Top Pizza Restaurants in Middle Island, NY in 2026 Near You
Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.
Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.9•5% off39 College Plaza, Selden, NY 11784
The mozzarella cheese was dry on the mozzarella saladChristina S. • 11/28/2025
Brunello's Pizza & Pasta of Smithtown
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.8•10% off60 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787
always deliciousMichael U. • 2/10/2026
Mama Lisa Restaurant
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.81226 Montauk Highway, Mastic, NY 11950
love Mama Lisa Restaurant. Always delicious.Kathryn P. • 12/23/2025
Villa Grazia
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.9•5% off1665 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720
love Villa Grazia!! only downfall is its a little pricy compared to everyone else in the areaChristina M. • 2/14/2026
Rocky Point Pizza
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.9•5% off279 NY-25A, Rocky Point, NY 11778
Consistently Good , reasonable prices … Recommend to All in my town , Mount SinaiRobert C. • 2/8/2026
Medford Pastaria
Open NowFree Delivery4.4•5% off3209 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY 11763
It took an hour and 40 minutes to deliver and the food is ice cold.Joshua M. • 2/11/2026
Pizzeria Los Amigos
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.8351 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY 11967
amazingKevin M. • 1/28/2026
Stony Brook Pizza
Open Now$2.50 Delivery4.82460 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790
Everything is always soooo fresh👍🏻 thank youSalvatore V. • 2/11/2026
Vincenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Open Now$3.00 - $5.00 Delivery4.9343 Route 25A, Miller Place, NY 11764
Old Town Pizza
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.8691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Pizza was burnt on the bottom, the delivery driver was deplorable.Michelle B. • 7/17/2025
Carlito's Pizzeria
Open Now$1.99 - $2.99 Delivery4.525 E Patchogue Yaphank Rd, East Patchogue, NY 11772
Never received my order, called restaurant multiple times and no response.Mely F. • 2/7/2026
Renzo's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.837 Route 25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Food was barley warmDenise C. • 12/28/2025
Anthony's Pizza
Open Now$4.95 Delivery4.9520 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach, NY 11951
That woman knows I how to cookAdam B. • 1/8/2026JC Pizzeria
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.755 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY 11967
Good pizza!Verified Slice Customer • 2/2/2026
Matt's Pizza
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.925 Gibbs Rd, Coram, NY 11727
Delivery driver super nice everytime he comes here! Thank you all so much for this delish pizzaLou R. • 12/8/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS
Open on New Year's Eve
•Pick Up Restaurants Near You
•Pizza Deals Near You
•Pizza Near You
•Pizza Restaurants Open Now
•Open on Christmas
•Open on Thanksgiving
•Open on Veterans Day
•Free Pizza Delivery Near You
•Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day
•Open on Labor Day
•Open on Independence Day
•Open on New Year's Day
•Open on Memorial Day
•Black Friday Pizza Deals
•