Exeter residents surely know their pizza. The most frequently ordered pizza type in the area is New York-style pizza, and there are lots of restaurants and pizzerias that serve this pizza that is familiar to every American. Created in 1905 in the Little Italy neighborhood of Manhattan, New York-style pizza is now a staple for pizza all over the world. Its large hand-tossed thin crust is savory with freshly made tomato sauce, chewy cheese, and the classic delicious pepperoni, all baked in a big gas oven. This combination is what makes everyone fall in love with this type of pizza.

While New York-style pizza seems to be the top favorite in the area, some Exeter residents believe that nothing can beat authentic Italian pizza. For these people, there is a generous variety of restaurants that serve Sicilian and Neapolitan pizza, made using traditional recipes.

Best Delivery Pizza in Exeter

Whether you are actively on a quest to find the best pizza in Exeter or simply wish to have an enjoyable pizza lunch with friends, Villa Pizzeria is a must-try. The owners’ goal is to serve the finest, most appetizing food in the area while also providing a cozy, warm atmosphere where you can enjoy their popular dishes. As a result, their restaurant is almost always crowded with people who want to spoil themselves by eating a great pizza.

When you first glance at their menu, you will see some of the most interesting and out-of-the-ordinary pizza types with some uncommon ingredient combinations. However, every risky mix of ingredients has been tested and then immediately adored by locals. Should you visit this restaurant, top choices include the Clams Casino Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Wings Pizza, or Steak Special Pizza. On the other hand, if you’re vegetarian, add the Florentine Pizza or the Spinach Pie to your delivery order.

Best Takeout Pizza in Exeter

Want to taste some of the best grandma pizza in all of Exeter? Then you should try Appletree House, a family-owned business in Exeter, serving some of the most delicious homemade dishes. Everything is made from scratch using the highest-quality ingredients. If you come across this place, you’ll be surprised it’s actually a restaurant inside.

Inside Appletree House, you will find a lovely decorated family diner with caring and polite staff that offers you a menu with homemade recipes, including pizza. All of this greatness is achieved by a single Exeter family who runs the restaurant. Whenever you think about visiting this restaurant, don’t forget to try out their House Red Pizza with Appltree’s signature tomato sauce and a blend of cheese. The Cheese Steak Pizza and BBQ Chicken Pizza are also flavorful choices. Their mouth-watering Beer Battered Onion Rings or Mac & Cheese Bites as an appetizer start any meal off right.

Best Pizza Near Exeter

Kingston

First settled in the 1770s and with a rich history, Kingston is a borough in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania. Quite weirdly, the best pizza in this small city is at a place commonly known as a bakery, AmberDonia Bakery.

Here you can feast on outstanding wood-fired pizza, including their most ordered items, the Italian Pizza, Romeo and Juliet Pizza, and the Amber Pizza. Want a dessert after a good pizza? Try the Peanut Butter Truffles.

Wilkes-Barre

Still carrying the nickname of “The Diamond City” from the 19th century, Wilkes-Barre is now famous for its Sicilian-style pizza. People from all over Pennsylvania travel to Angelo’s Pizza for their Sweet Sauce Pizza, claiming it is the best option on their menu.

If you happen to be in the area, give this pizzeria a try and create your own pizza with your desired ingredients. Their thick pizza crust will definitely have you coming back for more.

Back Mountain

Back Mountain, just over ten miles from Exeter, gets its name because the whole region is located behind the mountain ridge forming the northwest side of the Wyoming Valley.

With so many things to explore in the area, why not give their pizza a try as well? Bernie’s Pizza is one of the most popular pizzerias in the area, especially for their veggie pizzas: the Spinach and Feta Pizza and the Cauliflower Pizza. The stromboli’s at Bernie’s are also worth a try.