Find Pizza Near You in New City, New York

When Dutch pioneers navigated up the Hudson River they came across Coe's Tavern and after they'd stopped for refreshment there they took a liking to the surrounding area with its lakes and forests and decided to settle there. They called their settlement New City, but its relatively isolated location meant its growth was slow until well into the 1950s. It was only when a bridge was built over the Tappan Zee section of the Hudson River and the Palisades Parkway was completed that New City became more accessible. It may have seemed a minor progression at the time, but it was one that turned New City into a commuter town. People began to relocate to New City from larger towns nearby as well as from across the state border in New Jersey. While New City still remains mostly residential, it's a town with a population large enough to keep those in the hospitality industry well occupied, including the Italians who moved there to open their pizzerias.

Recommended Pizzerias in New City

caret icon

Paisano's Pizzeria logo
4.8filled star icon(330)
Open Now
Free Delivery
Order Online

Ray's Pizza & Restaurant logo
5% Off Online
4.9filled star icon(733)
Open Now
Free - $2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Rocco's Family Restaurant logo
View Menu

Ella New York Pizza & Pasta logo
View Menu

New City Pizza logo
4.9filled star icon(1556)
Closed
Free Delivery
Order Online

Napoli's Pizza logo
10% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(1209)
Closed
$1.00 Delivery
Order Online

Pakula's Pizza logo
4.7filled star icon(34)
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Calabria Restaurant logo
5% Off Online
4.6filled star icon(21)
Closed
$3.00 Delivery
Order Online

Danny's Pizza & Deli logo
4.6filled star icon(12)
Closed
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Norcina logo
View Menu

shop icon
View Menu


New City in New York is known for thick crust pizza

New City is known for thick crust pizza, but saying that isn't the end of the story in this New York state town. There's one thing you'll soon notice about the thick crust pizzas in New City and that is they come in a surprising array of different shapes and sizes. Browse through the menus of the pizzerias in New City and you'll discover square pizzas, round pizzas, and heart-shaped pizza. You'll find ones that vary in size from large Sicilian-style pies to mini pizzettes suitable for one person and even some that are the size of a coffee cup saucer that are just great for little kids or party finger food. Do the pizzerias in New City bake only thick crust pizzas? No, they don't. They love to serve thin-crust too and the thinner and crispier they can get it, the better.

Best delivery pizza in New City, New York

Pakula's Pizza have been dishing out amazing pizzas for over six years and their customers happily agree that they make the best delivery pizzas in New City. They may be a smallish pizza joint but their pies are prepared with care, loaded to the max with ingredients, and dispatched as soon as they come out of the oven. That means they always arrive absolutely piping hot the same as if it was being served at a table. Pakula's Pizza do have a few tables in their premises on South Little Tor Road but their main trade is concentrated on take-outs and deliveries. That could be because the locals of New City prefer to stay at home and enjoy Pakula's pies while sitting in front of the TV. It's not a bad choice, especially when you have one of their square pan-baked Frickin Chicken or Eggplant Rollatini pizzas to chow down on.

Best takeout pizza in New City, New York

If you're driving back into New City after spending the day in the High Tor State Park or have been playing a round of golf at the Paramount Country Club, keep going until you hit South Main Street. Once you're on South Main Street keep an eye out for the Calabria Restaurant’s gray brick building, and you'll be able to pull up to grab the best take-out pizza in New City. The Calabria Restaurant is as understated inside as it is out. Uncluttered and functional describes it succinctly. The kitchen is set up exactly the same with the main focus being on their multi-drawer pizza oven. That's where the important business of pizza baking takes place. When you're getting your take-out you'll be able to watch the entire operation, from when your pie is prepped to when it's cooked and boxed. It's quite a show and one with a tasty end result.

Best pizza near New City, New York

West Milford

Take a twenty-eight-mile drive west of New City and you'll cross over the state border with New Jersey before you come to West Milford. West Milford is surrounded by the Wawayanda State Park, the Farny State Park, the Ringwood State Park, and the Norvin Green State Forest. They're all exceptionally scenic spots for outdoor recreational activities during the warmer months. If you enjoy winter sports then you'll be wanting to head there once there's been a snowfall to go skiing or snowshoeing at the Mountain Creek ski resort. Whatever time of the year you go, don't miss stopping at Frank's Pizza on Marshall Hill Road for a pie.

Tuxedo Park

You don't need to get dressed up to the nines to make the twenty-two-mile trip from New City to Tuxedo Park, and you'll be a lot better off if you slip on a pair of good hiking boots before you go. While Tuxedo Park may be the village that's responsible for giving its name to the well-known men's dress suit, the tuxedo, there's not a great deal of note there other than the super scenic Dater Mountain Nature Park and Tuxedo Lake. When you've spent a couple of hours enjoying the scenery, head over to Steve's Brick Oven Pizza on NY-17. You can't miss it – it's a bright red building that doesn't blend in with the landscape.

Fort Montgomery

Take yourself on a scenic drive through the Bear Mountain State Park to Fort Montgomery. It's only around twenty miles, so easily managed in thirty minutes or so. Fort Montgomery is a hamlet on the banks of the Hudson River and also the site of a historic military fort. There are hiking trails around the nearby Hessian Lake, a trailside museum, a small zoo, and a boat dock all in the same vicinity, so plenty for everyone to do no matter what their age. Extra activities for the young ones include a carousel and a summertime swimming pool and you can also hire pedal boats for some additional aquatic fun. When you want to eat, you'll find Bear Mountain Pizza serves great pies.

FAQ

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best veggie pizza in New City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Sicilian-style pizza in New City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best calzone pizza in New City?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in New City?

caret icon

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

Even More Types of Food in New City

Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in New City, NY