Top Pizza Restaurants in North Arlington, NJ Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in North Arlington: a local guide

North Arlington is a small area close to New York, making it a cozy hometown for families. It was founded in 1896, but the settlement existed earlier. At the beginning of the 18th century, copper and ore were mined here, which were sold to England. Initially, the Dutch settled here, who arrived by ships from Amsterdam, rooting their customs and traditions. Then the place became popular among the Irish, Polish, and later Italians. The first pizzerias appeared here in the 1960s, offering Sicilian, Neapolitan, and New York-style pizzas. These days restaurants with a dine-in experience are popular here. People like to gather with their friends and families when they have time after work and on the weekends to share pizza and drinks. Also, delivery and takeout services are very common. According to Money Magazine, in 2017, the town was one of the best places to live. It has everything for a calm, safe, and happy life: good schools, shops, cafes, restaurants, and most importantly, a developed infrastructure that allows people to get to their workplaces quickly and comfortably.

North Arlington is known for Neapolitan Pizza

Neapolitan pizza is a real treasure from the historical center of Italy – Naples, but it also became a real gem of North Arlington. The local pizzerias use an old classic recipe for this dish that includes products typical of the Mediterranean region and imported to the US. Among them: sun-poured tomatoes, flavored olives, and aromatic cheeses. Baked on a thin flatbread, they conquer the tastes of local gourmets.
The quintessential Neapolitan pizza is the Margherita. With cheese and basil, plum tomatoes, or marinara sauce, and a drizzle of olive oil, what’s not to love? The dough-making methods and the composition of the fillings might sometimes be changed and supplemented at the chef’s discretion. But all Neapolitan pizzas should use flour from Napoli and Italian olive oil, making the crust as authentic as possible. Neapolitan pizzas require a wood-fired oven to reach the necessary high temperatures to cook them properly. The pizza comes out with a slight charring cooked to perfection.

Best Delivery Pizza in North Arlington

Ferazzoli’s Italian Kitchen is a small local pizzeria that makes the best value for money pizza for delivery in North Arlington. They offer their customers delicious, aromatic pizza made of fresh ingredients. The choice of pizza is excellent; 13 specialty items, including mostly classic options, are also available in a gluten-free crust. For dessert lovers, they have created a special delightful Nutella Pizza, which you can also buy in slices. But their hit is a Grandma Pie made in a pan oiled with extra virgin olive oil, covered with a homemade delicious red sauce, and topped with 100% natural classic cheese. Besides great pizza, Ferazzoli’s has hot and cold paninis, dinner entrees, and pasta dishes. They are known around town for good customer service, polite staff, and fast delivery. The next time you need delivery in North Arlington, opt for Ferazzoli’s Italian Kitchen.

Best Takeout Pizza in North Arlington

Nonna Lisa Pizza is a fabulous spot for takeout in North Arlington. Popular with locals after a busy work week, this casual pizzeria has something for everyone. Pizza is the restaurant’s main attraction, and they do everything from New York-style to Sicilian to Grandma pizza. For those who need it, they also do gluten-free pizza as well. The Grandma Pizza is a top choice with mozzarella, basil, and fresh marinara sauce on a square crust. If you prefer our pizza with a kick, the Grandpa Pizza is a spicier version of the Grandma Pizza. This restaurant offers great value and an extensive menu beyond pizza. Homemade baked pasta is a great option for someone who doesn’t want pizza. The Lasagna and Eggplant Parmigiana are especially good. Additional menu items include soups, calzones, and burgers. See for yourself everything Nonna Lisa’s has to offer the next time you need to place a takeout order.

Best Pizza near North Arlington


A 1 Pizza is a cozy pizzeria on Ridge Road in Lyndhurst that serves the best pizza in town. They have managed to gain a reputation as a place with authentic Italian food at affordable prices. Here you can have lunch or dinner, gather with friends over a fragrant pizza, or order delivery when you are at home and don't want to bother in the kitchen. All their pizzas are made from fresh dough, homemade sauces, and topped with fresh ingredients.


Belleville Pizza is a local casual pizzeria that offers the best pizza in Belleville. The assortment of pizza options is quite big, with about 30 different combinations and the opportunity to add additional ingredients yourself. Also, you can make your own pizza from selective ingredients suitable to your taste. From the dough base to the sauces to the size of the pie, this place is a winner. Belleville Pizza always makes their pizza fresh using only high-quality ingredients. The venue is suitable for dining in and has other service options, including curbside pickup.


Luna Wood Fire Tavern is a family-owned pizzeria that offers the best pizza and other Italian dishes in the center of Nutley. Their sophisticated pizza satisfies all the requirements of the most demanding customers from all over the area. Their pizzas are made in a wood-fired oven and are well-done to a perfect golden brown. Besides traditional Neapolitan-style pizza, there are also three options of Sicilian pizza and a range of extra toppings.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in North Arlington, NJ