Top Pizza Restaurants in West Islip, NY in 2026 Near You
Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta
Open NowFree Delivery5636 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795
Best around !Joseph H. • 11/9/2026
Bella Cucina Pizzeria Restaurant
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.7•5% off424 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Very good pizza!Kathleen G. • 9/9/2026
Crispino's Pizzeria
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.9159 Higbie Ln, West Islip, NY 11795
Great value for moneyNicole M. • 6/27/2026Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta
Open NowPickup Only4.5504 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795
Best pizza around WI!Alexandros M. • 10/30/2026
Parisi's Pizza & Pasta Of Massapequa
Open NowFree Delivery4.8910 Carmans Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758
I’ve ordered several times I just feel like the quality has gone down - there was missing cheese on our last pizza and it was doughy not cooked enoughBonnie S. • 11/6/2026
Spuntino
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.9687 Old Country Rd, Dix Hills, NY 11746
There was a piece of plastic in my foodChristin F. • 9/21/2026Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta
Open NowFree Delivery5636 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY 11795
Best around !Joseph H. • 11/9/2026.jpg?auto=format&fit=max&q=10)
Carmelina's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Open NowFree Delivery4.9183 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY 11701
Amazing pizza every time. You guys are the bestmichelle N. • 10/4/2026
Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant (Massapequa)
Open Now$2.50 Delivery4.919 Hicksville Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758
Best soup!!Nicole M. • 9/3/2026
Brunello's Pizza & Pasta
Open NowFree Delivery4.9929 Little East Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704
As always, it was delicious 👍Nance S. • 10/3/2026
Dominick's Pizza & Pasta
Open NowFree Delivery4.8•5% off308 35Th St, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Perfect!Kathleen R. • 10/26/2026
Leonardo's Pizza
Open NowFree Delivery4.9•5% off20 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758
Love the food, love going into the place and seeing the people. sometimes when I order on here the order gets stuck and I have to call but it doesn't bother me much. Good peopleKevin L. • 10/18/2026
Little Joe's Pizzeria
Open NowFree Delivery4.9•5% off24 Colonial Springs Rd, Wheatley Heights, NY 11798
The bestDavid H. • 10/10/2026
Amore Pizzeria
Open Now$2.00 Delivery4.9•5% off2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
It was great! Good delivery too!carol K. • 9/24/2026
Crostini Pizza North Broadway
Open NowFree Delivery4.9947 N Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758
Great FoodDoug V. • 10/9/2026Bella Cucina Pizzeria Restaurant
Open Now$3.00 Delivery4.7•5% off424 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Very good pizza!Kathleen G. • 9/9/2026
Mangia Pizza & Restaurant
Open Now$2.00 - $3.00 Delivery4.9785 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703
Always the best food in town!Cecelia R. • 10/5/2026
Pino's Pizza of Deer Park
Open NowFree Delivery4.9•10% off1747 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729
pizza goodVin C. • 10/11/2026
Dalisa Pizza
Open NowFree Delivery4.81500 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon, NY 11703
Good as usualRonald S. • 10/10/2026