Popular for its tourism assets, peaceful neighborhoods, a thriving business section located downtown, as well as summer and lakeside cottages, Canandaigua is the perfect place for a successful family trip. The city situated at the northern tip of Canandaigua Lake is of very high interest for those who wish to spend a day in nature, no matter the season. Here you can visit breath-taking nature parks and historic sites, relaxing piers and museums, or even ski and snowboard areas if traveling here during the winter.

Although Canandaigua does not host many pizza festivals or fun activities, many locals enjoy participating in one of the nearby events to explore the Italian cuisine and the secrets of an original New York-style pizza. The most popular festival in the area has to be the New York Pizza Festival, which showcases cooking classes from US pizza chefs or culinary personalities, pizza workshops for those who want to get creative, and many food trucks to keep you well-fed.

Canandaigua is Known for New York-style Pizza

Needless to say, the classic and beloved thin-crust pizza that is always loaded with delicious tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and plenty of other fresh ingredients is a top choice among Canandaigua residents. New York-style pizza is at home in this city, and it is highly requested in all restaurants and pizzerias in the area. As a result, many of these places have adapted their menus to the customers’ demands. They now serve this outstanding type of pizza for either takeout and delivery if you are in a hurry or in their cozy sit-down locations.

With the median age of the entire population in Canandaigua being 44 years old, most locals prefer dining in for a slice of tempting New York-style pizza after a busy day. The crispy, buttery crust, bubbly cheese, savory tomato sauce, and mixture of other delicious toppings are always a delight and never fail to amaze even the most meticulous pizza enthusiast.

Best Delivery Pizza in Canandaigua

For more than 70 years, Pontillo’s Pizzeria has been serving their signature pizza that has made so many of their customers stay loyal to their dishes to this day. With over 20 locations, this restaurant is proud to be known as a Western New York original, thanks to its outstanding food. According to locals, besides having an amazingly kind and friendly staff, their delivery service is top-notch, with fast cooking times on their dishes and quick delivery.

Pontillo’s Pizzeria is also popular because it allows customers to build their own pizza starting from the crust, which can be regular thin-crust or cauliflower crust. Customers can also choose the cheese, sauce, and toppings, making the entire pizza-eating experience memorable. You can choose any ingredient from their long list of over 15 available toppings. The menu features classic pepperoni, controversial pineapple, healthy vegetables such as mushrooms, broccoli, and spinach, and plenty of meats, including sausage, ham, and chicken.

Best Takeout Pizza in Canandaigua

If you search for the best takeout pizza that you can find in Canandaigua, then Pizza Sangiorgi will not let you down. Established in 2008, this family-owned restaurant with an incredible Italian heritage originating from Sicily, Italy, is famous in the area for its thin-crust pizza. Using only the highest-quality ingredients available, Pizza Sangiorgi creates delicious and interesting specialty pizzas that make customers want to come back for more of their food.

Should you plan on ordering from their restaurant, the Supreme Pizza is a must-try since it is loaded with fresh mozzarella, crispy pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black olives. Another popular choice among locals is the White Garlic Pizza, featuring mozzarella, provolone, Pecorino Romano, asiago, and garlic. It has a tasty and comforting flavor instantly loved by all customers who give it a try.

Best Pizza Near Canandaigua

Newark

Known for its rich history and named after Newark-on-Trent, a town in England, Newark is a city located in New York, frequently visited for its antique shops, history museums, historic sites, and even farms.

If you are visiting Newark for any reason or simply living here, you should know that BB’s Pizzeria makes the best pizza in the area. According to locals, the Taco Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, and the Calzones are all great picks.

Geneva

Featuring beautiful state parks, architectural buildings, and wineries and vineyards, Geneva is a town popular for being the home of the New York State Agricultural Experiment Station run by Cornell University.

Halsey’s Restaurant serves the best New York-style pizza in this city, with some exciting pizza combinations. From Garlic Crab Pizza and Meatball Pizza to Pizza al Pesto and The House Specialty Pizza made with blue cheese, this pizzeria will definitely impress you with its dishes.

Rochester

Famous for the nicknames of “Young Lion of the West,” “Flour City,” or “Flower City,” Rochester has a very distinguishable history in the fields of photography, xerography, manufacturing, and optics, with many educational resources.

Whether you are visiting the area to learn more about this place’s history or you simply wish to have fun here, Pizza Wizard is the best location to enjoy a delicious pizza. Order their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Garlic Pizza, or Pepperoni Pizza for a successful lunch or dinner.