand-stretched crust is pulled until it becomes very thin. Once the crust is the correct thinness, it is topped with a generous helping of well-crushed garlic. A house-made tomato sauce comprised of imported tomatoes from the motherland and a secret blend of aromatic spices is generously ladled over the garlic which is then topped with mozzarella cheese. The final flourish includes an additional layer of sauce and the selected toppings.

A city with a population base largely comprised of young, working families, Elizabeth’s pizzerias are quite varied, including traditional eat-in establishments with a diner atmosphere, food trucks, and hidden treasures reminiscent of true Italian trattorias full of elegance and charm.

De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies, a charming eatery proudly displaying the traditional red and white checked tablecloths and authentic Italian fare, was founded in 1947. A family-run restaurant, De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies traces its roots to the De Lorenzo family, immigrants from South Italy who made their way to America in the early 20th century. Today, the business has expanded to include several different mom and pop-style locations in both New Jersey and Pennsylvania, but one thing has remained the same: De Lorenzo’s menu still proudly features the tomato pies that have made their restaurant—and their state—famous.

Best Delivery Pizza in Elizabeth

For a truly unique pizza experience, you can’t go wrong with a visit to Piezano’s Pizza Kitchen. Located on the corner of the quaint downtown core of Elizabeth, Piezano’s Pizza Kitchen has a crisp, modern feel inside its small interior. Its services include indoor dining, takeout, and delivery.

Piezano’s Pizza Kitchen offers a wide sampling of Italian fare on its menu including several types of pizza: Sicilian, stuffed crust, gourmet, and New Jersey’s favorite tomato pie. Its specialty is a hand-stretched, paper-thin crust, a true delight for the senses that is good to the very last bite.

In addition to its pies, Piezano’s Pizza Kitchen is also pleased to offer custom-made pastas and sandwiches to suit the tastes of even the most discerning diner. Fan favorites include the Sicilian, thin-crust Grandpa pizza, the Chicken Franchese pizza, the Roman stuffed pizza, and the chicken marsala. There is also a wide variety of starters available for indoor dining, takeout, or delivery.

For prompt delivery of some of the city’s most delicious pizza, you’ll want to keep Piezano’s Pizza Kitchen’s phone number on speed dial.

Best Takeout Pizza in Elizabeth

Mikey’s Famous Pizzeria is located in a busy strip mall in Elizabeth. This modern restaurant has been operating under a new management team since 2014. Though its ownership has changed, its high quality and flavorful Italian cuisine has remained the same.

Mikey’s Famous Pizzeria’s interior is both clean and spartan with a generous number of tables for indoor dining. A restaurant renowned for fresh ingredients, exceptional service, and friendly staff, picking up takeout from Mikey’s is guaranteed to be an efficient and pleasant experience.

In addition to its pizzas, Mikey’s Famous Pizzeria’s menu offers a full complement of pastas, calzones, strombolis, salads, sandwiches, and more. One of the restaurant’s most popular offerings is its hero sandwiches, available in a wide array of different meat, cheese, and veggie combinations.

With an interesting and eclectic selection of pizza names, you’re going to want to order takeout more often to get your chance to sample such rare treats as the Fat Bastard, the Chicken Cordon Blue, Mikey’s Famous, and the Fat Albert.

Use Slice today to place an order for one of Elizabeth’s best pizzas at Mikey’s Famous Pizzeria.

Best Pizza Near Elizabeth

Roselle

A quiet, friendly suburban town, Roselle is less than three short miles from the heart of Elizabeth. For top-shelf pizza that will keep you coming back for more, you won’t want to miss the chance to sample the wares at Joe’s Rotisseria. Now a much-cherished New Jersey tradition, Joe’s Rotisseria is renowned for its Triple Threat, a unique combination that includes pizza, garlic knots, and a calzone, all in one delicious dish.

Joe’s Rotisseria takes great pride in its unusual flair, combining eclectic topping combinations with large portion sizes and a touch of the wild side in its approach to cuisine. Your taste buds will thank you for taking the time to stop by Joe’s, whether you sample a slice or take on the Triple Threat. With over 50 different types of pizzas and several crusts to choose from, you’ll be spoiled for choice with Joe’s menu which also includes sandwiches, starters, pastas, salads, and rotisserie chicken.

Hillside

Only a short 3-mile drive from the heart of Elizabeth is the town of Hillside, a charming residential community that is abuzz with young families and busy lifestyles. Among the best places to enjoy a pizza in Hillside is Comet, a delightful little mom-and-pop pizzeria that is big on charm and whose specialty includes authentic New York-style pizza. Stop by for a pie, pasta, salad, or sandwich in the spacious dining area, or grab a slice to take with you while on the go. Comet is a fully licensed establishment for those who fancy a glass of wine or a cocktail to accompany their dinner.

Linden

Only four miles away from Elizabeth is Linden, a town that combines the best of life in the suburbs with that big city vibe. If you find yourself hankering for a tasty slice during your trip to Linden, you’ll want to take a page out of the locals’ book and head straight to Pasquale’s Pizzeria IV. Pasquale’s Pizzeria IV is located within a strip mall. Its décor is warm and inviting with a tavern-like feel. There is ample comfortable seating for in-house dining, but takeout and delivery are also available.

Pasquale’s Pizzeria IV offers a full menu featuring pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, salads, and much, much more. Among its most popular offerings are the Buffalo Wings Pizza, the Vodka with Fried Chicken Pizza, and the Grilled Chicken Caesar Sicilian Pizza. There is a bountiful selection of appetizers from which to choose, and pizza is available by the pie or the slice.