Top Pizza Restaurants in Caldwell, OH in 2026 Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Wally's Pizza & Subs
Closed
$4.95 Delivery
4.3
805 Miller St, Caldwell, OH 43724
last time I ordered a pizza sub and two calzones they were not baked all the way through. there was so much raw dough on the inside at first we thought it was cheese. nah. just unbaked pizza dough.
Megan H. • 1/6/2026

Papa Joe's Pizza
Open Now
$4.00 - $6.00 Delivery
4.6
1899 Lockbourne Rd, Columbus, OH 43207
My mushroom was undercooked
LeeAnn T. • 1/10/2026
Luna Pizza Kitchen - Bethel Road Columbus
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.9
2052 Crown Plaza Dr, Columbus, OH 43235
The stromboli was incredible.
Derek D. • 12/28/2025
Ohio State Pizza & Wings
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.3
819 N Nelson Rd, Columbus, OH 43219
Yall are awesome
Danielle D. • 12/31/2025
Luna Pizza Kitchen - Worthington/Polaris
Open Now
$2.99 Delivery
4.5
150 Hutchinson Ave, Columbus, OH 43235
Delivery was a bit slow, beside that it was excellent.
Verified Slice Customer • 10/7/2025
Ohio State Pizza & Deli
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.7
•
10% off
325 E Hudson St, Columbus, OH 43202
Everything was great from the pizza to the rib tips!! Coming back for sure!
Verified Slice Customer • 12/19/2025
Papa Joe's Pizza
Open Now
$4.00 Delivery
4.8
3345 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213
Fire!🔥
jabari Dj Bigghoov H. • 12/12/2025
Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli Dublin
Open Now
$3.45 Delivery
4.4
5837 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH 43017
We’ve ordered several times before and the food was amazing. Tonight everything was cooked overly dark/borderline burnt and delivered a little cold. I’m really hoping it was an anomaly.
Megan M. • 12/12/2025
Jerusalem Pizza & Grill
Open Now
$6.00 Delivery
4.5
•
10% off
5590 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43231
Fish was undercooked. I asked it to be fried hard
Jacqueline B. • 12/12/2025
Cottage Inn Pizza
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
4.8
•
10% off
4674 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026
Bravo! Italian Kitchen
Open Now
$4.99 Delivery
4.3
3000 Hayden Rd, Columbus, OH 43235
Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.2
4434 Westerville Rd, Columbus, OH 43231
Nice pizza, not true NY style but still great!
Verified Slice Customer • 2/16/2025
Happy's Pizza
Open Now
$4.00 Delivery
4.8
•
5% off
1450 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222
We love Happys
Jenny M. • 10/26/2025
Pizza Bianca
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
4.3
•
10% off
5771 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43231
Gatto's Pizza
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.5
3420 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43205
Castello Pizza 2
Open Now
$4.95 Delivery
4.5
2070 Leonard Ave, Columbus, OH 43219
Great food
Stephanie S. • 12/30/2025

PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS