Find Local Pizza in Shelter Island, New York

Top Pizza Restaurants in Shelter Island Near You

caret icon

Piesano's Pizza logo

Piesano's Pizza

3 N Ferry Rd

Shelter Island, NY 11964

View Menu


Other pizza places near Shelter Island

caret icon

Roma Pizzeria logo

Roma Pizzeria

4.5filled star icon(20)

31455 Main Rd

Cutchogue, NY 11935

Open Now
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

American Pie logo

American Pie

4.4filled star icon(70)

2044 Montauk Hwy

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Open Now
$5.00 Delivery
Order Online

La Capannina logo

La Capannina

4.8filled star icon(119)

364 Montauk Hwy

Wainscott, NY 11975

Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online
5filled star icon 10/31/2021
best pizza in the area a K.

SLICE OF 48 logo

SLICE OF 48

4.9filled star icon(58)

46455 County Road 48

Southold, NY 11971

Open Now
Pickup Only
Order Online
5filled star icon 7/17/2021
Really good! Cooked perfect and delivery was awesome. Arrived piping hot .Thanks! Mike C.

Fresco Pizza Deli logo

Fresco Pizza Deli

5.0filled star icon(87)

623 Hampton Rd

Southampton, NY 11968

Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online
5filled star icon 11/3/2021
Best crust I have had around the Hamptons! Chris H.

Pineneck Pizza logo

Pineneck Pizza

New

3360 Noyack Rd

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Fierro's Pizza logo

Fierro's Pizza

New

104 Park Pl

East Hampton, NY 11937

Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Cittanuova logo

Cittanuova

29 Newtown Ln

East Hampton, NY 11937

View Menu

Cappelletti logo

Cappelletti

3284 Noyack Rd

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

View Menu

The Pizza Place logo

The Pizza Place

2123 Montauk Highway

Bridgehampton, NY 11932

View Menu

Emilio's logo

Emilio's

400 Main St

Greenport, NY 11944

View Menu

Sam's Restaurant logo

Sam's Restaurant

36 Newtown Ln

East Hampton, NY 11937

View Menu

Felices logo

Felices

237 Main St

Amagansett, NY 11930

View Menu

Sag Pizza logo

Sag Pizza

103 Main St

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

View Menu

World Pie logo

World Pie

2402 Montauk Hwy

Bridgehampton, NY 11944

View Menu


Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App
Slicechevron right iconNew Yorkchevron right icon Pizza Places in Shelter Island, NY