Tiffin is a serene town where you can comfortably live without worrying about crime or high living costs. The town lies along the Sandusky River, and it has a rich history as the first city in Ohio to have an electric power plant and the third in the country. Tiffin has fantastic nightlife, and many people flock to the city to party. Many young professionals and families live in the town due to the availability of employment and business opportunities. The town also has high-achieving public schools for adults and kids. If you haven’t visited Tiffin, you should add the town to your travel bucket list, and you will have the time of your life. You can attend the Tiffin Seneca Heritage Festival, which offers a platform to savor local delicacies such as buckeyes, a peanut butter and chocolate concoction as well as pizza. Pizzas became famous in Tiffin in the mid 20th century when Italian immigrants moved to the town due to the discovery of natural gases. Some of the Italians opened restaurants to share their traditional cuisine.

Tiffin is Known for New York-style Pizza

Almost everyone in Tiffin loves New York-style pizza, which dominates many restaurants in the city. New York-style pizza is inspired by Neapolitan pizza from Naples, Italy. Gennaro Lombardi created the first New York-style pizza in Little Italy in 1905. The pizza became popular in Tiffin in the mid 20th century when Italian immigrants and New Yorkers relocated to the town. New York-style pizza has a hand-tossed thin crust traditionally loaded with shredded mozzarella and tomato sauce. You can be creative and customize your pizza by adding more toppings. New York-style pizza has large slices with thick and crispy crust around the edges. Many restaurants serve it in slices instead of whole pies. You can use dried basil, red chili pepper flakes, grated parmesan cheese, and dried oregano to make the most flavorful and rich sauce. Some restaurants even go above and beyond by importing water from New York City since they believe it contains minerals that enhance the pizza’s taste and texture.

Best Delivery Pizza in Tiffin, Ohio

Reino’s Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned and managed restaurant that has served scrumptious thin-crust and healthy pizzas in Tiffin since 1950. The restaurant offers its pizzas for delivery, and you can order on Slice at a reasonable price. Frankie’s Original Pizza is made for sharing with your family and has delicious toppings, including a three cheese blend, pepperoni, and pizza sauce. Feast on a Tropical Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza loaded with banana peppers, ranch pineapple, bacon, and chicken. You can also treat your taste buds to an American Foldover filled with mayo, lettuce, pepperoni, and tomatoes. Hungry for something other than pizza? Reino’s Pizza & Pasta has several other options on their menu for you to explore. You can request a Spinach Salad tossed with two types of peppers, black olives, blue cheese, and spinach. The restaurant has an extensive lunch specials menu, and you can treat your colleagues to a Spaghetti Lunch Special served with garlic toast and sauce.

Best Takeout Pizza in Tiffin, Ohio

Fort Ball Pizza is a locally-owned and managed restaurant that has served delicious Italian food in Tiffin since 1978. The restaurant uses prime ingredients and prepares its pizza dough daily. Surprise your family with a takeout order of a Meat Eater Pizza topped with sausage, ham, pepperoni, and bacon. You can double the excitement by adding a Supreme Pizza piled generously with mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, and green peppers. It's a flavorsome dish that should always be in your takeout order from Fort Ball Pizza. Besides pizza, the restaurant has a great selection of foldovers, and you can get yourself an Italian Foldover packed with lettuce, salami, pepperoni, and creamy Italian dressing. Try the Chicken Sub with tomato, mayo, and cheese if you crave a heavenly sub. When you need a quick meal for dinner, you can opt for a Chicken Alfredo with fettuccine noodles, chicken, and creamy Alfredo sauce. Wrap up your takeout order with a Large Grilled Chicken Salad tossed with cucumbers, cheese, green peppers, and chicken strips.

Best Pizza Near Tiffin

Clyde

Clyde is about 20 miles northeast of Tiffin, and it’s a lovely destination where you can sample tasty dishes served at Big D’s Pizza. The restaurant serves delicious pan pizzas available in exotic combinations. Sample the Big D’s Special Deluxe Pizza with over 12 meat and veggie toppings. It’s hearty and very filling. The Chipotle Pizza is one of their more unique specialty pizzas but is a popular choice. It has your choice of steak or chicken along with onions, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella cheese on a bed of smoky chipotle sauce.

Willard

Bruno’s Pizzeria is an iconic restaurant that serves exquisite cauliflower, thin-crust, and gluten-free pizzas in Willard, located about 30 miles from Tiffin. Get your squad together and request a delivery order of the Chicago Classic Pizza loaded with three types of cheese, sliced Italian sausage, old world pepperoni, and sliced green peppers. You can top up your order with a Veggie Pizza piled with diced Roma tomatoes, two types of peppers, a blend of two kinds of cheese, and mushrooms.

Findlay

Luca Pizza di Roma is a family-owned and operated restaurant that has served mouth-watering Italian dishes in Findlay for over 40 years. The pizzeria incorporates premium ingredients, and you can feel the freshness of the food in each bite. Try the Luca Deluxe Pizza topped with pepperoni, green peppers, black olives, and sausage. The restaurant also serves pizza by the slice, and you can surprise your loved ones with a Meat Stuffed Pizza Slice, and they will be grateful.