Top Pizza Restaurants in North Tonawanda, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in North Tonawanda: a local guide

Northern Tonawanda, which became a city in 1897, has long been known for its forestry industry. From the 19th century, the largest lumber companies have opened here, creating jobs and attracting new residents. In that period, residents built many mansions for the local businessmen, which testifies to the city’s wealth and the success of its residents. Those homes still adorn North Tonawanda’s landscape. In 1938 the first chocolate factory and shop opened here, and later many restaurants opened their doors, including the most popular ones – pizzerias. Although the first Italian restaurants were operating in the 1920s in the wider area, making pizza in the Roman style was popular back then. Currently, the most popular pizza styles are New York, Sicilian, and Buffalo.
Some time ago, there were annual Pizza Fests in North Tonawanda and Tonawanda where people could sample local pizza, vote for the best one, and have fun. It was the local’s most favorite and long-awaited event of the year that united pizza fans of the community.

North Tonawanda is Known for Buffalo-style Pizza

Pizza in the city is as famous a dish as it is throughout America, and you can find all styles and toppings here. However, of all the varieties available in North Tonawanda, the most popular and most ordered is Buffalo-style pizza. This pizza is approximately 60 years old and was created in the neighboring city of Buffalo. The dough looks like something between Detroit, Chicago, and New York-style pizza. Usually, it is made in a round shape with a fluffy and airy dough in the center, with crisp edges. The sauce makes a big difference in contrast with other typical pizza sauces. It is slightly sweet and spicy, made of butter and a hot sauce. As for the toppings, it has either pepperoni or shredded chicken breast. The recipes vary; the chicken can be boiled, deep-fried, or grilled, and the sauce can contain blue cheese. You will see Buffalo-style pizza topped with a blend of cheeses like provolone, cheddar, and mozzarella.

Best Delivery Pizza in North Tonawanda

The Wurlitzer Pizza & Co is a family-owned pizzeria with over 20 years of experience and the best place for pizza delivery in North Tonawanda. This pizzeria can deservedly be called one of the best in the city. Everything here is at a high level – pizza quality, delivery speed, the level of service. It offers a wide assortment of different pizzas. As the customer, you can choose the pizza size and the crust. Seasoned crusts with lemon pepper or sesame are free of charge, as well as New York-style extra thin crust. In addition, the menu at Wurlitzer includes salads, a variety of snacks, and advantageous offers for big companies. What distinguishes them most among the others is that they offer plenty of pizza options for vegans, and their pizza always comes hot and fresh, as if it was just from the oven. Are you in the mood to have some pizza? Place your order here:

Best Takeout Pizza in North Tonawanda

Submaster is a chain restaurant responsible for making great subs, wings, and the best pizza for takeout in North Tonawanda. It should be noted that there are many pizzerias for pickup in town, but Submaster beats out the competition by offering the tastiest pizza in combination with excellent customer service. Most customers believe that the pizza at Submaster is simply perfect in terms of taste. It has the optimal dough to filling ratio, and every ingredient they use is as fresh as possible. The dough is made daily on their premises, and the pizza is baked to order in a specialized oven. Besides typical crust, there are gluten-free and cauliflower crusts for those who need it. Once you’ve chosen a pizza, you have to add one of their namesake subs to your takeout order. The Sicilian Sub is an excellent choice for meat lovers. It has ham, capicola, pepperoni, and salami.

Best Pizza near North Tonawanda

Tonawanda

Olisi’s NY Pizza is a local pizzeria that serves the best pizza in nearby Tonawanda. They make delicious hand-tossed New York-style pizza with a thin crust. As the chef of this restaurant says, the main thing is the dough. It is prepared from high-quality flour according to a special secret recipe. They offer pizza of different sizes, including legendary slices, which can be folded while eating like a true New Yorker. The menu also includes Italian specialties, various types of meat and fish, as well as delicious homemade desserts.

Amherst

Zetti’s Pizza & Pasta is a cozy Italian restaurant offering the best pizza in Amherst. They make bruschetta-style pizzas, and Sicilian-style pies. The place has an extensive pizza menu, mainly with classic tastes, but if you don't like a single ready-made option, or you just want to experiment, then you can create the pie yourself. Each pizza looks more like an open pie, although there is also an option of stuffed pizza if you like a covering on top. Customers especially appreciate the abundance of fillings.

Buffalo

Gino’s NY Pizza is a small cozy pizzeria that makes the best pizza in Buffalo. They specialize in authentic NY-style pizza and offer amazing stuffed pizzas. You can also order pizza by the slice. Besides pizza, there are tasty appetizers, wings, and heroes. New dishes regularly appear on the menu, so you can always find something different. The place is very popular in the area and has a lot of loyal customers who drive a distance to get the best pizza.

show more iconSee More
Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in North Tonawanda, NY