Find Local Pizza in Madison, Ohio

Where the first settlers who arrived in Madison in the late 18th century were from is not clear. They may have sailed across Lake Erie from Canada or trailed across land from Michigan, Cleveland, or even Pennsylvania. If the latter was the case then it was probably the sight of such an enormous expanse of water that prevented them going any further. Madison wasn't named until almost a century later when it was given the name it still has today which honored the fourth president of the United States. It was a quiet farming community from the off and when work on the farms was in short supply, people would travel to the nearby communities in search of extra jobs. It was only when the invention of modern transport came about that, and once they could move around more easily, that more people relocated to the town. Madison grew as a bedroom town sufficiently enough to entice a few Italian settlers to open restaurants there and pizza soon became a popular item on their menus.

Top Pizza Restaurants in Madison Near You

caret icon

Joey's Italian Grille logo
View Menu

Karen's Holiday Custard logo
View Menu

Defender Doggs logo
View Menu

Pizza Roto logo
View Menu


Other pizza places near Madison

caret icon

King's Pizza logo
5% Off Online
4.5filled star icon(629)
Open Now
$2.00 Delivery
Order Online

Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli logo
5% Off Online
4.3filled star icon(54)
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Buckeye Pizza logo
3.5filled star icon(5)
Open Now
$4.00 Delivery
Order Online

Cousin Vinny's Pizza logo
4.2filled star icon(8)
Open Now
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Sparano's Pizza logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(1658)
Closed
$2.50 Delivery
Order Online

Borgata Pizza Cafe logo
3.9filled star icon(15)
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

W.G. Grinders Catering - Upper Arlington logo
4.2filled star icon(74)
Closed
$5.40 Delivery
Order Online

Borgata Pizza Cafe logo
4.0filled star icon(19)
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Casa Di Pizza logo
4.8filled star icon(216)
Closed
$2.50 Delivery
Order Online

Moretti's Of Arlington logo
10% Off Online
4.1filled star icon(12)
Closed
$6.90 Delivery
Order Online

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli logo
4.8filled star icon(713)
Closed
$5.00 Delivery
Order Online

Little Italy Pizza logo
4.5filled star icon(434)
Closed
$2.95 Delivery
Order Online

Pasta Villa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria logo
4.6filled star icon(90)
Closed
$4.65 Delivery
Order Online

Pizza Rustica logo
5% Off Online
4.8filled star icon(30)
Closed
$3.90 Delivery
Order Online

Papa Giorgios logo
5% Off Online
4.7filled star icon(50)
Closed
$4.65 Delivery
Order Online


Madison in Ohio is known for thick crust pizza

While the Italians who relocated to Madison may have changed the place they lived in, they didn't change what they knew about pizza, so Madison is known for thick crust pizza. In truth, you'll be hard put to find any other type of pie being served in Madison at all, no matter how hard you search for it. In Madison, thick crust pizza is the hero of the day. The simplicity of a thick crust pizza and the levels it can be elevated to are what makes this traditional Italian bake so versatile. From being a plain old boring Margarita, which consists of nothing more than a dough base, tomato sauce, and cheese, it can be turned into a gourmet dish by just adding a combination of well-chosen topping ingredients. If only all baking was quite so simple.

Best delivery pizza in Madison, Ohio

It's no good sitting at home at your computer or behind your desk in the office and listening to your stomach rumble. Everyone has to eat no matter how hard they work, so order in a pizza and you won't lose any time away from whatever you're doing. You quite probably deserve the best delivery pizza in Madison and if you give Joey's Italian Grille a call, that's what they'll deliver. Joey's Italian Grille has been serving the Madison locals with pizza from their premises on Hubbard Road for several decades. You don't get to stay open in a small place like Madison unless your food is pretty good so those years of experience are a great recommendation for the quality and service of this pizzeria. Try their Smashed Meatball pizza and you'll be just another one in the throngs of Joey's happy customers.

Best takeout pizza in Madison, Ohio

If you're driving past Madison, which is understandable, along the US-90 when hunger strikes and you want to pick up a take-out pizza, exit the highway when you see the sign for River Street. You'll need to go north until you find Pizza Roto and that's where you can get the best take-out pizza in Madison. Pizza Roto is housed in a smart clapboard and dark timber fronted building with contrasting red canopies over the door and windows. There's a spacious parking lot out front and a large patio area on one side where you can chill while you wait to get your pie. Reading the menu of Pizza Roto will help pass the few minutes it takes them to bake your pie and it's very entertaining seeing how the names of the pizzas match up with the topping ingredients.

Best pizza near Madison, Ohio

Fairport Harbor

Head west out of Madison for around ten miles and if you follow the right signs you'll arrive in Fairport Harbor. Fairport Harbor is right on the shore of Lake Erie and where you'll find the Headlands Beach State Park. Find a comfortable spot on the sands and just sit back and enjoy the views of boats skimming across the lake and Fairport Harbor's lighthouse. Scenic locations don't get much better than this. If you're interested in maritime history, have a browse around the Fairport Marine Museum, which is housed in the lighthouse, before you go for a pizza at Rego's Brickhouse Pizza on New 4th Street.

Painesville

Painsville is located around twelve miles west of Madison, but the reason for going there, the Paine Fall Park, is a little way out and closer to Leroy Township. Once the site of a sawmill and ashery, the area is now one of outstanding natural beauty surrounding Paine Creek where it cascades over an eighty-foot wide drop. Explore the woodlands of Paine Hollow, hike along the course of the creek, and just enjoy the gentle tranquility of this stunning terrain before heading to Master Pizza Painesville for a pie.

Ashtabula

You might think it’s hard to find any culture within a reasonable driving distance of Madison, but you'd be wrong. Go twenty miles northeast and in Ashtabula you'll discover all the cultural activities you're craving. In the Ashtabula Arts Center you can catch live performances of theater, music and dance, at the Hubbard House Underground Railroad Museum you can learn about how the underground railroad worked in the area, or in the Ashtabula Maritime and Surface Transportation Museum, discover all there is to know about all types of vehicles and shipping. You won't need to go out of your way to get a good pizza in Ashtabula either as Main Street Pizza on Main Avenue makes really good ones.

FAQ

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best veggie pizza in Madison?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best mac and cheese pizza in Madison?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best calzone pizza in Madison?

caret icon

Q: 🍕What restaurant has the best Sicilian-style pizza in Madison?

caret icon

Why Order on Slice

Pay Less
Pizzerias pay less to use Slice. Which means you pay less for pizza.
Support Local Shops
Every order supports small shops, their families, and the community.
Best Ingredients
Slice doesn't hurt shops with high fees. So they can afford the best ingredients.

You could be eating pizza in less than an hour!

Install App

Pizza Types in Madison

Slicechevron right iconOhiochevron right icon Pizza Places in Madison, OH