Top Pizza Restaurants in Island Park, NY in 2026 Near You
Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.
Mustachio's Pizzeria
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.92701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
Always consistent and the staff are always polite Order was on time !Gregory S. • 8/5/2026
Colosso Taco & Pizza Express
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.966 Main St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
We order every week and today on the random tuesday, it was absolutely out of this world. THANK YOU! It was DELICIOUS! We love you guys!Jillian R. • 8/4/2026
Gino's NY Pizza
Open Now$4.99 Delivery4.83500 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
I didn't order anchovies, I ordered pepperoni, lol. I didn't know people even actually put real anchovies on pizza anymoreKelly Y. • 8/6/2026
The Wurlitzer Pizza
Open Now$5.50 Delivery4.81401 Nash Rd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
love the vegan optionsAlison S. • 7/13/2026Olisi's NY Pizza
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.92352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
BEST pizza in town!Niagara T. • 8/4/2026
Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood
Open Now$3.50 Delivery4.71009 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Love it!Sarah A. • 7/28/2026
Broadway Pizza
Open Now$5.00 - $6.00 Delivery4.9•5% off7320 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304
Best pizza place in townGary F. • 8/7/2026
JT's Pizza
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.91161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Best local place to meLouise H. • 7/12/2026
Fatman's Pizza
Open Now$6.50 Delivery4.82712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Best Hungarian hot pepper pizza I’ve had in a long time Anthony K. • 7/27/2026
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.692 Niagara St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
the canzone was delicious but I ordered extra meatballs and there wasn't any meatballs in itLois B. • 7/24/2026
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.8345 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY 14207
I eat at Joes pretty regularly by the slice. I liked the pizza flavor but it wasn’t a joes NY style pizza. It was thicker than usual and doughy. It wasn’t thin and crispy like usual. I also ordered extra mushrooms and on four of the slices I could only find 2 mushrooms. Love the pizza but this one wasn’t it.Verified Slice Customer • 3/17/2026
Sports City Pizza Pub
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.51407 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14213
Food is amazing as always. Honey bbq wings are out of this world! Best in the city!Louis G. • 1/24/2026
La Nova Pizzeria
Open Now$7.00 Delivery4.1371 W Ferry St, Buffalo, NY 14213
Both pizzas we ordered were practically burnt on top, and its not the first time. This is very upsetting when paying $40 for a pizzacarrie C. • 7/5/2026
Submaster
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.6•5% off105 Main St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
My sub was drenched with oil when I only requested mayo :( and you guys are usually really good about not doing that kind of thingVictoria B. • 7/25/2026Forno Napoli
Open Now$6.90 Delivery4.7•5% off1280 Sweet Home Rd, Buffalo, NY 14228
love your foodLindsay M. • 8/7/2026
PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS
Open on New Year's Eve
•Pick Up Restaurants Near You
•Pizza Deals Near You
•Pizza Near You
•Pizza Restaurants Open Now
•Open on Christmas
•Open on Thanksgiving
•Open on Veterans Day
•Free Pizza Delivery Near You
•Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day
•Open on Labor Day
•Open on Independence Day
•Open on New Year's Day
•Open on Memorial Day
•Black Friday Pizza Deals
•