Find Pizza Near You in Middletown, New York

Middletown is a city with a unique and rich history, with thousands of its residents having Italian heritage tracing back to the late 1800s to the Sicilian town of Melilli. With them, their stories of immigration and proud Italian heritage have brought about a great mix of culture, cuisine and the now close community of Italian Americans that reside today in Middletown. And with that of course comes the authenticity and bold flavors of the Italian American cuisine, which features heavily amongst many of the restaurants within this area and in the favor of local residents. This city certainly isn't called Little Melilli for nothing! Enjoy the traditional tastes of Italy right here in Middletown New York!

Recommended Pizzerias in Middletown

caret icon

Marco's Pizza logo

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant logo

Fuentes Wood Fired Pizza & Italian Restaurant logo

Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar logo

Badabing Pizza & Pasta logo


Pizzerias in Middletown with Discounts

caret icon

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant logo

Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar logo

Sicilian Delight logo

Yani's Pizza logo

Tony Boffa's Restaurant logo


Pizzerias in Middletown with Fastest Delivery

caret icon

Marco's Pizza logo

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant logo

Fuentes Wood Fired Pizza & Italian Restaurant logo

Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar logo

Badabing Pizza & Pasta logo


Pizzerias in Middletown with Free Delivery

caret icon

Badabing Pizza & Pasta logo

Bella Lena's logo

Yovani's Pizza logo

Pecorinos Pizzeria & Restaurant logo

Joey's Pizza logo


Favorite pizza in Middletown NY

Fond of everything from the creative to the classic Italian American creations of pepperoni and meat lovers pizzas and everything beyond, there is certainly no shortage of delicious pizza in Middletown. But of course, in a city with a history and culture as rich as this, pride and authenticity go into every bite. From over-the-counter pizzerias to upscale sit-down restaurants, you certainly won't struggle to find an authentic Sicilian pie, wood-fired or stone-baked to perfection and topped with all the quality ingredients and traditional flavors of Italy

Best pizza for delivery in Middletown NY

For when you're craving a bite (or 10!) of rich and cheesy pizza, you certainly don't want to wait a second longer than you have to. Luckily with Marco's Pizza, you’re promised all that and more. Here you can choose everything from specialty pizzas to a perfectly pan-baked pie, pizza by the slice, and you can even make that jumbo slice for when you just can't wait to get your hands on a real treat like Marco's Pizza! Offering so many luxurious options from local favorite Sicilian cheese pizzas to deep-dish pies packed with all the best ingredients ranging from traditional combinations of salami, sausage, mushrooms, pepperoni, mozzarella and so many more, to more creative pies such as the Taco pizza that are guaranteed to fill your every craving!

Best pizza for takeout in Middletown New York

Proudly serving satisfied customers since 1980, Colandrea Pizza King has remained a family-owned and operated business since its very beginning. And with that family feel comes the warm and welcoming taste of home. With every pie baked with love, it is no wonder that this pizzeria was voted the best pizza in the Hudson Valley by K104.7 and Times Herald Record readers. With an extensive menu offering a wide array of Italian delights from rolls to calzones, cheese steaks to cold heroes (a well loved sandwich) to of course everybody's favorite, their perfected pizza pies! And these pizzas certainly are perfection! Specializing in Neapolitan pizza, you'll have the option to choose from any of the delicious and high-quality toppings such as sausage, mushroom, meatballs, pepperoni, green peppers, bacon, broccoli, and so much more. Or if you're not in the mood to create your own and would rather leave your meal in the capable hands of Colandrea Pizza King, fear not! They have the perfect selection for you, try one of their specialty pies today!

Best pizza near Middletown New York

Best pizza near Port Jervis NY


Residents of Port Jervis are fans of the traditional and the classic Italian American New York-style pizza, and here Port Jervis Brick Oven Pizza you can get an awesome mix of both! With traditional thin-crust pizzas baked to perfection in the brick ovens, you’re guaranteed that staple crunch of an authentic Italian pizza with all the flavor and familiarity of classic New York-style slices. Here you'll find everything from meat lovers pizza to the chicken Alfredo to the simple and perfected Margarita - don't miss out !

Best pizza near Kiryas Joel New York


Eataly is the place to go if you want a local favorite that is highly reviewed, and for good reason! With all manner of Italian treats from calzoni to Stromboli, you certainly won't leave here hungry! Choose from classic options of Margarita, vegetarian, and specialty pizza so by the slice. Or for something more filling - a real treat sink your teeth into is their stuffed pizza slice which is packed to the crust with scrumptious flavor!

Best pizza near West Milford NJ


For the best-tasting pizza in West Milford NJ, it's gotta be Frank's pizza! Rated 4.6 stars by local residents, Franks continues to serve some of the best pizza in West Milford. Offering of course all the classics, such as a rich Margarita made with the freshest ingredients and a snappable thin crust baked to perfection so you can taste quality in every bite! Or for something more hearty, the meat lovers’ pizza comes topped with everybody's favorite combination of pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, mozzarella, and onions. Try one of Frank's pizzas today!

Best pizza near Beacon NY


Sal's Pizza and Pasta is here for you when hunger strikes! As it has been for the residents of Beacon New York for years, proudly earning itself a spot as one of the top-rated pizzerias in the city. Sal's Pizza and Pasta offers exactly what they say, but what they won't tell you is that every bite is full of mouth-watering flavor- they let their pizza speak for themselves! With gourmet pizzas such as these it's not hard to understand, whatever choice you make be it the grilled chicken Caesar pie, the white pie, the stuffed meat or pesto pie, or even something a little bit more out of the box like Sal’s shrimp scampi pizza, you know you’re in for a treat!

FAQ

Q: 🍕Where can the best Sicilian pizza be found in Middletown NY?

caret icon

Q: 🍕Where can the best Neapolitan pizza be found in Middletown NY?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What pizzeria has the best veggie pizza?

caret icon

Q: 🍕Where can the best stuffed crust pizza be found?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App
Slicechevron right iconAll Citieschevron right icon Restaurants in Middletown