Located along the shores of its namesake, the Millstone River, Millstone, NJ, is a township well-known for its rich history in relation to the Civil War and past presidents. In the late 1800s, mass immigration began from Italy to the United States, and many immigrants settled in New Jersey, making Italians the single largest ethnic group in the state. As can be imagined, these proud working-class new citizens brought their own history and many wonderful traditions with them, including treasured family recipes from the old country. These recipes have been passed down for current generations to enjoy through family-owned pizzerias and bakeries throughout the region.

Whether you crave the light, chewy crust of the Sicilian, the local favorite Trenton tomato pie, or the tried-and-true classic Neapolitan pizza, you'll find authentic Italian cuisine in spades at the numerous local pizzerias in Millstone. In fact, many of these pizzerias have been owned and operated by the same families for decades.

Millstone is Known for New Jersey Tomato Pie Pizza

The unique Trenton-style tomato pie pizza is what made New Jersey famous for its pizza. Hand-crafted and baked to the ideal crisp texture in specialty wood-fired brick pizza ovens, Trenton tomato pie (also known as New Jersey tomato pie) is a truly distinct slice of Italian flavor. It differs most obviously from the traditional square, deep-dish Philadelphia and New York-style tomato pies with its round shape and thin, flaky crust. What also makes this local-favorite unique is that its zesty, aromatic sauce is layered on top of the cheese and toppings, resulting in a savory and memorable culinary experience.

While Trenton-style tomato pie is the local favorite in the township of Millstone, New Jersey is a true melting-pot of pizza types, thanks to its strong Italian-American roots, and it's not uncommon to find that each pizzeria puts its own distinctive spin on tradition.

Best Delivery Pizza in Millstone

Step into Tre Colore Pizzeria & Restaurant in Millstone, and you’ll feel immediately as if you’ve been transported to a charming Italian cafe with its elegant yet casual atmosphere. Located just off Highway 33, this family-owned and operated pizzeria combines 50 years of restaurant experience with the freshest and highest quality ingredients to bring to you a culinary experience you won't soon forget. Offering everything from delicious entrees to authentic pasta, fresh salads, and tempting calzones, their pizza is the real stand-out.

Choose from Traditional, Sicilian, Pan, or Grandma-style crust; Tre Colore's pizzas can be piled high with the toppings of your choosing. Or try one of their tasty gourmet pizza selections, such as their Lasagna Pizza, Salad Pizza, or Cheese Steak Pizza, for a truly unique creation. Whatever pizza you choose to order, one thing is for sure - you’ll get the best delivery pizza Millstone has to offer!

Best Takeout Pizza in Millstone

At Vesuvio’s Pizza & Family Restaurant, you’ll experience the best of old-world Italian flavor. As soon as you walk through the doors, you'll sense the old-world charm permeating the rustic stone and timber-frame interior. Nick, the founder, was born and raised in Naples, Italy, and has worked in the restaurant business since he was 11 years old. Vesuvio’s Pizza & Family Restaurant is a local favorite for its 30-year pizza-making tradition combined with only the best ingredients. It’s the founder’s dream come true to bring the taste of Naples to America.

Vesuvio’s prides itself on serving generous portions of authentic Italian fare at affordable prices, making it a popular family spot. Vesuvio’s Pizza has the best Neapolitan pizza around. Try the Grandma pizza for something different, or the traditional Old Fashioned Margherita for something classic and flavorful. Their extensive menu also contains delectable appetizers, salads, and dinner entrees.

Best Pizza Near Millstone

Jackson Township

Jackson Township, just south of Millstone, is home to the expansive Six Flags Great Adventure amusement park. It’s also home to some of the greatest pizza you’ll ever taste at Fusaro’s Pizza. Serving fresh, authentic Italian comfort food, Fusaro’s combines old-world family traditions with truly innovative pizza creations. From their Grandma-style pizza to their simple yet perfect Margherita pizza to their stromboli, calzones, and other traditional Italian dishes, Fusaro's has become a local favorite for consistently exceeding expectations.

Hillsborough

About 30 miles north of Millstone is the township of Hillsborough, home to the history-burdened Belle Mead General Depot, and today the hometown of many proud Italian-Americans. Among countless delicious local pizzerias, Bella's Pizza easily garners 5-star ratings for their top-secret recipe sauce, homemade dough, and wide range of fresh toppings available to customize your pizza. Or try one of their customer-favorite specialty pizzas. There’s no doubt about one thing: you'll be back for more soon!

Skillman

Directly northwest of Millstone, you’ll find the town of Skillman and Genteel’s Brick Oven Pizza & Ristorante. Located conveniently just off of Highway 206, Genteel's offers a casual environment, warm and friendly service, and has truly perfected the art of brick-oven pizza-making. Featuring a delectably crisp crust, plenty of bubbly cheese, and an array of colorful toppings, it's hard to go back to regular chain pizza after sampling a slice that's been baked in an authentic brick pizza oven.