Top Pizza Restaurants in Middle Island, NY in 2026 Near You
Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.
.png?auto=format&fit=max&q=10){kind=logo}
Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria
Open NowFree - $5.00 Delivery4.9374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738
I have always liked their pizza but the last 3 times I ordered it was dry, burnt and cold when I got it.Michele A. • 8/7/2026
Rocco's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.95507 NY-347, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Love them. Always good and freshCathy D. • 8/9/2026
Albert's Pizza
Open Now$3.00 - $7.00 Delivery4.8•5% off601 Portion Rd, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Fresh and delicious!Verified Slice Customer • 8/17/2026
Bella Roma Ristorante Pizza
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.8•5% off264 Middle Country Rd, Coram, NY 11727
very good.Ed K. • 6/18/2026
Giovanni's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.9•5% off522 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772
You guys are greatdawn D. • 8/11/2026
Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.8•5% off39 College Plaza, Selden, NY 11784
Thank you!Stacy R. • 8/4/2026
Salvino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.9•5% off638 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784
Everything we’ve ordered is just delicious!Teri L. • 8/19/2026
Medford Pastaria
Open NowFree Delivery4.6•10% off3209 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY 11763
Great Pizza 🍕Lisa C. • 7/25/2026
Setauket Pastaria
Open Now$2.50 Delivery4.74082 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket-East Setauket, NY 11733
Always great food and fast delivery. Setauket Pastaria is my go to for pizza and Italian food. Five stars.Phyllis C. • 7/5/2026
Marinelli's Pizzeria
Open NowFree - $3.00 Delivery4.8257 Echo Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789
Fast delivery and excellent pizza!Carlo I. • 8/2/2026
Zara's Pizza & Restaurant
Open Now$4.25 - $4.95 Delivery4.8365 Boyle Rd, Selden, NY 11784
Always goodEddie C. • 8/19/2026
Rocky Point Pizza
Open Now$4.00 Delivery4.9•5% off279 NY-25A, Rocky Point, NY 11778
Everything is always excellent, especially the eggplant!Lauren K. • 6/22/2026
Villa Grazia
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.8•5% off1665 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720
I ordered plain wings I got a spicy and the wings were very over done fried tater like oil and the french fries looked like they served me someone leftovers and same as the wings the french fries were well done and oil soaked. Chicken fingers were well doLinda J. • 6/21/2026
Spuntino St James
Open Now$5.00 Delivery4.9•5% off420 N Country Rd, St James, NY 11780
The quality of the food was very good but the size of the pizza was extremely small for the price chargedJasmin C. • 5/27/2026.png?auto=format&fit=max&q=10)
St. James Pizza & Pasta
Open Now$3.00 Delivery5348 Lake Ave, St James, NY 11780
great every time.Fred Y. • 4/10/2026
PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS
Open on New Year's Eve
•Pick Up Restaurants Near You
•Pizza Deals Near You
•Pizza Near You
•Pizza Restaurants Open Now
•Open on Christmas
•Open on Thanksgiving
•Open on Veterans Day
•Free Pizza Delivery Near You
•Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day
•Open on Labor Day
•Open on Independence Day
•Open on New Year's Day
•Open on Memorial Day
•Black Friday Pizza Deals
•