Top Pizza Restaurants in Hampton Bays, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Hampton Bays: a local guide

The area that is present-day Hampton Bays was settled in 1740 and called Good Ground. As part of Good Ground, there were ten other hamlets in the area, each settled by one or two families. The region began to attract tourists and vacationers in the 1900s, thanks of course, to the bays and beaches that surround it – Tiana and Shinnecock bays to the south, and Peconic Bay to the north. As you’d naturally expect, Hampton Bays is a fascinating destination for recreation, especially in summer, because of the water bodies that border the hamlet which offer plenty of opportunities for water sports. Ponquogue Beach, Meschutt Beach, Tiana Beach, and Peconic Bay are among the top sites to visit here. Other interesting places to spend time with family and/or friends here are Sear Bellows County Park and the Old Ponquogue Bridge.

Hampton Bays is known for Sicilian pizza

Every visitor in Hampton Bays that’s curious to find out the particular type of pizza that the residents of the hamlet are crazy about realizes very early on that it’s Sicilian pizza for the locals. There’s even talk about the fact that this may be a pointer to the origin of the Italians that moved into the area from surrounding regions during the early days. Interestingly though, there are other pizza styles available in the hamlet – New York pizza, Neapolitan pizza, grandma pizza, stuffed pizza, and so on, that give the frequent tourists and guests in the hamlet plenty of options to choose from while here. The chefs in the hamlet stick, as much as possible, to the traditional recipes for the Sicilian pies so that everyone gets to enjoy authentic pies anytime they’re craving the thick crust square pie. Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce are the first-choice ingredients on the pie, while toppings are abundant.

Best Delivery Pizza in Hampton Bays

It’s an absolutely delightful feeling knowing that you can be in your living room, place an order for your preferred pie, and literally count down till delivery because you’re sure the food will arrive right on time. If you’re in Hampton Bays, that’s what you enjoy every time you patronize the amazing team at Francesca’s Pizza & Restaurant on Ponquogue Avenue. At this family-run restaurant, prompt delivery is non-negotiable as that’s exactly what they stand for. In addition to the excellent delivery service that Francesca’s is known for in the hamlet, they have an extensive pizza menu that consists of delicious blends of Sicilian pie, regular cheese pizza, stuffed meat pizza, etc., all of which are delicately prepared and full of rich and fresh ingredients. What can beat eating this hot and yummy delicacy in your comfort zone? You should be placing an order for yours on Slice.

Best Takeout Pizza in Hampton Bays

West Montauk Highway is one of those routes in Hampton Bays that gets a lot of traffic because of Salvatores Of The Hamptons that lies on the highway. Salvatores, being the most fancied pizzeria for takeout in the hamlet, attracts plenty of residents, particularly those that are up and about in the area and are looking to quickly grab lunch or dinner while still on the road. The restaurant cooks their pies with wood-fired ovens and you’ll find numerous pies here including Naples-style pies, Margherita pizza, grandma pizza, Philly cheesesteak pizza, and so on. With its beautiful inside décor and outside seating, folks never really worry about spending a little more time waiting for their takeout pizza. Of course, placing an order ahead on Slice saves you this wait time, so feel free to do just that. The pizzeria is a gem and the food is a treat.

Best Pizza Near Hampton Bays

Westhampton Beach

Head over to the village of Westhampton Beach, southwest of Hampton Bays for a refreshing family vacation that presents diverse opportunities to play, laugh, and bond. Whether it’s by the village’s beaches, at the library, along the scenic trails, or at the village’s events and concerts, you’re in for a wonderful time. There are great restaurants with delicious food here too, one of which is 103 Bambinos Pizzeria, the home of traditional Neapolitan pies, White Pizza, and Salad Pizza.


As the oldest and largest community in the Hamptons, the village of Southampton welcomes young and old to explore its several attractions and pursue mind-blowing adventures. The village was settled in 1640 and is renowned as the first permanent English settlement in the State. When you’re ready to eat, the place to go is Melrose East Restaurant & Pizza on County Road 39, and you should prepare for a delectable meal because they’ve got the most amazing thin-crust pies.


Sitting on the mouth of the Peconic River, the town of Riverhead is a famous agricultural community on Long Island that features four separate beaches, each of which is open year-round to visitors for exciting activities. Moreover, the town offers additional recreation opportunities for those willing to explore Hallock State Park Preserve, Wildwood State Park, and Indian Island County Park. As for foodies, Rocco’s Pizza & Pasta on Old Country Road is the answer to your pizza cravings.

show more iconSee More



Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Hampton Bays, NY