Top Pizza Restaurants in Westville, NJ in 2024 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Westville: a local guide

In Westville, make sure you sample the Trenton tomato pie or what some people call New Jersey-style pizza. Joe's Tomato Pie prepared the first Trenton tomato pie in Trenton, New Jersey, in 1910. The pizza later became an iconic dish in New Jersey, and by the mid 20th century, it was already in Westville, and the residents loved it. You can now order tomato pie from many pizzerias in Westville for delivery or takeout, and you won't be disappointed. New Jersey-style pizza is a progeny of Italian tomato pie discovered in Sicily, Italy. However, the two pizza styles differ in some features. Trenton tomato pie is thin and circular, while the Italian is thick and square. Toppings for the Trenton tomato pie start with mozzarella cheese and other toppings, followed by tomato sauce at the very top. The tomato sauce uses basil, tomatoes, and oregano for seasoning, and you can taste the homemade goodness in every bite.

Best Delivery Pizza in Westville

Frankie’s Pizza is one of the oldest pizzerias in Westville, and it has polished its pizza-making skills over the years since its opening. When you need a delicious pizza in Westville, you should order from Frankie’s Pizza. First, you can whet your appetite with juicy chicken fingers or cream cheese poppers. The pizzeria also serves a house special called Frankie’s Special Pizza. It has the best toppings, including sausage, meatballs, pepperoni. The fresh mushrooms, peppers, and onions balance the meatiness perfectly. The Tomato Pizza is an excellent option for a taste of something local. If a whole pizza is too much, opt for one of their individual slices that make the best lunch. Although pizza is Frankie’s specialty, they also do several other dishes, all at affordable prices. The selection of sandwiches is enviable with both hot and cold subs, panini, kaiser roll sandwiches, and club sandwiches. Try your best to save room for dessert because the tiramisu is heavenly.

Best Takeout Pizza in Westville

Tony Soprano’s Pizza is a notable restaurant in Westville serving the locals and visitors mouth-watering Italian dishes. The pizzeria offers an assortment of New York-style and Sicilian pizzas. They also have a long list of low-carb wraps if that suits your diet. The kid’s menu, called “Little Wise Guys,” will satisfy any picky eater and has a cartoon theme. Tons of sandwiches, burgers, and pasta dinners make this a restaurant with something for everyone. The main feature of the menu at Tony Soprano’s is the pizza. With over 20 gourmet pizzas choices, you’ll need more than a few minutes to peruse the menu. When you order takeout from here, you’ll be surprised at the quality of food you get for the price. This family-owned pizzeria has perfected their pizza-making skills over the last 45 years, so you know it’s going to be tasty. They do all the classics but throw in some unique options like the Wing Sauce Pizza. Instead of tomato sauce, they use wing sauce - what a fantastic idea!

Best Pizza Near Westville

Gloucester City

Gloucester City, the location of the Frightmare Halloween Festival, is a wonderful place to visit, especially in October. After you’ve been scared, head to Jacqueline’s Pizza & Pasta. The pizzeria draws pizza connoisseurs from Gloucester City and the surrounding area. A selection of pizza types awaits you at Jacqueline’s - they have New York-style, Sicilian, deep-dish, and Grandma pizza. Customers can find red or white sauce options, gourmet pizzas, and everyday pickup specials. All their salads come with a garlic knot, and the calzones melt in your mouth.

Bellmawr

Luciano’s Pizza is a hidden gem in Bellmawr, serving exquisite Grilled BBQ Chicken Pizza and many other pizza combinations. The pizzeria uses only the best ingredients when preparing their dishes. They offer New Jersey’s favorite pizza style: tomato pie. You can opt for a gluten-free pizza or any one of their New York-style gourmet pizzas. Luciano’s also serves several lunch specials and homemade cheeseburgers at an economical price. A trip to Bellmawr wouldn’t be complete without visiting Luciano’s Pizza.

Woodbury

Woodbury lies less than three miles from Westville and is full of young families and commuters who work in nearby Philadelphia. Woodbury is big on food, and the best place in town for pizza is Maggio’s Pizza & Pasta. Open for over ten years; you have to try their Grandma Pizza when you visit. The square pizza is loaded with homemade marinara sauce, basil, and sliced mozzarella. To say that the toppings are generous would be an understatement. The Deep Dish Tomato Pie, a thicker twist on a New Jersey classic, is another tasty option.

show more iconSee More

PIZZA TYPES IN WESTVILLE

EVEN MORE TYPES OF FOOD IN WESTVILLE

Slicechevron right iconNew Jerseychevron right icon Pizza Places in Westville, NJ