With most of Somerset’s population being middle-aged people, Grandma pizza is at the top of the pizza list. Created by hungry Italian immigrants, Sicilian pizza can be made in a regular household oven with simple ingredients. It’s the ultimate comfort food and a nice treat after a hard day’s work. It was first cooked in the home kitchens of Long Island, New York, and is often mistaken for Sicilian pizza. Due to its versatility, simplicity, and rich taste, Grandma pizza has become known all over the country.

Grandma pizza is typically rectangular in shape, with delicious, savory tomato sauce on top of the cheese. Then, if the pizzeria allows it, you can add whatever additional toppings you prefer. Since this kind of pizza has become a real staple in Somerset, and locals always want more every time they order it, there are a lot of family-owned restaurants and pizzerias that serve it nowadays.

Best Delivery Pizza in Somerset

Want to enjoy a tasty traditional New York-style pizza in a luxurious, relatively-new restaurant on a relaxing weekday afternoon? Then Little Italy Ristorante Pizzeria is your best bet. The restaurant’s location is great, the customer service and staff are always polite and friendly, the atmosphere of the whole place is peaceful. Overall, it’s an experience to remember whether you opt for delivery, takeout, or onsite dining.

Little Italy Ristorante is the ideal delivery place in Somerset for any Italian cuisine you could want. They do pasta, calzones, parmigiana sandwiches, and both chicken and veal dishes. The pizza at Little Italy is the true star of the show, with everything from hand-tossed NY thin-crust to Sicilian to pizza by the slice. Some of the pizzas have fun names, like the Heart Attack Pizza. Don’t let the name throw you off; this pizza topped with pepperoni, bacon, and sausage is worth the extra calories.

Best Takeout Pizza in Somerset

Although this place also serves sandwiches, subs, and bowls, Best Way Pizza is mainly known for being one of the oldest restaurants in the Somerset area. Since 1955, Best Way Pizza has served the most appetizing cheesy square cuts of pizza at great prices, making it a clear top choice for all locals.

As more and more people fell in love with the unique taste and shape of the restaurant’s pizzas, Best Way Pizza has increased in popularity, becoming a place people resort to whenever they crave a mouth-watering pizza, especially for takeout.

Nowadays, the company has 13 franchise locations and offers its amazing pizza in many neighborhoods across Pennsylvania. If you ever come across this pizzeria, try the Three Toppings Square Pie, the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie, or the Meatfest Square Pie. Finish your meal with the sweet Cinnamon Breadsticks that are perfect for sharing with the whole family.

Best Pizza Near Somerset

Johnstown

The tragic bursting of a dam in 1889 is what made Johnstown famous. Besides this, Johnston is also known for hosting baseball tournaments every summer. After the games, people from all over the country gather for a huge Italian meal of pizza and pasta.

Salvatore’s Pizza is everyone’s go-to in this situation in Johnstown. They specialize in hand-tossed NY-style pizzas, and they have all the combinations you might want, like Meat Lovers and Vegetarian. Beef up your pizza meal to satisfy a crowd and order some hoagies, pasta dinners, and appetizers.

Cumberland

Also known as the Queen City, Cumberland is a regional business and commercial center in western Maryland, located on the Potomac River. Bella Napoli is the most sought-after restaurant in the area. This restaurant has a substantial menu, with Neapolitan pizza as their focus. Other pizza choices include a decadent thick-crust Sicilian pizza, calzones, and strombolis. Bella Napoli is ideal if you pass by on your next road trip and need a gluten-free menu. They do both gluten-free pizza and pasta.

Greensburg

Greenburg is and has been a major cultural center in all of western Pennsylvania, thanks to the Westmoreland Museum of American Art. If you are visiting the area to admire historical American art and are also craving some pizza, Lupi & Leo is your go-to location.

At Lupi & Leo in Greensburg, pizza innovation is the name of the game. They offer various unique pizza creations, like the Mac and Cheese Brisket Pizza. It’s topped exactly as it sounds - with cheddar-gouda mac and cheese and succulent brisket. Try the Pickle Pizza for tangy pickles and garlic on mozzarella cheese topped with ranch. You’ll probably find your new favorite pizza here!