Top Pizza Restaurants in Dexter, NY in 2026 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

All Out Pizza & More
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
4.7
•
10% off
19009 NY 12E, Dexter, NY 13634
Was perfect and done on time
Christopher V. • 12/21/2025

Mustachio's Pizzeria
Open Now
$3.00 Delivery
5
2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
Consistently awesome. You guys rock.
Jason P. • 4/7/2026
Deniro's Pizzeria
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.7
2251 George Urban Blvd, Depew, NY 14043
Delivery over half hour late- fries were cold and gross
Anne B. • 4/4/2026
JT's Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.9
1161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
I love Jts
Tanesha B. • 3/15/2026
La Nova Pizzeria
Open Now
$7.00 Delivery
4.7
371 W Ferry St, Buffalo, NY 14213
Our order was delivered quickly and the delivery person communicated updates on arriving for drop off.
Sheila K. • 1/8/2026
Muscarella's Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
5
5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221
There are some mighty hard-working young people making this business run, and they're doing an awesome job. Please all be good to them, especially with the tip jar.
Maria H. • 1/31/2026
Colosso Taco & Pizza Express
Open Now
$4.00 Delivery
4.8
66 Main St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Special instructions not followed
Brice R. • 4/7/2026
La Nova Pizzeria
Open Now
$7.00 Delivery
4.5
5151 Main St, Amherst, NY 14221
awesome
Patrick S. • 3/6/2026
The Wurlitzer Pizza
Open Now
$5.50 Delivery
4.7
1401 Nash Rd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
The best Bleu Cheese in history! Love this place!
Anthony S. • 3/20/2026
Gino's NY Pizza
Open Now
$4.99 Delivery
5
3500 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
Somehow, you guys always get it right. The wings are always perfect.
Maria R. • 4/3/2026
Broadway Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 - $6.00 Delivery
4.9
•
5% off
7320 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304
they always come thru food is amazing service is outstanding
Christopher W. • 3/19/2026
Fatman's Pizza
Open Now
$6.50 Delivery
4.9
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Order took a half hour longer than expected and entire pizza had pepperoni on it rather than half. This is a big deal when half of the people can’t eat the food. I appreciate the partial refund, but I will not order from here again.
Jennifer M. • 1/17/2026
Carbone's Pizza & Subs
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
4.5
1126 E Lovejoy St, Buffalo, NY 14206
I had chicken wings.. They were delicious
Patricia H. • 3/22/2026
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.8
92 Niagara St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Food was tasty but too much grease/oil
Mary D. • 1/31/2026
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.9
345 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207
I eat at Joes pretty regularly by the slice. I liked the pizza flavor but it wasn’t a joes NY style pizza. It was thicker than usual and doughy. It wasn’t thin and crispy like usual. I also ordered extra mushrooms and on four of the slices I could only find 2 mushrooms. Love the pizza but this one wasn’t it.
Verified Slice Customer • 3/17/2026
Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood
Open Now
$3.50 Delivery
4.8
1009 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Thank you for being the best pizza in Buffalo always ❤️
Megan G. • 4/3/2026

PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS