The borough of Sussex is located in Sussex County in the state of New Jersey. The population of Sussex is approximately 1,800 residents as recorded in 2019, showing a steady population decline from census records in 2010 and 2000.

There are a variety of things to do and places to go in Sussex including the Wallkill River National Wildlife Refuge, the Ward-Nasse Gallery, Papakating Creek, and Lake Neepaulin. Sussex is also home to plenty of yummy restaurants, eateries, and local dives where you can enjoy great food.

Here, we are going to focus on the pizzerias Sussex has to offer! From Sicilian to deep-dish to grandma pizzas, we have got you covered. So, read on to find out what our selection is for best pizza delivery, best pizza takeout, and best specialty pizza in and around the town of Sussex.

Sussex is Known for New York City Pizza

Thanks to the proximity of New York City to Sussex, New Jersey, the pizza scene in Sussex is deeply rooted in New York City pizza styles. The pizzas are delicious, large, saucy, cheesy, and packed full of authentic Italian seasonings that bring the pizza together in harmony.

New York City pizzas are made in a circle with a thin crust. The pizza maker rolls out the dough until it is very thin, then typically stretches the dough out again by hand to get the perfect size and shape. Next, the pizza is covered in sauce and cooked.

Once the pizza is almost done cooking it is taken out of the oven and covered with lots of shredded mozzarella cheese. If there are toppings, they are added now. The pizza goes back into the oven and is finished when the cheese is golden brown and melted to perfection.

Best Pizza Delivery in Sussex

The best part of ordering a pizza is the moment when the pizza arrives and it is still warm and aromatic. There is nothing better. TJ’s Pizza in Sussex is a perfect example of a great delivery pizzeria. They get you your food fast and their pizza is delicious.

TJ’s Pizza has combos like the Family Combo, which comes with one cheese pizza, 12 buffalo chicken wings or 12 mozzarella sticks, garlic sticks, and a two-liter soda. They have other fan-favorite pizzas like the Balsamic Chicken pizza, which is topped with sundried tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, artichoke hearts, grilled chicken, and finished with a balsamic glaze.

Another specialty pizza from TJ’s Pizza is the Tuscany Chicken Pesto pizza, which is loaded up with tomatoes, grilled chicken, red onions, parmesan cheese, and finished with a drizzle of pesto aioli. They offer dine-in, pickup, and no-contact delivery. Order online, in-store, or over the phone today.

Best Takeout Pizza in Sussex

The best takeout pizzeria in Sussex is Lorenzo’s Pizzeria. They sell a variety of different foods here, including homemade cookies, brownies, baked ziti, and of course, pizza. Lorenzo’s is a relaxed, low-key, and casual vibe where you can get great food at affordable prices.

Lorenzo’s is known for their perfected New York City pizza, which is amazingly yummy. They offer their delicious cheese pizza for $9.50 on Tuesdays during their Tuesday Plain Pizza Special, so be sure to swing by to get yours.

Takeout orders can be placed in-store or called in by phone and usually are ready in 20 to 30 minutes, depending on your order. Do not forget to ask them about their daily specialties and baked goods to complete your takeout order.

Best Pizza Near Sussex

Wantage

The best pizza in Wantage is at Brothers Pizza. Here they make delicious authentic pizza that is loaded with flavor and expertise. They serve a variety of foods including salads, sandwiches, and soups, as well as pizza. They offer family specials that serve four to six people, perfect to order when you do not feel like cooking dinner.

They have plenty of options for toppings, specialties, and styles of pizza, so you are sure to find what you are craving here. Check out their full menu online or in-store today.

Franklin

The best pizza in Franklin is located at the Brick and Brew, a lovely restaurant with a casual yet upscale atmosphere. You can get delicious specialty pizzas along with traditional and authentic pizzas. Plus they have a variety of other menu items as well.

You can order for pick-up or enjoy eating in their light-filled dining room with great service and polite staff.

Lafayette

The best pizzeria in Lafayette is AG Pizza and Restaurant, a delicious pizzeria and restaurant that serves a variety of different foods as well as fantastic pizza. They offer gluten-free wraps, tasty sandwiches, pizza, and more. You can get something for everyone at AG Pizza and Restaurant.

Make sure to check out their full menu online or in-store today.