Top Pizza Restaurants in Middle Island, NY in 2026 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Middle Island Pizza
Closed
$4.95 Delivery
5
586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953

Rocco's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Closed
$3.00 Delivery
4.9
5507 NY-347, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Love them. Always good and fresh
Cathy D. • 8/9/2026
Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria
Closed
Free - $5.00 Delivery
4.9
374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY 11738
Delicious!
Teri L. • 10/3/2026
Bella Roma Ristorante Pizza
Closed
$4.00 Delivery
4.8
•
5% off
264 Middle Country Rd, Coram, NY 11727
Food was not made and had to return for a second trip.
Chris M. • 9/25/2026
Pellegrino's Pizza
Closed
$3.00 Delivery
4.9
•
5% off
99 NY-25A, Shoreham, NY 11786
Love it
Donald B. • 10/16/2026
Albert's Pizza
Closed
$3.00 - $7.00 Delivery
5
•
5% off
601 Portion Rd, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Always a great experience.
Alaina F. • 10/2/2026
Giovanni's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
4.9
•
5% off
522 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772
There was an error with my order and everyone was so cooperative in fixing it
Susan S. • 10/5/2026
Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros
Closed
$3.00 Delivery
4.8
•
5% off
39 College Plaza, Selden, NY 11784
No yogurt sauce provided for chicken gyro platter !!
Jennifer W. • 10/16/2026
Zara's Pizza & Restaurant
Closed
$4.25 - $4.95 Delivery
4.9
365 Boyle Rd, Selden, NY 11784
Excellent food
AnnMarie M. • 9/30/2026
Medford Pastaria
Closed
Free Delivery
4.9
•
10% off
3209 Horseblock Rd, Medford, NY 11763
Delicious!!!
Teri L. • 10/18/2026
Setauket Pastaria
Closed
$2.50 Delivery
4.6
4082 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket-East Setauket, NY 11733
Driver and food excellent
Verified Slice Customer • 10/17/2026
Marinelli's Pizzeria
Closed
Free - $3.00 Delivery
4.8
257 Echo Ave, Sound Beach, NY 11789
Love the food! Great quality and good prices! Proportions are very good!
Suzanne S. • 10/16/2026
Salvino's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
4.8
•
5% off
638 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784
The pizza crust is very dry, like too much flour on it. Not enough cheese on the pizza but the meatballs were tasty
Tammy S. • 10/11/2026
Mama Lisa Restaurant
Closed
$4.00 Delivery
4.8
1226 Montauk Highway, Mastic, NY 11950
Great food
judy C. • 10/10/2026
Vincenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Closed
$3.00 - $5.00 Delivery
4.9
343 Route 25A, Miller Place, NY 11764
Best pizza parlor on Long Island
Theodore P. • 5/10/2026
Villa Grazia
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
4.9
•
5% off
1665 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720
Was missing extra dressing that I paid for and lettuce was brown.
Victor U. • 9/12/2026

PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS