920 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
1635 River Valley Cir S, Lancaster, OH 43130
765 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130
Ohio is a melting pot of regional cultures, and the diversity is one of the reasons why Ohio has different cooking styles. Ohio-style pizza is one of the beneficiaries of the state’s diversity. Ohio-style pizza may not be as famous across the country as Sicilian pizza or New York-style pizza, but that does not mean that the flavor profile isn’t inviting. Ohio-style pizza is a rarity in the culinary world that requires special skills to prepare. It’s something you should have on your list to try when visiting this state.
Ohio-style pizza is a round, square-cut pie with cheese that goes all the way to the edge and a mid-thick crust. It often comes out of the oven with tomato sauce, a baked crust, and a thin layer of melted cheese. The toppings in Ohio-style pizza are usually added after the dough exits the oven so that the heat from the crust will heat up the toppings a bit.
Fans of pizza in Lancaster are likely familiar with Fat Cat Pizza located on Ety Road. Fat Cat Pizza is a neighborhood favorite Italian eatery dishing up incredible pizzas in Lancaster for more than 40 years. Step inside this fun pizzeria, and you’ll see a wide selection of wood-fired handmade pies. Sporting a crispy crust, heaps of cheese, and great toppings like bacon and tomatoes, these pizzas draw pizza lovers from Lancaster and beyond. If you are unsure what to go for, get the Fat Cat’s All-The-Way Pizza. It’s one of their best sellers with a unique combination of toppings. It has mild peppers, green peppers, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions, all on a luxurious bed of provolone and mozzarella. Fat Cat has a great selection of traditional dishes on their menu, which go well beyond pizza. Try one of their delicious salads, subs, and sandwiches to complement your pizza.
Sugar Bears Pizzeria is a laidback Italian restaurant famous for giving you the option of deciding how you want your pizza to look and taste. This adored Lancaster pizzeria offers a selection of unique pies that range from unconventional to traditional. Sure, you can enjoy a classic cheese pizza, but why not try something special like the Bear Paw Pizza? It features half the pepperoni and half the cheese. They also have the Luau Pizza, their take on a typical Hawaiian, and the Deluxe Pizza, which most people call a supreme. In addition to the tasty pizzas, diners can also enjoy appetizers, chicken breast bites, and delicious pasta dishes. There is also a kids’ menu which contains options for small cheese pizza and chicken nuggets paired with mozzarella sticks. For a healthier option, and for those who like things a specific way, you can get the Whatever Salad. It’s lettuce topped with “whatever you want.”
About ten miles from Lancaster, Baltimore is a village in Fairfield County. Sis & Harold's Pizza is a restaurant that pays full attention to delivering great food. Their pasta dishes are tasty, but it would be a crime to come here and not try out their delicious pizza. Sis & Harold's offers several pizza options, including the Meataterian, which is just cheese and five kinds of meat. Can’t decide between a pizza and a sandwich? Get the BLT Pizza for the best of both worlds. It’s pizza topped with bacon, lettuce, and tomato, as you may have already guessed.
Pickerington is the second-largest city in Fairfield County and is blessed with a fair share of excellent pizza restaurants, including Romeo’s Pizza. Romeo’s Pizza uses the best all-natural ingredients available to produce the best pies. Always make sure to come with a serious appetite, though, as the portions are absolutely massive. Guests can get super creative with their pies at Romeo’s Pizza. Add on toppings such as red onions, tomatoes, or sausage to make your perfect meal.
Circleville not only occupies a unique place in the history of American town planning but is also famous for its annual pumpkin show, which attracts over 300,000 people. The pies at Gant’s Pizza & Pub are baked specially to give a crunchy crust and soft base with your preferred toppings. Choose from one of their 15 specialty pizzas, like the Chicken Fajita or the Meat Lovers. They also offer meal options of subs, salads, and sandwiches.
Question:What restaurant has the best gluten-free pizza in Lancaster?
Question:What restaurant has the best thin-crust pizza in Lancaster?
Question:What restaurant has the best thick crust pizza in Lancaster?
Question:What restaurant has the best veggie pizza in Lancaster?