Find Pizza Near You in Bay Shore, New York

Bay Shore is known for being a peaceful and relaxing area. If you live there, you probably move at your own pace. There are many amazing restaurants and pizzerias to order from as well. If you want to enjoy everything the area has to offer, you should try all their local pizza places!

Pizza came here very quickly after it was brought to New York City. It didn’t take long for the dish to spread here. Today, the most popular variety you’re going to find here is the New York slice. There are plenty of other options, however. You should be able to find anything you like through Slice!

Overall, this is a wonderful place to live. You’re sure to find all of the best pizzas here. Just like the rest of the state, Bay Shore, NY, has a great craving for pizza. In this article, we’ll show you all of the best places to eat. Here’s what you should know.

Recommended Pizzerias in Bay Shore

caret icon

Amore Pizzeria logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(577)
Open Now
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Fratelli Pizzeria & Restaurant logo
View Menu

Victorio Ii Pizza logo
View Menu

Corks and Taps logo
View Menu

Victorio's Pizza logo
View Menu

Valentinos Pizza logo
15% Off Online
4.5filled star icon(368)
Closed
Free Delivery
Order Online

Slice of Bay Shore logo
4.8filled star icon(212)
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

The Classic New York Pizza Joint logo
5% Off Online
4.7filled star icon(84)
Closed
Free Delivery
Order Online

La Casa (Formerly Tina's II) logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(157)
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Joe's Pasta & Pizza logo
4.7filled star icon(202)
Closed
$3.45 Delivery
Order Online

Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant logo
4.7filled star icon(101)
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Frank & Maria's Italian Market logo
4.8filled star icon(45)
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Gino's Pizzeria logo
View Menu

Buseto Pizza logo
View Menu

Mulberry Street logo
View Menu


Bay Shore is Known For New York Style Pizza

New York-style pizza originated in the state, making it the most popular option in Bay Shore. You can enjoy this slice just about anywhere since it was made to eat on the go. Many locals love it and have their own favorite places to pick up their meals.

The style consists of large, foldable slices of pie. You’re sure to love every bite of the crispy crust. The slices are so large that they’re sold by the slice. You can expect a single slice to be about the size of your plate. Most people will just order one or two.

The focus of this pie is the crust. You’re sure to notice the unique flavors and texture that it offers.

Overall, you’ll find plenty of different stores in the area that offer this thin crust pizza. No matter what you want, you’re sure to find it here! There are also options for Neapolitan pies and deep dishes.

Best Delivery Pizza in Bay Shore

If you’re looking for the best delivery pizza, we recommend that you visit Gino’s of Bay Shore. This pizzeria has a convenient location right on Main St. You’re sure to receive your order very quickly due to this. Plus, the staff there make sure that your order is always prepared right away.

Customers also recommend that you try their buffalo sauce- it tastes great with plenty of different menu items. You’re sure to love it! There are so many different flavors that you can experience there.

Customers also mentioned appreciating the service that they received. Your order is likely to arrive much earlier than anticipated, allowing you to enjoy it early! So, when you’re already hungry, this would be the best place to order from.

Overall, you’re bound to enjoy everything that this Bay Shore restaurant has. The staff will start making your food right away, so you can be confident that it arrives on time.

Best Takeout Pizza in Bay Shore

However, if you’re already out of the house, you’ll want to make sure to try some takeout! We suggest that you order from Amore Pizzeria instead. They have some of the best options for a quick take-out meal.

Many people order from here on their way home from work or other places. It’s very easy to grab your meal on the way back, allowing you to enjoy it as quickly as possible. When you order through us, you won’t have to wait in a line to get your food either.

They have plenty of options and make sure to take care with every single order they get. You can create your own pies too, using all of the toppings that they have available. You’re sure to find something that you like here!

In short, this is the best place to order from if you need something quick while you’re already out of the house. We recommend placing your order ahead of time with us. That way, you know when you need to pick it up.

Best Pizza Near Bay Shore

New York City

There are so many unique and amazing places to eat in New York City. you’re sure to find somewhere to enjoy a slice! However, we’d have to recommend that you order from Zero Otto Nove. They have some of the best Naples-type pizzas in the immediate area. Plus, they’re known for making delicious sides.

Jersey City

However, if you’re closer to Jersey City, you’ll want to visit Razza Pizza there instead. They have some of the best options for pizza and offer plenty of options for vegans and those who can’t eat gluten. No matter what you’re craving, we’re confident that you can find something here.

Newark

Finally, we’d have to say that the best pizza in Newark would have to be Blaze Pizza there. They have an amazing crust and are very well-loved by the locals. You’re sure to enjoy their pies and the customer service offered to you.

FAQ

Q: 🍕 What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Bay Shore?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Neapolitan pizza in Bay Shore?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Grandma pizza in Bay Shore?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best deep dish pizza in Bay Shore?

caret icon

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

Even More Types of Food in Bay Shore

Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Bay Shore, NY