Top Pizza Restaurants in Middle Island, NY in 2026 Near You
Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.
Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.6•5% off39 College Plaza, Selden, NY 11784
The mozzarella cheese was dry on the mozzarella saladChristina S. • 11/28/2025
Rocky Point Pizza
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.9•5% off279 NY-25A, Rocky Point, NY 11778
..great food, great people. dependable and delicious.nanci T. • 1/24/2026
Pizzeria Los Amigos
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.7351 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY 11967
delivery driver was amazing!!Colleen M. • 1/19/2026
Old Town Pizza
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.8691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Pizza was burnt on the bottom, the delivery driver was deplorable.Michelle B. • 7/17/2025
Prisco's Gourmet
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.71355 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950
Love you guys!Lisa B. • 11/11/2025
Hero Haven Pizza & More
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.8•10% off478 Neighborhood Rd, Shirley, NY 11967
Great pizza forgot the dipping sauce for the garlic knots other than that food was 5 out of 5M C. • 9/27/2025
Colin's Deli
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.7132 Colin Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
I always loved Colin's been going over 20 yearsJennifer F. • 1/24/2026
Albert's Pizza
Open NowPickup Only4.9•5% off601 Portion Rd, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
always a good experience and meal at AlbertsCraig R. • 1/23/2026
Giovanni's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Closed$2.00 Delivery4.6•10% off522 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772
The grandma pizza was delicious. The order was accurate, the service was great and the delivery on point.Vanina P. • 1/25/2026
Rocco's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Closed$3.00 Delivery4.85507 NY-347, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
We love it.Eric W. • 1/17/2026
Zara's Pizza & Restaurant
Closed$4.25 Delivery4.8365 Boyle Rd, Selden, NY 11784
Great PizzaNancy M. • 1/10/2026
Salvino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Closed$2.00 Delivery4.9•5% off638 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784
AmazingConnor A. • 1/17/2026
Pellegrino's Pizza
Closed$3.00 Delivery4.9•5% off99 NY-25A, Shoreham, NY 11786
Always great.John K. • 1/22/2026
Alvarez Pizza
ClosedFree Delivery4.98 W 1st St, Patchogue, NY 11772
I haven’t received my orderAnnaLisa R. • 12/20/2025
Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria
ClosedFree - $5.00 Delivery4.9•10% off374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738
ExcellentAlyssa K. • 1/25/2026
Frequently Asked Questions
PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS
Open on New Year's Eve
•Pick Up Restaurants Near You
•Pizza Deals Near You
•Pizza Near You
•Pizza Restaurants Open Now
•Open on Christmas
•Open on Thanksgiving
•Open on Veterans Day
•Free Pizza Delivery Near You
•Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day
•Open on Labor Day
•Open on Independence Day
•Open on New Year's Day
•Open on Memorial Day
•Black Friday Pizza Deals
•