When most people think of pizza, they picture a classic slice of New York-style pizza. It could easily be called the pizza for everyone with its thin crust, perfect amount of sauce, and ample amount of bubbly, melted cheese. The quintessential New York-style slice often contains more ingredients than other types of pizza, with sugar and olive oil added to the dough, and zesty herbs like basil, oregano, and crushed red pepper sprinkled throughout the sauce. Its typical large, hand-tossed size (most are an average of 18 inches in diameter) also makes it the ideal pie for a party, family night, or any large gathering.

New York-style pizza was created by Lombardi's Pizzeria in the Manhattan neighborhood called "Little Italy" when Gennaro Lombardi first opened its doors in 1905. Slices sold for five cents a piece and word of mouth quickly spread, resulting in a handful of other pizzerias opening in the area, many of which are still serving their delicious pizza to this day.

Best Delivery Pizza in Sayville

Sayville Pizza, located right on the charming main street of town, is easily a local favorite. This classic pizzeria has been in business for over 60 years, so it should come as no surprise that they’ve truly perfected the art of pizza-making. Their cozy booths and casual ambiance make you feel instantly at home as you walk in the door, while their pizzas-by-the-slice displayed at the front counter are sure to make your mouth water. Whether you're looking for New York-style pizza or a Sicilian-style pie, Sayville Pizza is a guaranteed delicious choice for delivery to your next get-together or night in.

If you're craving an authentic Italian favorite to pair with your pizza, Sayville Pizza also offers a pleasantly varied selection of salads, pasta, heroes, and appetizers. And don't forget to check out their extensive dessert menu; from their cannolis, tiramisu, and toasted almond cake to their simple, decadent chocolate cake, you're sure to find the perfect finishing touch to your meal.

Best Takeout Pizza in Sayville

When you want classic, family-style Italian fare made with the freshest ingredients, Butera’s of Sayville offers some of the best food around. Owned and operated by Martin Butera, his wife Laurie, and his brother Gary Butera, Butera's is truly a family enterprise in every sense of the term. Their warm yet elegant atmosphere, generous portions, and convenient location on the main street of Sayville are sure to make them the perfect go-to option you'll return to again and again for all your takeout meal needs.

Peruse their menu to discover their complete offering of antipasti, mixed salads, and authentic Italian pasta and entrees. However, their crisp grilled pizza-of-the-day takes center stage once you taste its light crust and unique selection of toppings arranged over freshly melted cheese. Finish off your meal with a traditional Italian dessert, such as the Apple Crostada, Chocolate Tartufo, or Amaretto and Almond Cake for a thoroughly Italian takeout experience.

Best Pizza Near Sayville

St. James

Located a dozen miles north of Sayville is the small hamlet of St. James. During the early 20th century, St. James was home to a handful of famous movie stars. But today the real star in town is Spuntino Restaurant and Bar. Offering an exquisite Italian dining experience, their delicious brick-oven, wood-fired pizza steals the show with its perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings. Their creative selection of pies makes it easy to find the perfect pizza for every taste.

East Islip

Just ten miles to the east of Sayville is the town of Islip. Located along the beautiful Great South Bay, Islip is well-known for boating, fishing, and great swimming beaches. But it's also popular for its main street shopping district lined with boutiques, hair salons, and restaurants, including pizzerias. Bellina's Pizza is a local favorite. They have a wide selection of ready-to-go New York-style pizza-by-the-slice, Sicillian-style grandma pizzas, and other tasty Italian baked goods.

Patchogue

Situated a handful of miles northwest of Sayville is the picturesque village of Patchogue. Patchogue is brimming with historical attractions, preeminent of which is the elegant Patchogue Theater for Performing Arts. It was initially opened in 1923 and is fully restored to the condition of its glory days. Family-owned Giovanni's Pizzeria & Gelateria holds its own special spot on the walkable main street of downtown with its authentic New York-style pizzas, lively ambiance, and homemade gelato bar that is sure to satisfy any appetite.