Top Pizza Restaurants in Shelby, OH in 2025 Near You

Q: What is the best pizza place in Shelby?

[Mama's Pizza](https://slicelife.com/restaurants/oh/shelby/44875/mama-s-pizza-shelby/menu) is rated 4.11 out of 5 based on 1810 Slice reviews.

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

Mama's Pizza

Closed

$4.99 Delivery

4.1

40 Mansfield Ave, Shelby, OH 44875

You should offer an "all of the above" for the previous question! Best crust I've had in years, generous toppings and reasonable price!

Verified Slice Customer • 5/13/2024

Tony's Pizza

Closed

$4.95 Delivery

4.5

946 Galloway Rd, Galloway, OH 43119

Shared my love of Tony’s pizza with my family who had never had it. It was a big hit.

Verified Slice Customer • 12/21/2024

Borgata Pizza Cafe

Closed

$6.90 Delivery

4.8

2285 W Dublin Granville Rd 113, Worthington, OH 43085

Always delicious! You can tell they use quality ingredients and don’t skimp!

Verified Slice Customer • 12/21/2024

Luna Pizza Kitchen - Dublin

Closed

$3.99 Delivery

4.4

5380 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Dublin, OH 43016

Been good each time I order

Verified Slice Customer • 5/22/2024

Sparano's Pizza

Closed

$5.00 Delivery

4.8

3947 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

Sparano's has been a favorite for years. Always good!

Verified Slice Customer • 1/31/2025

Pizza Pizza 007

Closed

$6.90 Delivery

4.8

3027 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43202

Amazing employee and Amazing food!

Verified Slice Customer • 1/30/2025

Luna Pizza Kitchen - Bethel Road Columbus

Closed

$3.99 Delivery

4.6

2052 Crown Plaza Dr, Columbus, OH 43235

Great pizza at a great price!

Verified Slice Customer • 11/20/2024

Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli

Closed

$4.95 Delivery

3.9

5425 Roberts Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026

Amazing food

Verified Slice Customer • 12/12/2024

Bridge Street Pizza

Closed

$4.99 Delivery

3.7

16 E Bridge St, Dublin, OH 43017

Very impressed with the service and especially the quality of the food! Would highly recommend!!! We also got the gf crust along with an original crust, and both were excellent!

Verified Slice Customer • 10/28/2024

Halwani's Pizza & Stromboli

1453 Ida Ave, Columbus, OH 43212

Easy ordering and pickup, convenient location for late night dinner..

Verified Slice Customer • 8/4/2024

Papa Joe's Pizza

Closed

$4.00 - $6.00 Delivery

4.6

2970 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204

Luigi's Pizza

Closed

4.8

5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026

I hadn't had Luigis for at least 20 years and I saw some comments on Facebook about it being run or owned by a different person now. The new person was making a better pizza. So I gave it a shot! I was not disappointed. I really like the crust. It is kind of pricey though. It would be nice if they had coupons or deals to kind of knock the price down a little.

Pat B. • 5/19/2024

King's Pizza

1950 N 4th St, Columbus, OH 43201

Moon Pizza

Closed

$4.95 Delivery

4.2

3861 Park Mill Run Dr, Hilliard, OH 43026

Love the fresh ingredients!

Verified Slice Customer • 10/19/2024

Piece of Chicago Carryout

1048 Mt Vernon Ave, Columbus, OH 43203

Papa Giorgios

Closed

$4.65 Delivery

4.8

5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus, OH 43220

Frequently Asked Questions

Question:What is the best pizza place in Shelby?

PIZZA PLACES OPEN ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS

Open on New Year's Eve

•

Pick Up Restaurants Near You

•

Pizza Deals Near You

•

Pizza Near You

•

Pizza Restaurants Open Now

•

Open on Christmas

•

Open on Thanksgiving

•

Open on Veterans Day

•

Free Pizza Delivery Near You

•

Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day

•

Open on Labor Day

•

Open on Independence Day

•

Open on New Year's Day

•

Open on Memorial Day

•

Black Friday Pizza Deals

•

Slice Ohio Pizza Places in Shelby, OH