Top Pizza Restaurants in Newton, NJ Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Newton: a local guide

If you are looking for a truly unique type of pizza, then the Trenton Tomato Pie is a great option. This is a unique pizza that will include some of the traditional toppings that you want, like mozzarella cheese and sauce, but the cheese will go on the bottom and the sauce is on top.

This pie is going to be created in a circular shape and will come in a thin crust. For those who are fans of the thin crust, this is one of the best options to choose. It will also rely on mozzarella cheese to give it some of the flavor that you are looking for. Customers can choose to add on some other toppings if they like, but plain cheese and sauce are the most common options.

Best Delivery Pizza in Newton

When you want some great pizza and wings to take home for the game or after a long night of work, then you need to check out Max and Leo’s right away. Everything is perfect about the pizza that you can get here. They have many special pizzas that you can’t get anywhere else, along with some classics that will become your favorite in no time.

One thing that many customers enjoyed was all of the flavor that comes with it. The bottom of the pizza is crisp and has a light charcoal taste that makes it more authentic than any pizza you can make at home. You can also create your own pizza out of their always fresh ingredients at any time that you would like. Add some wings and a few drinks to the order to complete the meal.

Best Takeout Pizza in Newton

While there are many takeout restaurants that are sure to impress in Newton, we have to say that one of our favorites is Sweet Tomatoes Pizza. They offer delivery, takeout, and curbside delivery for all of your needs when you really want that pizza.

They do offer some of the traditional options for pizzas, but there are a few unique ones that you may want to try too. Pesto Splash and Buffalo Chicken were raved about by other customers and you can choose to add some soups or calzones to the mix too.

The biggest issue is the seating if you want a night out. But for those getting takeout, this is not a big deal. You can choose to get pizza by the slice or even half and half pizzas to satisfy everyone at the table. The staff is friendly and you will truly enjoy your experience.

Best Pizza Near Newton

Bradley Beach

If you are in the Bradley Beach area, then you need to check out Vic’s Italian American Restaurant. This place is packed on the weekend and they have the best pizzas and drink selection in the area. This is more for the traditional crowd, but the soft and crispy crust and great toppings will quickly make this one of your favorite spots. You will never leave this spot feeling hungry when you are done.


When you want a family-owned business with some of the best in specialty pizzas, then Federici’s Family Italian Restaurant is the place to stop when you are in the Freehold area. This company specializes in thin-crust pizza that you will love. And the long list of available pizzas on the menu will almost make your head spin. There are also other homemade Italian dishes for customers to choose from to get something that is tasty and easy in this area.

New Jersey it’s

You can’t come to New Jersey and not try Papa’s Tomato Pie. This is one of the oldest pizza restaurants in the country so it is worth a stop on your list. The tomato pies are some of the best and rank in the top of the best tomato pies in the whole area. This is an old-school, high-quality pizza restaurant and it is a shame to miss it if you are in the Robbinsville area for vacation or passing through.

show more iconSee More


Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in Newton, NJ