Find Local Pizza in Mineola, NY

Mineola gets its name from an Algonquin Chief and roughly translates to “pleasant village.” This name sums up the town perfectly. Located on Long Island, the main population of the town is middle age, and it’s an ideal place to raise a family within commuting distance to NYC.

Mineola has a decent combination between upscale restaurants and street food to satisfy the tastes of its residents and tourists. Pizzerias and food chains try as much as possible to provide both services to suit the needs of the people. The Annual Italian Festival at Tully Park is a five-day festival showcasing Italian heritage and culture while attracting more than 25,000 people. Apart from carnival rides, the festival features lots of music and a funfair. It hosts multiple food vendors with famous Italian and international cuisine, including pizza, sausages, hot dogs, and burgers.

Mineola is Known for New York-style Pizza

Like most things in Mineola, the pizza scene is growing every day. There are chefs and families in the city that have been making pies for decades, so progress and innovation are only natural. There is something for everybody in the city, from Chicago-style deep-dish to New York-style to classic Neapolitan personal pizzas.

Mineola has its fair share of upscale pizzerias, and New York-style pies seem to be the most popular in the city. However, those searching for Chicago-style, deep-dish, even Detroit-style pizzas can easily satisfy their cravings.

Neapolitan pizza gave birth to New York-style pizza when the Italian immigrants brought pizza into New York in the early 20th century. New York-style pizza has wide and long slices with a foldable and crispy thin crust. New York-style pies are traditionally topped with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce. Luckily, if you like additional toppings, pizzerias in Mineola offer you plenty of choices.

Best Delivery Pizza in Mineola

Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant is a full-service Italian restaurant in Mineola that combines the finest ingredients with the best service to give you an unforgettable experience. Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant’s cozy atmosphere welcomes diners to enjoy a wide variety of soups, salads, wood-fired pizzas, and desserts. With their locally sourced ingredients, rest assured that you get nothing but the best here.

Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant is perfect for you no matter the occasion. It can accommodate those looking for a casual night out with friends or even a romantic dinner with a partner. Starting with their Neapolitan Cheese Pizza is a must. You can also try out their Sicilian pies to get that classic Italian feel. At Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant, guests have the opportunity to create their own or choose from a long list of flavorful combinations. The unique Italian flare and delicious dishes demonstrate why this restaurant is a pillar of the pizza community in Mineola.

Best Takeout Pizza in Mineola

Taglio Pizza is a family-friendly restaurant that serves the best square Roman-style and round New York-style pizza. You can enjoy wood-fired pizzas cooked with the best ingredients at Taglio Pizza. Pair a pizza with something from their excellent beverage selection for a great night out. On the other hand, this is a great place when you just want to pick up your meal and go. The orders are prepared quickly and accurately. They’ll have you on your way in no time!

The Margherita Pizza is a popular selection with fresh mozzarella, marinara sauce, and fragrant basil. Don't miss the Buffalo Chicken Pizza with crispy buffalo chicken, blue cheese dressing, and mozzarella cheese. The atmosphere is laid-back, with a low-light setting.

Visitors adore the pizza but keep coming because of the comfort food and quick bite options perfect for takeout. Apart from takeout, they also offer delivery and dine-in service options.

Best Pizza Near Mineola

Garden City

Less than two miles from Mineola, Garden City is a village in the Town of Hampstead. As the name suggests, it is an area rich in agriculture and home to over 300 different kinds of animals. Enzo’s Pizzeria Restaurant is a family-friendly restaurant with a menu based on cooking with fire, including calzones and their specialty pies. The key to their widespread critical acclaim is their high-quality ingredients and quality staff.

Westbury

You can find Vito’s Pizzeria just three miles from Mineola. Vito’s Pizzeria is an upscale pizzeria with a menu filled with great options for everyone. One good thing about Vito’s Pizzeria is the fact that its ingredients are locally sourced. They go out of their way to ensure they get the best for customers. Sure, the pies taste amazing, but you’ll feel even better knowing the ingredients are healthy and haven’t traveled very far to get on your pizza.

Hampstead

Hampstead is one of the three towns in Nassau County alongside Garden City and Mineola. Hampstead is home to some top pizzerias like Bella Pizza Carry-Out And Delivery. Bella Pizza Carry-Out And Delivery combines classical Italian-style pizza with original toppings that will fully satisfy your cravings. In every single pie, you can feel the creativity and originality. They also offer a great selection of beverages and have the best staff. What else do you need?