365 Atlantic Ave, Freeport, NY 11520
385 S Main St, Freeport, NY 11520
Freeport, New York is a village on Long Island just outside the New York City boroughs of Queens and Brooklyn. Freeport is a pleasant commuter-town for those working in New York City that want a suburban lifestyle. Because Freeport is located directly on Long Island’s south shore, its community has access to beaches, fishing areas, and other outdoor activities.
New York City’s Five Boroughs and surrounding areas are famously associated with the Italian-American community. Freeport has enjoyed a long history of Italian immigration, and their culture and cuisine are integral parts of daily life. Outstanding Italian restaurants, delis, and pizzerias are typical throughout Freeport. Grabbing a slice of New York-style thin-crust pizza while on the go is as common as a family meal carried out from a high-end pizzeria serving Sicilian or other flavorful pizza styles.
One might be surprised that Freeport is known for square-shaped Sicilian pizzas rather than classic New York-style thin-crust. While you will find a classic slice shop all over Freeport, the most prominent pizza style is most certainly Sicilian pizzas. This is partly due to Freeport being further out on Long Island. Unlike the tiny counter-service slice shops in the bustling metropolis of Manhattan, life is a little slower in Freeport, and there is more space for larger kitchens in their pizzerias. This space allows chefs to focus on their square-shaped passions and serve some of New York’s best Sicilian pies.
You can’t blame the local chefs for favoring Sicilian pizza. What’s not to like about crust that is both crispy, crunchy, and chewy? What’s not to love about the most delicious, chunky tomato-based sauce? Sicilian pizza is also much easier to eat than other thick-crust pies. They have tons of toppings, but they aren’t spilling off your plate like a Chicago-style deep dish pizza. A Sicilian pie is substantial and compatible with the casual dining you’ll find in Freeport.
John Anthony’s Neighborhood Pizzeria is a wonderful local spot specializing in classic pizza styles like Neapolitan and Sicilian. These are all heavily inspired by authentic Italian ingredients and are all baked perfectly.
Their Neapolitan pie headlines their menu. This ultra-thin and charred creation is the perfect go-to pizza for any family looking for a simple and delicious centerpiece for their dinner. With tomato sauce this delicious and a perfectly-baked crust, you won’t need toppings. But, their basil and Italian sausage are impeccable additions to this pie. If you’re looking for some greens, their Primavera Pizza is topped with mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, and fresh-plum tomatoes. They have a full menu of Sicilian-style pizzas with every topping from Baked Ziti to Artichokes to BBQ Chicken. All of these are crisped perfectly, with a pillowy focaccia-like chewiness in the middle.
There are also must-try selections of Italian entrees, subs for the lunch crowd, and freshly-baked desserts. Order John Anthony’s Neighborhood Pizza with Slice to get the best pizza in Freeport delivered right to your door.
Montana Brothers is a local restaurant and pizzeria focusing on authentic Italian pizza styles. Their Sicilian Pizza and Stuffed Pizza are excellent options for hungry customers. Their Eggplant Parmigiana is a purist’s favorite.
While their flagship pizza might not be prepared by your grandmother, their Grandma Pizza is an absolute must-try. This Long Island cultural landmark is similar to a Sicilian-style pizza, but with the sauce on top of the cheese. They also bake a traditional Margherita Pizza to absolute perfection. We are talking the freshest basil, the finest mozzarella, and the doughiest charred crust.
A pizzeria in New York would not be complete without a by-the-slice option. Their pizzas tend to be more artisanal and substantial, but having an option for customers on the go is vital in Freeport. This is also an excellent way to add to your whole order.
The chefs at Mario’s Pizza in nearby Oceanside are obsessed with recreating classic Italian flavors and dishes in pizza form. Their Eggplant Pizza is inspired by the iconic eggplant parmigiana dish and can be loaded with ricotta cheese. They offer a massive All The Way Sicilian Pizza that comes with twelve slices. Because it’s Long Island, they’ve mastered the art of Grandma Pizza for good measure. They also have a full Brick Oven Pizza menu for those who crave some charred crust.
Bonbino’s Pizza is a no-frills pizzeria that has counter service, an old-time New York vibe, and some of the best pizza options in Rockville Centre. They love square-shaped pizza at Bonbino’s. Grandma pizza is an excellent option if you’re a sauce aficionado, and their stuffed pizza comes in a square as well. Their Sicilian pizza is one of their most famous dishes. It’s loaded with cheese and has one of the crunchiest outer crusts you’ll ever find.
Tomato & Basil in nearby Merrick specializes in classic thin-crust options inspired by pasta dishes. The menu is headlined by their Baked Ziti Pizza, using the iconic tomato-based sauce from the pasta dish to create one of the town’s best pizzas. Pizza Alla Vodka, Eggplant Rollatini Pizza, and even Chicken Marsala Pizza are all options for those that can’t quite choose between pasta and pizza. Of course, there is a Grandma pizza on the menu as well.
Q: What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Freeport?
Q: What restaurant has the best Sicilian pizza in Freeport?
Q: What restaurant has the best Grandma pizza in Freeport?
Q: What restaurant has the best Neapolitan pizza in Freeport?