435 Hepburn Street Plaza, Williamsport, PA 17701
Located almost exactly halfway between Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, Williamsport is the cultural and economic center of central Pennsylvania. Williamsport has a classic small-town feeling, with their Main Street being the center of town. Historic buildings, shops, restaurants, and pizzerias line the streets, where the community of Williamsport gathers for work or leisure.
Williamsport is most famous for being the beating heart of Little League Baseball. The organization is headquartered in South Williamsport and the Little League World Series is held annually at Lamade Stadium in town. This association only adds to the family and community-oriented culture in Williamsport. Because this is a smaller city, most of the population is comprised of families working and living in town or the surrounding neighborhoods. Lycoming College has a scenic campus right near downtown Williamsport as well. This makes restaurants like pizzerias particularly vital for a place like Williamsport.
Because Williamsport is a family-oriented city, the always-dependable thin-crust pizza is the most common style on menus here. Thin-crust pizza is the perfect go-to for families as it’s perfect for prominently featuring toppings, as well as being simple and easy to eat.
Thin-crust pizza, most famous for originating in New York, eventually spread throughout the country to become one of the go-to dishes in every city. Williamsport is no different, families from around town have made a dinner of pizza their weekend or post-Little League game ritual. And while there are excellent Sicilian and stuffed pizzas in Williamsport, thin-crust is the most common pie you’ll find.
The relative simplicity of thin-crust pizza doesn’t mean the pizza chefs in this town don’t get creative with their pies. You’ll find every topping from spicy honey to balsamic to BBQ Fried chicken on these pies. Because thin-crust is the ideal pizza for a group, a variety of toppings makes it easier to satisfy everyone.
Leo’s Pizzeria is a casual pizza place in downtown Williamsport that is popular for classic Italian-inspired pies and calzones. Their thin-crust pizzas are baked with a perfect char, with the crunchy outer crust, and chewy crust in the middle that goes perfectly with the melty cheese and premium toppings.
They name their Margherita pizza the Queen because it’s their chef’s favorite menu item. Their signature mozzarella blend mixes perfectly with the freshest basil available. These classic flavors go perfectly with their homemade sauce and crust. The Caprese Pizza combines mozzarella, basil, and tomatoes with a balanced balsamic glaze to create one of the best pizzas in Williamsport.
The Fireboy Pie might be a little less classic, but just as delicious. Anyone who can handle some heat will enjoy pepperoni, crushed red peppers, spicy honey, and jalapenos on a cheesy thin-crust pizza. The spicy honey and jalapenos balance perfectly for a sweet but very spicy pizza.
Order from Leo’s Pizzeria with Slice to get Williamsport’s best pizza and more delivered right to your door.
Right in downtown Williamsport, Long Island Pizza is a must-try restaurant for a variety of pizza styles. While you might think they would specialize in New York-style thin crust, their chefs excel at stuffed pizza. The Stromboli Pizza combines your favorite pepperoni and mozzarella, while their Chicken Delight loads this pizza with chicken, bacon, and cheddar. The must-try might be their Meatball Parm Stuffed Pizza, which is stuffed with homemade meatballs, their signature tomato sauce, and parmesan cheese for an endlessly satisfying product.
Long Island Pizza also has an excellent selection of stromboli and sub sandwiches for the lunch crowd. Their Super Stromboli is packed with just about every meat in their kitchen, and the Italian Sub Sandwich transports you back to Long Island with its classic Italian cold cuts and hot peppers.
Right across the river in South Williamsport is The South Side Restaurant, Pizzeria & Tavern. This no-frills casual restaurant offers a variety of specialty thin-crust pizzas that are sure to satisfy any craving. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza offers a huge kick of spice and cools the tastebuds with a blend of blue cheese and mozzarella. Their Margherita is the perfect option for purists. This pizza is your go-to for classic Italian flavors with lightly charred thin-crust and locally-sourced fresh toppings.
With menu items like classic Sicilian and Godfather Pizza, you can’t say Original Italian Pizza in Montoursville isn’t aptly named. This pizzeria focuses on recreating authentic Italian recipes and flavors in pizza form. The Godfather is topped with sliced sausage, pepperoni, raw onion, a drizzle of house peppers, and their house blend of parmesan with oregano. Their Stromboli menu has a flavor for everyone and anyone! Grilled Veggies, Steak, Buffalo Chicken, and Four Cheese Stromboli are the most popular.
Just down the river in Jersey Shore, D’Agostino’s Pizza & Subs is a perfect go-to restaurant for quick bites and pizza. While you are certainly encouraged to create your own pizza, D’Agostino’s challenges customers to keep it simple with three pizza options: red, white, and supreme. Their homemade tomato sauce for their red pizza is a perfect balance of sweet and savory, with their blend of mozzarella melted on top. Their white pizza has an olive oil and garlic base and will satisfy your craving for simple flavors done well. Try one of their hot or cold sub sandwiches. With almost 20 options to choose from, all of which are executed perfectly, you will most certainly find your new favorite sub.
Q: What restaurant has the best thin-crust Pizza in Williamsport?
Q: What restaurant has the best Sicilian pizza in Williamsport?
Q: What restaurant has the best-stuffed pizza in Williamsport?
Q: What restaurant has the best veggie pizza in Williamsport?