Top Pizza Restaurants in Livingston, NJ Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Livingston: a local guide

The Trenton tomato pie, also known as New Jersey tomato pie, is one of the old-school, classic New Jersey pizza styles. It originated in Trenton back in 1910 at Joe’s Tomato Pie and has greatly evolved and spread across the country ever since. It has a relatively thin crust and is round. The pieces are cut in squares and rectangles instead of the typical triangular slices of New York-style pizza. The tomato pie really focuses on the tomato sauce, often with only a dusting of mozzarella, and the sauce is placed on top of the cheese. It is usually served lukewarm with a soft bottom. Although a topping of mozzarella and tomato sauce is traditional, most pizzerias in Livingston encourage diners to add their own spin to the tomato pie in the form of additional toppings. Remember, all those extra toppings will go directly on the dough with the cheese and then be covered in sauce.

Best Delivery Pizza in Livingston

Pizzeta Enoteca is a family-friendly restaurant in the heart of Livingston. Pizza Enoteca is a cornerstone in the Livingston area and has been known for its outstanding pizza, excellent service, and friendly staff over the years. They offer pizza with the best ingredients and give customers the option of making their own pizza to taste. The pizza options at Pizzeta Enoteca range from the Classic Pizza to the Four Seasons Pizza, which contains artichokes, tomatoes, basil, and mushrooms. You can leave the classic as is with just cheese and mozzarella, or you can build your pizza on this flavorful base.

Order an appetizer from Pizzeta Enoteca to start your meal off on the right foot. Try the Bruschetta, Baked Clams, or Nonna’s Meatballs. With any of these, you won’t be disappointed. Soup, salad, and sandwiches round out their diverse menu nicely. Peruse the options and place your order today!

Best Takeout Pizza in Livingston

The pizza at Calabria Restaurant Bar and Pizzeria is what pizza lovers call phenomenal. They prepare the pizzas with locally grown Italian-inspired ingredients. Calabria Restaurant Bar and Pizzeria has been open for over four decades, and their fantastic food and atmosphere continue to draw customers across generations. This is not to say that their success is based on nostalgia alone, as their hand-made pizzas have remained one of the best in Livingston year after year.

Calabria’s Sausage Pizza topped with classic cheese and sausage is essential in your dining experience. Creativity abounds with each pie cooked in Calabria’s brick oven, including the Pizzetta Dino, with ingredients like prosciutto, arugula, mozzarella, and shaved Reggiano. You can also get your pizza gluten-free.

Although it might seem that all they do is pizza, that's not the case. Calabria features other tasty options like calzones, salads, and sandwiches. When you order takeout from here, you certainly won’t go hungry.

Best Pizza Near Livingston

West Orange

West Orange, home of renowned inventor Thomas Edison, is a suburban township in Essex County, New Jersey, with a proud community heritage. Frank’s Pizza serves pizza and other classic Italian dishes in a casual, old-fashioned setting. It is a restaurant where tourists visit either for slices or whole pies. Pizza lovers everywhere need to give their stuffed pizza a chance, but if you’re not up for it, the Sicilian pizza slice is a sure bet.

Short Hills

You can find high-quality pizza at Brooklyn Pizza in Short Hills, where fresh, local ingredients are prioritized, and the crust is treated with the utmost care. Customers will find updated takes on old-school pizza classics from Italy. This innovation is what keeps guests coming back for more. The Brooklyn Grandma pizza made up of mozzarella cheese, olive oil, and basil is a popular choice with the regulars.

East Hanover

Just three miles from Livingston, East Hanover is a township in Morris County, New Jersey. The Godfather Brick Oven Pizzeria is a popular family-friendly spot that draws a following for serving its signature brick-oven pizza and counter-service Italian fare. They have gluten-free and cauliflower crusts so there’s something for everyone here. Some guests take the dough home to try making pizza themselves, but it might not be easy to perfectly replicate the pizzas made by their skilled staff.

show more iconSee More


Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in Livingston, NJ