Top Pizza Restaurants in Oceanside, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Oceanside: a local guide

Pizza is a quick and tasty meal that is filling, yummy and delicious; regardless of what type you choose! Over in Oceanside, there are a whole host of different types of pizzerias, restaurants, takeouts, and deliveries available. You can find just about every type of pizza you can imagine. However, there is only one type of pizza that most people go for over in the Empire State. The NY pizza was originally inspired by the traditional Neapolitan style pizza, and it was believed to have been created by NY’s and the USA's first pizzeria. This was located in New York's Little Italy and was founded by Gennaro Lombardi in 1905. Since then it has been served up in large foldable slices. In fact, even the most inexperienced tourists know to avoid eating this type of pizza with a knife and fork! Famous the world over, New York pizza is arguably the best in the country and it is not very difficult to see why.

Best Delivery Pizza in Oceanside NY

If you are in the mood for Italian food, we have some of the best pizzas in Oceanside featured on Slice. No matter how you slice it, we are confident that one of our partners will bring your delicious pie right to your door.
However one of our favorite places for the best pizza delivery in Oceanside NY is Villa Formia. Located in the Madison Plaza Shopping Center on Mott Street, this place has been serving up tasty pizza pie to the local community since it first opened in 1986. It is named after a small town on the outskirts of Rome, and its menu contains an array of modern and traditional Italian cuisine. We particularly love their tasty Grandma Pie, which has a thin Sicilian crust, vodka sauce, and mozz. Other notable options include the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza, Chicken Cesar Pie, or their simple yet extra-yummy Margherita. As well as a range of pizza sold by the pie or the slice, you can also find salads, calzones, wraps, paninis, pasta dishes, and more.

Best Takeout Pizza in Oceanside

Nothing is cheesier than ordering scrumptious pizza at Slice, and many of our partners offer both delivery and takeout. However, D'Cocco's restaurant and pizzeria is one of the best places to get takeout pizza in Oceanside. Serving up modern and authentic Italian food to the local community since 1988, DCocco’s Pizzeria and Restaurant is an Oceanside favorite. They have a variety of different types of pizza available, including a classic Neapolitan, Sicilian pizza, whole wheat pie, ultra-thin, gluten-free, and more. Alternatively, create your own pizza with a superb selection of fresh ingredients for you to choose from. We particularly love the tasty House Special Pizza, which is generously topped with a variety of fresh ingredients. We have also heard excellent things about their yummy pinwheels. A NY-classic, this spiralized version of pizza comes with either pepperoni or spinach, broccoli, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese. With hero sandwiches, gyros, delicious sides, entrees, pasta dishes, and more, D’Cocco’s has something for everyone.

Best Pizza Near Oceanside

Lynbrook, NY

A village in Nassau County NY, Lynbrook is located on the south shore of Long Island. If you are feeling hungry for pizza in Lynbrook, check out the delightful pies on offer over at Don Giovanni Pizzeria. Located on Merrick Road, this place has an excellent selection! We particularly love their House Special Pizza, which is topped with sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, onions, mushroom, peppers, olives, and mozzarella cheese.

Baldwin, NY

A hamlet and CDP also located in the town of Hempstead, Baldwin is a local suburb with lots of green space. If you are looking to enjoy a slice over in Baldwin, we love Gino’s on Atlantic Avenue. Check out Gino’s Special pizza for a stunning NY-style pie topped with meatballs, mushrooms, onions, peppers, sausage, and pepperoni. Whereas, if you prefer to eat meat-free, their deliciously fresh Garden pizza is topped with assorted veggies, tomatoes, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, sauce, and cheese.

Long Beach, NY

Known as the ‘City by the Sea’, Long Beach had a population of 33, 657 residents at the last count. It is located around 70 miles from Oceanside, and pizza is a popular choice over there. We particularly like West End Pizza and Restaurant. A popular choice amongst Slice users, this place has a whole host of different types of pies available for you to choose from. This includes Sicilian, Grandma pizza, Neapolitan, healthy pizzas, veggie pizzas, and more!

show more iconSee More


Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Oceanside, NY