Find Local Pizza in Cicero, New York

Cicero is a wonderful place to live. There are plenty of things to do and many restaurants that locals enjoy. If you happen to be in the area, you’ll want to try out the unique pizza options you have here.

This is a family-friendly town with many wonderful pizzerias for you to enjoy. There are places to order from and even many different selections for pizza takeout. Overall, you’ll have a wonderful time exploring all of the pizza places in the town.

We recommend that you order from Slice if you live in Cicero, NY. You have many pizzerias to choose from, so we’ll help you find all of the best places. We made sure to include all of the best options for pizza in the area below. There are plenty of hidden gems in the area that we’re confident you’ll love!

Top Pizza Restaurants in Cicero Near You

caret icon

Paladino's Cicero Pizza logo
View Menu

Sardo's Pizza & Fish Fry logo
View Menu

Cicero Country Pizza logo
View Menu

Lakeshore Pizza logo
View Menu


Other pizza places near Cicero

caret icon

Liberty Pizza logo
10% Off Online
4.7filled star icon(340)
Open Now
$1.00 Delivery
Order Online

Peppino's Pizzeria logo
4.8filled star icon(950)
Open Now
$2.50 Delivery
Order Online

Pavone's Pizza logo
4.8filled star icon(1384)
Open Now
Free Delivery
Order Online

Tangy Tomato logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(49)
Open Now
Free Delivery
Order Online

Amore Pizza & More logo
4.7filled star icon(38)
Open Now
Free Delivery
Order Online

Samara Pizza & Deli logo
5% Off Online
4.0filled star icon(72)
Open Now
$5.40 Delivery
Order Online

Barbagallo's logo
New
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Debs Mini Mart logo
New
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Trapper's logo
4.7filled star icon(64)
Open Now
Pickup Only
Order Online

Uncle Chubby's logo
4.1filled star icon(114)
Closed
$4.00 Delivery
Order Online

Mr Pizza & Wings & Jamaican Food logo
15% Off Online
3.8filled star icon(16)
Closed
$4.00 Delivery
Order Online

Helena's Mediterranean Cafe & Deli logo
4.7filled star icon(10)
Open Now
Pickup Only
Order Online

Paladino's Cicero Pizza logo
View Menu

Trappers II Pizza & Pub logo
View Menu

Seniora Pizza logo
View Menu


Cicero is Known For New York Style Pizza

If you’re in Cicero, you’ll have many options for a delicious New York-style pizza. This type of pizza is a thin slice that’s very large. The pizza is made this way, so you can fold it in half as you eat. That way you can easily carry the slice with you as you walk.

The New York-style slice is very popular in this state. Although, you can still find many different pizza types in Cicero. If you haven’t tried a local slice of New York pie, you’ll want to try it soon! This location has very authentic New York slices that taste wonderful.

Overall, the area is known for New York-style pizza. You’ll have a lot of fun trying all of the different pizza options in this town. You’ll run into this tasty, thin slice the most- locals love it! We’re confident you will too.

Best Delivery Pizza in Cicero

If you want a great delivery service, we recommend that you order from Trapper’s. This pizza pub is open every single day, allowing you to order any time that’s convenient for you. They’re also open pretty late into the night.

The restaurant is very fast when it comes to pizza delivery. They prepare the food very quickly and always use fresh ingredients. The staff also bring it to your home right away, allowing you to enjoy your meal in no time at all!

If you’re hungry and don’t want to cook, this place has some of the best services in the town. Customers love their pepperoni slices, vegetarian quesadillas, and beer the most. However, there are plenty of toppings and sides for you to choose from- their menu is very large.

Overall, the pizza here is wonderful and always delicious. You can feel confident that a hot, fresh pizza will soon be at your doorstep when you use the link below!

Best Takeout Pizza in Cicero

If you’re looking for the best takeout in the area, we would recommend that you order from Paladino’s Cicero Pizza. This place on Brewerton Road has some of the best pizzas around. You can easily order through Slice and pick up your meal as soon as it’s ready.

Many locals in the area enjoy ordering from this pizzeria for lunch. You can order ahead of time, then pick up the meal while you’re out. Locals will plan their order, allowing them to pick up the food on their way back from running errands or work.

The location also has a very delicious pie. You get plenty of gooey cheese and toppings with every order. Plus, the locals love the taste of the sauce and crust. You’ll want to try it out as soon as you’re able!

Overall, the cooks at this restaurant prepare a wonderful meal each and every time that you order. You’ll be able to pick up your order very quickly as well- the staff get started very quickly and are fast with completing their pies.

Best Pizza Near Cicero

Syracuse

Pavone’s Pizza in Syracuse offers very large portion sizes. They have amazing prices as well and many locals love the place! You can order a lot of food at a great value here.

Fairmount

If you want some of the best pizza around, be sure to travel to Fairmount. It’s not far away and you can enjoy Uncle Mike’s Hometown Pizza. They have decent prices and are very well-loved by locals living there.

Fulton

Mama Gina’s in Fulton, NY is another wonderful pizzeria. It’s the perfect distance away for a day trip and you can explore the area there too. The restaurant offers amazing meals at good prices. Plus, you get to enjoy delicious crust, cheese, and sauce with your order.

FAQ

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best deep dish pizza in Cicero?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Cicero?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Neapolitan pizza in Cicero?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Silician pizza in Cicero?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App
Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Cicero, NY