Top Pizza Restaurants in Red Bank, NJ Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Red Bank: a local guide

New York-style pizza originated with Italian immigration in 1905. Gennaro Lombardi opened his Manhattan pizzeria and started serving large, thin-crust pizza with a plain topping of red sauce and mozzarella cheese. Slowly, the New-York style of pizza scattered across the nation and became a popular choice. Ideally, the New York-style pizza is a thin-crusted pie. Instead of being fragile, the pizza’s crust is pliable and can be neatly folded to eat it like a true New Yorker. A dense cheese covering is spread all over the pizza, and you can add toppings if that’s your preference. Most restaurants provide the option to choose between the whole pie and a single slice as NY-style pizza is typically 18 inches and yields eight large pieces. Compared to Neapolitan pizza, NY-style pizza has more cheese. And not just any cheese. They use low moisture mozzarella, which prevents the pizza from becoming too greasy or oily.

Best Delivery Pizza in Red Bank

Are you looking for the best pizza delivery place? Mr. Pizza Slice is an excellent option for the delivery of pizza, fries, and Italian hot dogs. They use fresh ingredients to make all their menu items. You can find various pizza-style options on the menu, including Sicilian Square Pizza, Brooklyn Square Pizza, and Grandma Pizza. They have tons of different specialty pizzas to pique your interest. Try the Penne Vodka Pizza, the BBQ Chicken Ranch, or the Eggplant Parm Pizza for something new. The value and service at Mr. Pizza Slice are so good that it’s no surprise that they have been in business for over four decades. Once you’ve exhausted the pizza options, try the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with chicken tenders, buffalo sauce, and shredded cheese. The wings, salads, and calzones should not be missed either. Give yourself lots of time to peruse their extensive menu. It’s going to be hard to choose just one thing to order.

Best Takeout Pizza in Red Bank

Taliercio's Gourmet Deli offers incredible food with top-notch service and reasonable prices in Red Bank. If you haven't tried their fried ravioli, you are missing out. Their Chicken Cordon Bleu Bites are another house specialty worth trying. You can tempt your taste buds with Buffalo Style Pizza; it will melt in your mouth. The Pesto, Olive, and Feta Pizza is always tasty, and they also have a Gluten-free Plain Pizza you can dress up any way you want. If it’s thicker crust you’re after, order the Focaccia Pizza. It comes plain and is ready to be customized as well. To say their menu is huge might be an understatement. It could take you years to get through it all. In addition to the fantastic pizza, they have salads, sandwiches, and eggrolls. The incredible food and friendly staff convince customers to come back again and again.

Best Pizza Near Red Bank


Living in Freehold offers a more sparse suburban feel. Most people live in this town because of its good schools. Freehold is famous for producing beans, rye, and potatoes. Attilio's Pizzeria is a nice spot to enjoy their distinct flavors of pizza, cheesesteaks, and burgers. Both the quality and quantity of pizza will amaze you. A unique menu item here is the Sicilian Upside Down Pizza. Why not add a little whimsy to your next meal in Freehold?


Sayreville is located in Middlesex County and is a relaxing place to live. Residents and tourists favor Sayreville for its clean environment and kind people. If you want to try the pizza of Sayreville, Rustoni’s Pizza is a fantastic place to start. For something new, try the Sicilian pizza slice; it has a crispy bottom and is loaded with rich tomato sauce. Don’t forget to top it with fresh basil! Chicken parmigiana is another specialty here.

Old Bridge

Old Bridge is famous for multiple state parks and Sayre Woods Bible Church. Tourists love visiting Old Bridge due to its picnic areas and huge playground.
Vinnie's Pizza Old Bridge offers appetizing pizza to its customers. Start by creating your own pizza with any additional toppings you want. You can also have your pizza on a cauliflower crust. The Margarita Pizza and the Baked Ziti Pizza are definitely worth a try.

show more iconSee More


caret icon
caret icon
caret icon
caret icon


Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in Red Bank, NJ