Pleasantville certainly exists well within the Italian-American influence so iconic in New Jersey cities. An old-world appreciation is evident in the food in cities like Atlantic City and Pleasantville. You’ll not only find authentic dishes but authentic ingredients celebrated on these menus. It’s no wonder that classic Sicilian pizza would thrive in a city like Pleasantville. Sicilian pizza showcases the attention to detail that excellent tomato sauce requires because chefs can’t just pile cheese on top. For the best tasting results, Sicilian Pizza requires sourcing the ripest tomatoes and an understanding of how to season the sauce.

This is also a family town, so serving thick-crusted deep-dish pizza is the perfect way to feed a hungry group. The deeper, the better. And it’s almost a requirement that these pizzas are square or rectangle in shape. Pleasantville takes Italian food seriously, and Sicilian-style pizza is certainly revered in this city most of all.

Best Delivery Pizza in Pleasantville

Picture a classic Italian pizzeria located in New Jersey. The vibrant red and green facade. The joyous celebration of food, family, and culture. Marco Polo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante perfectly embodies this. Their no-frills menu features a variety of flavors, but Marco Polo’s pays homage to its roots, with classic Italian dishes as the focal point. Like many pizzerias in Pleasantville, Sicilian pizza is the first thing on the menu. Marco Polo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante prefers pizza to have a substantial crust, so their deep-dish pan pizza is a must-try. Unlike its Sicilian counterpart, Marco Polo’s thick crust creation features a hefty layer of mozzarella on top.

Aside from being a pizzeria, Marco Polo’s is also a “ristorante,” with classic pasta dishes and Italian entrees that effectively celebrate the local seafood culture of the region. Marco Polo’s also has a nice variety of deli selections, including hot and cold subs, strombolis, and calzones. Finish your meal with a freshly-baked Cannoli.

Order Marco Polo Pizzeria with Slice to have the best pizza in Pleasantville delivered.

Best Takeout Pizza in Pleasantville

Jo Jo’s Italian Grille is located right in downtown Pleasantville, making it the perfect stop on the way home from work or perhaps an Atlantic City casino. It’s easy to pick up a classic Sicilian pizza or their other amazing creations. Their square-shaped Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza headlines this menu, but they have a full line of incredible pizzas all baked in a wood-fired brick oven. Their thin-crust has the perfect char for those looking for a good crunch. Look for their specialty pizzas to find old-country-inspired creations with authentic Italian ingredients.

They have pizza by the slice for anyone who wants a bit of variety or just a quick bite to eat. The lunch crowd will find numerous calzone, stromboli, and panini options to satisfy their mid-day cravings. Jo Jo’s is also perfect for the whole family, so combining one of their famous pizzas with a classic Italian dish, like the Veal Saltimboca, covers your bases.

Order Jo Jo’s Italian Grille with Slice to pick up the best pizza in Pleasantville.

Best Pizza Near Pleasantville

Northfield

Carluccio’s Coal-Fired Pizza has a saying: “Pizza Well-Done. Done Well!” This could not be more true of this Northfield-based family restaurant and pizzeria. Most of their pizzas feature the signature char you only get with baking pizza in a coal-fired oven. Whether you concoct your own pizza or choose from their signature menu, you will find the best-baked crust, sweet and zesty sauce, and meltiest cheese in the area. They also offer the elusive Grandma-style pizza, which loads chunky San Marzano tomato sauce on top of a crispy pie with oregano and extra virgin olive oil.

Atlantic City

You don’t need to make it to a casino buffet or steak house to eat some of Atlantic City’s finest foods. Jonuzi’s Pizza is an outstanding option for picking up a wide selection of gourmet pizzas or classic Italian dishes. Their homemade meatballs with spaghetti and red sauce will make you feel right at home. Jonuzi’s Margherita Pizza uses only the freshest basil and finest mozzarella. This restaurant offers a must-try authentic Italian food experience, with the convenience of ordering on Slice for delivery or pickup.

Egg Harbor Township

Micchelli’s is a family-owned-and-operated restaurant churning out classic and creative pizzas. They specialize in veggie and heart-healthy pizza, as well as some more creative options, like Mexican Pizza. They also bake a New Haven-style clam pizza, not the most common of sights this far away from Connecticut! If you’re looking for Italian food, Micchelli’s covers all the bases with a full menu of entrees and calzones for the lunch crowd.