Top Pizza Restaurants in Rye, NY Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Rye: a local guide

Located on Long Island Sound in southeastern New York, Rye is a small, coastal city famous for its waterfront that covers 60 percent of the town’s surface area. Named one of the best places to live in New York, Rye is frequently visited by people from the New York area, thanks to its highly-rated schools, peaceful streets, and kind residents. Tourists are drawn to the popular Playland Amusement Park, where children can have fun and make new friends. The many nature and wildlife areas are a great choice if you want to relax. Don’t forget a trip to the beautiful beaches and historic sites.

About 30 miles away from New York City, there are plenty of fun festivals and events to attend for an engaging day out in Rye. One of the most popular events is the Rye Food Festival, organized on the pier at Playland Park. Here you can explore new Italian delicacies, Mexican street food, donuts, and even drinks. It’s an ideal opportunity to expand your culinary interests and meet new people.

Rye is Known for New York-style Pizza

Because Rye is located very close to New York City, there is a clear influence over the way pizza is made and enjoyed in this area. As you might expect, Rye's most ordered and beloved type of pizza is the famous New York-style pizza, as long as it’s made using a traditional recipe. Featuring a large, buttery, and thin crust topped with delicious tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella cheese, it’s obvious why this type of pizza is famous all over the country. Most pizzerias will go beyond the sauce and cheese with other ingredients like pepperoni, other meats, or vegetables. This pizza style is an excellent pick whether you wish to enjoy it in a sit-down restaurant or get a slice on your way to work.

Originally a grocery store located in the Little Italy neighborhood in New York City, Lombardi’s was the very first pizzeria in the country. This is the same pizzeria that created the famous New York-style pizza and sold it for the first time in 1905. Nowadays, you can find this pizza in almost every pizzeria and restaurant in the United States, including those in Rye.

Best Delivery Pizza in Rye

According to Rye locals, Valtori Pizza Kitchen offers the best New York-style pizza and traditional Italian food in the city. The secret recipe sauce developed over more than 25 years is a key factor in their success. Add this delicious sauce to locally-sourced fresh ingredients and handmade pizza dough, and you have the best pie in town.

At Valtori Pizza, you can build your own pizza based on your preference and taste. Choose one of their seven types of pizza crust and then top it with however many ingredients you want from their list of more than 30 available toppings. Don’t feel like getting creative? The option of ordering one of their Specialty Pizzas is also available. An interesting choice that might surprise you is the Mediterranean Chicken Pizza. It has grilled chicken, mushrooms, artichokes, roasted peppers, onions, and Kalamata olives.

Best Takeout Pizza in Rye

Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant is one of the most popular pizzerias in Rye for mouth-watering pizza made with exquisite ingredients. Their generous menu includes pizza, pasta, chicken, seafood dishes, homemade sandwiches, and soups. You will always find something that suits your taste and mood. Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant’s dishes are made with the freshest and highest-quality ingredients available on the market. It’s easy to order from here for takeout whenever you feel like it.

If you decide to order from their restaurant and would like something out of the ordinary, try their Lasagna Pizza. It has chopped meat, ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, resembling a traditional lasagna. The Al Dente Special Pizza featuring chicken cutlets, artichokes, tomato, basil, cherry peppers, garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, and mozzarella is another excellent pick for a tasty lunch or dinner.

Best Pizza Near Rye

Port Chester

Famous for The Waterfront, an entertainment center with a 14-screen movie theater, many shopping stores, and a large number of restaurants, Port Chester is a village in New York, part of the town of Rye.

Villa Rustica Pizzeria is one of the most popular and appreciated restaurants in the area, thanks to its mouth-watering pizza recipes. From their simple Margarita Pizza to the Napoli Pizza or Pepperoni Pizza, all of their dishes are flavorful and high quality.


One of the wealthiest villages in the United States, with some well-known celebrities living in the area and many exceptional schools, Harrison is known for its many art museums and centers, beautiful gardens and parks, and even adventure parks.

If you live here or are traveling here and wish to enjoy some outstanding Italian pizza, then you must check out Sofia’s Pizza & Restaurant. Customers recommend the Lasagna Pizza, Gina’s Special Pizza, and Chicken Bacon Pizza.


Mamaroneck is home to a Westchester County landmark listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2010, Walter’s Hot Dog Stand. The city also features a lively downtown full of antique shops, restaurants, and other stores.

Craving a tasty pizza loaded with lots of ingredients and then baked to perfection at very high temperatures? Then Sal’s Pizzeria has exactly what you are looking for, and locals suggest you order the Sicilian Pie, Chicken Parm Pizza, or Cheese Pizza.

show more iconSee More


Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Rye, NY