Traditional pies have been the order of the day since the township got its first pizzeria so Nutley is known for thick crust pizza. In truth, the pizzerias in Nutley don't stray far from making what are authentic Italian pizzas, so you're always going to get a great pie no matter where you go. Whether they use recipes handed down through their families is a question which can't be answered unless you ask the pizzeria chefs yourself when you’re there. It's a good guess that many do use family recipes to bake their thick crust. Thick crust is an Italian pizza that's been around forever and some form of passing on secrets about pizzas through the generations is more than likely to have happened, but as they're secrets, it's hard to find out just what. The only thing that is certain is that the thick crust pizzas you get in Nutley will be some of the best, if not the very best, in New Jersey.

Best delivery pizza in Nutley, New Jersey

When you want the best delivery pizza in Nutley, you need to order from a pizzeria that has extensive experience in baking pies. You'll find one such pizzeria is Amore Pizza by Jack Calandra where they've been knocking out great pies for over twenty-five years. Amore Pizza has a premises on Center Street which is a home from home for many of their customers who drop by regularly for a slice of pie. Amore Pizza don't just bake pizza; they pour all their love of Italian food into each pie whether it's a round one, a tray-baked grandma-style, or their house special, a heart-shaped pizza. If you're ordering in a pizza because you're having a quiet night in with your better half, order the heart-shaped pizza from Amore with their favorite toppings and it won't fail to impress.

Best takeout pizza in Nutley, New Jersey

If you've been hiking the trails in the Yanticaw Park with the kids and they're moaning they're hungry and can't wait to eat until they get home, don't go crazy. You're one block away from being able to pick up the best take-out pizza in Nutley. Head for North Franklin Avenue and you'll come across a pizzeria called Luna Wood Fired Tavern. Luna Wood Fire Tavern is a pretty smart place, so if the kids are all muddied up and old enough to be left alone for five minutes you might want to leave them in the car while you go get the pizza. If not, sneak them through the smoked-glass doors and sit them among the plants at the rear of the dining area. Whatever pizza you order to take out from here will be baked in a wood-fired oven, so expect a little charring on the crust. That's normal on a wood-fired oven pie and adds to the overall flavor.

Best pizza near Nutley, New Jersey

East Hanover

If you want a great day out with the family without going too far, make a trip twenty miles northwest of Nutley to East Hanover. There are some super activities in East Hanover the kids will really enjoy. Start out with a visit to Imagine That! which is an indoor play area designed to inspire creativity. Let them loose in the FunPlex while you have a coffee or join them in a game of laser tag then head outdoors to the Troy Meadows for a walk along the wetland boardwalks. Finish the day on a good note by taking them for a memorable pie at Avellino's Wood Fired Pizza on Ridgedale Avenue.

Newark

Newark is less than a ten-mile drive south of Nutley and a good city to head for if you want to have a cultural day. One of the most fascinating places to visit in Newark is the Thomas Edison National Historical Park. In the park, you'll be able to explore the home and workshops of Edison, the genius inventor, as well as find out what the effects of his discoveries and inventions have had on modern society. Boggle your brain with even more history at the Liberty Hall Museum or go to browse the artworks in the Montclair Art Museum before treating yourself to a pizza at Frank's Pizzeria on Bloomfield Avenue.

Passaic

If you're bored with doing all the unusual run-of-the-mill things like museums, art galleries, and endless hiking nature trails, try a visit to Passaic and you'll be able to do something completely different. You might not like it a lot at the start, but you'll have had fun by the time you're done. The Brighton Asylum Haunted House theme park is located in Passaic and it is one of America's top scare parks. Enter if you dare and if you do go in, be prepared to scream until you come out again. After you stop shaking, go to Romeo's Pizza on Main Avenue and recover over a pie.