Question 1

What is the best pizza place in West Islip?

Accepted Answer

[Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/our-little-italy-pizza-pasta/menu) is rated 4.8 out of 5 based on 13193 Slice reviews. Other favorites are [Crispino's Pizzeria](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/crispino-s-pizzeria/menu) and [Bang Bang Burritos](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/bang-bang-burritos/menu).

Question 2

Where can I get pizza deals in West Islip?

Accepted Answer

[Anthony's Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/anthony-s-pizza-pasta-west-islip/menu) has a 5% discount available right now. [Find even more pizza deals](#has-discount).

Question 3

Which West Islip pizza shops have pizza by the slice?

Accepted Answer

Grab a quick slice at [Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/our-little-italy-pizza-pasta/menu) or [Crispino's Pizzeria](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/crispino-s-pizzeria/menu).

Question 4

Which pizza places do catering in West Islip?

Accepted Answer

Consider [Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/our-little-italy-pizza-pasta/menu) or [Crispino's Pizzeria](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/crispino-s-pizzeria/menu) for great local catering options in West Islip. [Anthony's Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/anthony-s-pizza-pasta-west-islip/menu) is also popular.

Question 5

Where can I get both pizza and wings at one place in West Islip?

Accepted Answer

Pizza and Wings in one place? [Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/west-islip/11795/benedetto-s-pizza-pasta/menu) has you covered.

Top Pizza Restaurants in West Islip, NY in 2026 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

Crispino's Pizzeria

Bang Bang Burritos

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta

Frequently Asked Questions

Question:What is the best pizza place in West Islip?

Question:Where can I get pizza deals in West Islip?

Question:Which West Islip pizza shops have pizza by the slice?

Question:Which pizza places do catering in West Islip?

Question:Where can I get both pizza and wings at one place in West Islip?

PIZZA TYPES IN WEST ISLIP

Healthy Pizza

Grandma Pizza

Sicilian Pizza

Veggie Pizza