Top Pizza Restaurants in Dexter, NY in 2025 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

All Out Pizza & More
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
4.6
•
10% off
19009 NY 12E, Dexter, NY 13634
This was my first time ordering online. Delicious pizza, but I thought 45 minutes for a pizza was a long time while I waited in an empty parking lot.
Verified Slice Customer • 12/19/2024

Mustachio's Pizzeria
Open Now
$3.00 Delivery
4.8
2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
I could not believe the amount of meat on my Bully sub! My wife said, you're not gonna finish that....oh! I finished it...
Verified Slice Customer • 1/19/2025
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.4
92 Niagara St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Love your food, unfortunately I am not real happy about the $2.65 food tech charge. I do not subscribe to tipping people in a non tipping position, no problem tipping wait/bar staff, hotel cleaning people, cabs, staff at hotel free breakfasts, cabbies Ubers etc… but not counter help and the $2.65 that just gets slipped onto my check is very “cell service” b.s. everyone wants to tack on extra charges.
Verified Slice Customer • 11/12/2024
Ricotta's Pizza Niagara
Open Now
$3.00 Delivery
4.8
349 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14201
Excellent pizza, easy online ordering, faster delivery than expected, courteous driver.
Verified Slice Customer • 2/8/2025
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.8
345 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207
The delivery person was also very prompt and very nice
Verified Slice Customer • 9/30/2024
La Nova Pizzeria
Open Now
$7.00 Delivery
4.6
371 W Ferry St, Buffalo, NY 14213
The receipt did not match the costs on the website.
Verified Slice Customer • 3/5/2025
Colosso Taco & Pizza Express
Open Now
$4.00 Delivery
4.2
66 Main St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Wish it came in a smaller portion..
Verified Slice Customer • 1/10/2025
Gino's NY Pizza
Open Now
$4.99 Delivery
4.7
3500 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
Perfect NYC style pizza
Verified Slice Customer • 5/10/2024
Fatman's Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.6
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150
I live in Toronto, and was looking for a Buffalo style pizza while shopping in the area. So glad I found Fatman's pizza! Love the semi sweet sauce, the crust was amazing, and I could not believe how much cheese was on the pizza, it was like triple cheese! So delicious! Will definitely be back!
Verified Slice Customer • 9/29/2024
Olisi's NY Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.5
2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
First time using it. Definitely will be using it again!
Verified Slice Customer • 12/7/2024
Deniro's Pizzeria
Open Now
$3.50 Delivery
4.1
•
10% off
2251 George Urban Blvd, Depew, NY 14043
I asked for utensils and plates- they didn’t come with my pizza. You were delivering to a hotel- of course we require them. Pizza was good. I appreciate the driver delivering in this crap weather/ but initially told me “we were out of plates”. Don’t lie to me. Didn’t offer any remedy- couldn’t wait to run away… and I had tipped the prick 20%. Never again will I order here- and I am here often for work.
Verified Slice Customer • 1/14/2025
JT's Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
4.8
1161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
JT’s is probably the best pizza in my area. On top of that, the customer service is amazing! You feel like you’re one of the friends there. I highly recommend!
Verified Slice Customer • 4/18/2024
Broadway Pizza
Open Now
$5.00 - $6.00 Delivery
4.9
•
5% off
7320 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304
On time and accurate and
Verified Slice Customer • 3/16/2025
La Nova Pizzeria
Open Now
$7.00 Delivery
4.5
5151 Main St, Amherst, NY 14221
Portion was HUGE and so good!
Shelly-Lynn J. • 7/30/2024
Mister Pizza Elmwood
Open Now
$2.75 - $4.75 Delivery
4.4
1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
So happy to find a place to get a fish fry delivered!
Randy R. • 3/9/2025
Carbone's Pizza & Subs
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
4.7
1126 E Lovejoy St, Buffalo, NY 14206
If you want it during a playoff game, be prepared to wait for a longgggg time. We ordered for 545 and I wasn't able to pickup the order until 630. Food was very good wings were perfect so it's worth it if you can wait.
Jennifer S. • 1/20/2025

PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS