Top Pizza Restaurants in Commack, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Commack: a local guide

Before Europeans arrived in the area where the hamlet of Commack is today, the region was home to the Secatogue Native American tribe. The name of the hamlet was derived from the native language which means pleasant lands and the original spelling was Comac. This community started out as an agricultural community, thanks in many ways to the fertile soil in the area, but there’s little or no evidence of such today as the hamlet is residential and suburbanized. There are several landmarks and historic sites to see in Commack – a major thing that makes it an attractive and lovely place to visit. The hamlet is home to the oldest Methodist Church building in New York State (built in 1789) and also features the National Jewish Sports Hall of Fame and Museum. There isn’t much Italian representation in the population here, but the food definitely makes up for that as there are delicious pies available to enjoy.

Commack is known for Neapolitan pizza

There’s hardly a pizza aficionado that visits Commack that doesn’t find what interests them in the restaurants within the neighborhood seeing as different pizza types like Sicilian, grandma, white pizza, stuffed pizza, tomato pizza, even NY-style pies are common. It’s one of the things that makes this hamlet stand out in the area. As much as Commack is well-known for the different pies that are available there, it is even more popular for Neapolitan pizza, the pie that no one here ever jokes with. Virtually all the restaurants serve the Naples-style pizza, offering locals the traditional meal as well as custom-made ones. What’s even more exciting about the community is that the pizzaiolos prepare the Neapolitan pies in such a way that it’s authentic and true to the Italian legacy, such that everyone that grabs a bite of it gets to know what makes this pie so famous.

Best Delivery Pizza in Commack

For more than a decade, Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant on Jericho Turnpike has served the residents of Commack by providing excellent pizza delivery service which has made the pizzeria gain the trust of everyone in the hamlet. In fact, it’s not uncommon for this restaurant to be the reason many don’t cook because you can count on them to feed your entire household by delivering a delicious meal to your home at the right time. After all, individual and group orders are excellently handled by the pizzeria’s team. Another thing that makes this restaurant keep getting repeat business here is the fact that they have an extensive menu that features regular cheese pies, house specialty pies, stuffed pies, and many more. The family-run restaurant never disappoints, so place your order now on Slice to get that fresh, hot, and tasty pie delivered before you know it.

Best Takeout Pizza in Commack

Some of the best pies in Commack are cooked in the ovens at Gino’s of Commack, so don’t be surprised, as a newbie in town, when you see the traffic here as you arrive to pick up your own order. The restaurant certainly lives up to the rave about their takeout pizza service in the hamlet by making sure that every meal is perfect so that every customer that walks through their door for pickup returns for more before long. Rest assured you’ll have a memorable dining experience whenever you settle down to eat the pizza you pick up here, especially if it’s one that you created yourself as the chefs are always spot on with such orders. Those that fancy the pizzeria’s specialty pies are never too tired nor busy for a quick stop and grab because it’s always worth it. Order now on Slice.

Best Pizza Near Commack

East Northport

East Northport is a census-designated place that lies northwest of Commack in the town of Huntington. This hamlet, even though called East Northport, actually lies south of the village of Northport on Long Island. It was originally occupied by the Matinecocks Native American tribe. Here in East Northport, the locals enjoy delectable pies that range from Neapolitan pizza to grandma pizza and Sicilian pizza, so visit Filetto’s on Clay Pitts Road if you’re in the mood for any.


Smithtown lies east of Commack and consists of a number of villages such as Head of the Harbor, Village of the Branch, Nissequogue etc. that each offer nice learning and recreational opportunities to guests that visit the town. Besides the family-friendly activities here, this town which was originally settled in 1665 has really great pizza and there’s no better place to pick up a box or two for the family than at Don Jono’s Pizzeria Restaurant on West Jericho Turnpike.

Kings Park

There’s no way you should be in Kings Park and miss out on the delish pies that are served at Linda’s Riverside Pizzeria & Café on Riviera Drive because the grandma pizza, Sicilian pizza, or any other gourmet specials here will certainly add more color to your trip. Some of the landmark places you may wish to spend time at while you’re here include Sunken Meadow State Park, the Nissequogue River, Kings Park Bluff, and Leo P. Ostebo Kings Park Heritage Museum.

show more iconSee More
Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Commack, NY