Batavia was named by the Dutch families who first settled here, and this cozy and family-centered town is well-known for its homey feeling. This is a location that is just far enough away from the big city to feel comfortable and like it is located in the country. This is an area that many families live in, and lots of people will tell you that they came to visit and simply never left.

This is a place that offers lots of great family-owned and operated restaurants and you can count on this town to deliver a great sit-down eating experience as well as good delivery and takeout options. Many of the restaurants in town are run by third or fourth-generation families and the quality of the food really shows this. You can find great food of all kinds in this area, but there are many excellent pizza restaurants that are located here for your enjoyment.

Batavia is Known for Classic Pizza

Despite being located relatively close to New York, this area is not actually known for Italian-style pizza or for Chicago-style slices. This is an area that offers comfort foods on every menu and you will get access to a really great classic pizza here. There are options on every menu that everyone will love and most places have specialty menu options, but the pizza feels timeless and is not specific to one unique style.

This is a location that delivers a delicious round pie with a flavorful crust and quality toppings no matter where you dine. If you want a really great family-dining experience, this is the city to find it and you will be able to get a really excellent pizza here as well as quality sides and more. Batavia knows that its roots are in family comfort and care and you will get food here that makes this heritage clear in all the best ways.

Best Delivery Pizza in Batavia

The best delivery pizza in this area can be found at Batavia’s Original. This location offers wings as well as pizza and even has a popular pizza kit on the menu that lets you create their delightful pizzas at home. There are carb-conscious offerings on the menu here like the Pizza Boat that is made without the crust and an excellent Margherita pizza. You can also get some really great classics with the build-your-own pizza menu.

Their loaded Garlic Knots are excellent and you should consider making room for the Biggest Round in Town pizza or breadsticks. This is a family-owned location and the feeling of welcome and comfort is palpable when you order from this location. You can order everything off the menu to go and you will have a great experience when you work with this location for your delivery needs.

Best Takeout Pizza in Batavia

For the best takeout pizza in this area, you need to order from Big Pauly’s Pizza. This location makes quality hand-tossed pies that are woodfired. You will get a delicious and crunchy crust on every order and they make some of the best pizzas around. Try their chicken pizza or the steak pizza if you want a fun twist on the meat-lovers concept or you can get a delightful simple cheese pizza that is still amazing.

Save room for their yummy pizza fingers or get the Hodge Podge appetizer which is a mix of veggies served with blue cheese. There is no shortage of comfort food on this menu and you will love that you can get a full range of pizza styles and flavors here with ease. This is a great place to order for a large group with diverse tastes and you will love that their takeout options cover the entire menu.

Best Pizza Near Batavia

Holley, NY

Murray Superette offers quality classic pizzas that you can pick up or sit down to eat. Their Philly Pizza is a local favorite but they also make a great calzone and have excellent sides. This is a good place to head if you love a munchies menu and you can get fries, pizza rolls, and other pizza-inspired sides as well here. This is a great place to head if you want a menu with variety and great comfort foods as well as great pizza.

Leicester, NY

Harry’s Expressway is a great place for classic pizza slices as well as fun things like their delicious breakfast pizza. You can get any kind of pizza that you want here, as well as quality breakfast offerings and even some excellent sides and comfort foods. This is a surprising pizza place with a really creative pizza menu and you can have pies here that you would not get anywhere else. If you are in the area, this is the perfect place to go for your pizza order.

Avon, NY

Pizza Land-Avon has a very fun and unique menu and you need to make sure that you consider trying their loaded french fry pizza when you stop in. There are all the classic pizza styles on the menu here as well and you can also enjoy a great Mediterranean pizza or a taco pizza here. This location offers a lot of specials as well, which makes it a great choice for feeding a crowd.