Find Local Pizza in Garden City, New York

Garden City is considered to be one of the best places to live in New York. The area is a dense suburb, with plenty of restaurants, cafes, bars, and pizzerias. You’ll also get to experience many parks in the area.

Many people in Garden City are always on the move. That makes pizza delivery a popular option for people during the week. It’s easy to sit down and have a relaxing dinner with the family when you can order something delicious.

Pizza first came to Garden City not long after it debuted in NYC after WWII. It spread quickly throughout the state and remains one of the most popular dishes in the area today.

If you want to try something delicious, make sure to stick around! There are plenty of wonderful pizzerias in Garden City, NY that can satisfy your cravings for good pizza.

Top Pizza Restaurants in Garden City Near You

caret icon

Enzo's Pizzeria Restaurant logo
4.9filled star icon(1413)
$1.00 Delivery
Order Online

Garden City Pizza logo
4.8filled star icon(360)
Free Delivery
Order Online

Pizza Supreme logo
5% Off Online
4.9filled star icon(1181)
Free Delivery
Order Online

Grimaldi's Pizzeria logo
4.7filled star icon(284)
$3.45 Delivery
Order Online

Olivos Mediterranean Bar & Grill logo
5% Off Online
$2.95 Delivery
Order Online

Calogero's logo
View Menu

Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian logo
View Menu

Garden City is Known For New York Style Pizza

With Garden City being so close to New York, it makes sense that the area would enjoy a classic New York slice the most. This style features a large and thin hand-tossed crust. The pie is so massive that the slices are usually sold individually instead of as a whole.

The crust is chewy and very easy to fold in half. The pie also can come with a variety of different toppings, although mozzarella and pepperoni are the most popular options.

There are so many different options in Garden City, NY when it comes to finding New York-style slices. You’ll have fun taste-testing all of the delicious slices in the area. Overall, you’ll have a lot of options when it comes to choosing your new favorite pizzeria!

Make sure to stick with Slice. We’ll help you find all the best local options.

Best Delivery Pizza in Garden City

Do you want some of the best pizza delivery in Garden City? Make sure to order from Garden City Pizza. They offer free delivery and have amazing services. The team there always makes sure your food is cooked to perfection. Plus, they have plenty of toppings and pizza styles to choose from.

The menu options are also very creative and you receive large portions with your order. Customers greatly enjoyed the Greek Salad Pizza and the Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza- both come piled high with toppings!

The restaurant has a very fast delivery time as well. You can be confident that you receive your meal promptly after ordering with us online. We make sure they receive your order immediately. The staff at this pizzeria are very hardworking and will have your order to you right away. So, if you’re hungry right now, they are one of the places to order from in the area.

Best Takeout Pizza in Garden City

Are you looking for some delicious pizza takeout instead? Enzo’s Pizza Restaurant has amazing options on their menu. Customers love their veal parm sandwiches and many of their other sides. They also enjoy the crust the pizzeria uses on their pies.

The food will always be ready earlier than you think, making it a great option for many people. You can order ahead with Slice, then pick up your food while you’re already out. Many regulars will even order takeout on their lunch breaks.

The restaurant is well known for being one of the best Italian places in the immediate area. Next time you're craving pizza or pasta, make sure to place an order. We’re confident that you’ll enjoy your takeout! The cooks will have it ready for you quickly- all you need to do is pick it up.

Pizza Near Garden City

New York City

New York City is full of many wonderful, unique pizzerias. If you want to travel the short distance to the city, you can experience a variety of slices. You will want to try out Joe’s Pizza, if you haven’t already. The location has been in business since 1975 and the original owner, who’s from Naples, still runs the store! So, if you’re looking for a classic NY slice, this is it.

Jersey City, NJ

Abbondanza Trattoria, on 257 Grand Street, uses an authentic brick oven to prepare their dishes. The restaurant also has plenty of other Italian foods, on top of their pizza menu. They have all the classic pies, including Sicilian and Margheritas. Plus, they offer many specials.

Newark, NJ

If you want the best pizza in Newark, you’ll need to stop by Nico's Kitchen & Bar. The restaurant offers some of the best crust, cheese, and toppings around. Many customers also enjoy the sit-down environment.


Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best vegetarian-friendly pizza in Garden City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Garden City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Sicilian pizza in Garden City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Grandma pizza in Garden City?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Pizza Types in Garden City

Even More Types of Food in Garden City

Areas of Garden City

Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Garden City, NY