Top Pizza Restaurants in Lexington, SC Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Lexington: a local guide

When visiting Lexington, be ready to taste authentic Italian dishes, such as the local's favorite Sicilian pizza. Many pizzerias in the town make some flavorsome Sicilian pizzas prepared using wood-fired or gas ovens. The baking methods help attain an original Italian pizza flavor. Sicilian pizza was made famous in Lexington around the 1950s, and now this savory style of pizza is dominant. The Sicilian pizza has a spongy crust with a meatless sauce. The crust is also referred to as focaccia. For an authentic taste, expect toppings of herbs, onions, tomatoes, and anchovies. You can customize the toppings if you want, but sometimes the traditional toppings are better. That way, you can eat the pizza as the creators intended. Done correctly, one bite of a Sicilian pizza in Lexington, and you’ll be carried away to Sicily.

Best Delivery Pizza in Lexington, South Carolina

Papa Gio's Pizzeria is a Lexington treasure that has served the residents tasty Sicilian pizza by the slice and other gourmet pizzas. The family-owned and run pizzeria uses 100% Grande mozzarella cheese for better flavor and consistency. If you eat gluten-free, Papa Gio’s has you covered with their cauliflower crust. You can get it in six different ways, like the Meat Lover’s and BBQ Chicken. They also do a fantastic flatbread pizza that will keep you coming back for more. Make sure you order your delivery on an empty stomach so you can also add starters to your meal. The calamari and Papa Gio’s Sampler are great options. Feel free to try their soup, salads, and wings if you’ve got the room. Then, there’s always the cannoli and cheesecake for dessert. Quick delivery and friendly service will have you repeatedly ordering from Papa Gio’s.

Best Takeout Pizza in Lexington, South Carolina

Online takeout pizza or what some people call takeaway pizza makes it easier to enjoy authentic Italian food in the comfort of your home. Luce Cucina Italiano is a family-owned and managed pizzeria that has served Lexington residents with homemade New York-style pizzas since 2009. The pizzas are hand-tossed and also available in thin crust. The menu at Luce Cucina Italiano is creative. They have fun pizzas like the Philadelphia Pizza with onions, tomatoes, and grilled steak. The Super Supreme Pizza really is super. It has four kinds of meat, mushrooms, olives, onions, and banana peppers. For vegetarians, they have the Spinach and Broccoli Calzone, the Veggie Calzone, the Brooklyn Bridge Pizza, and the Vegetarian Pizza. It’s safe to say that no one will go hungry when you order takeout from Luce.

Best Pizza Near Lexington

Irmo

The town of Irmo lies nine miles southeast of Lexington and is home to award-winning pizzerias like Brooklyn Express Pizza. They offer authentic New York-style pizzas and veggie pizza. The restaurant uses fresh ingredients and vegetables to prepare its mouth-watering dishes, which you can order on Slice. The pizzeria has reasonable prices, especially given how yummy the food is. Brooklyn Express Pizza has a great selection of salads, stuffed pizza, wings, burgers, and daily specials.

West Columbia

West Columbia is located ten miles to the east of Lexington and is a good destination for takeout or delivery pizza. Big Cheese Pizza is one of the best pizzerias in town, offering authentic Italian and New York-style pizzas. The pizzeria also serves gyros, Philly subs, sandwiches, and combo meals. The prices are favorable, and the delivery and takeout are quick. They’ll get your order right every time, especially if you order on Slice.

Cayce

You will have to travel a little east of Lexington to Cayce to enjoy the world-class pizzas prepared in town. Schlotzsky's has served Cayce residents delicious pizza for over 20 years. The pizzeria uses old pizza recipes, which bring out the best flavor in the dishes. On the menu, you’ll find tasty veggie pizzas, flatbreads, soups, salads, and a kid's menu.

show more iconSee More

PIZZA TYPES IN LEXINGTON

EVEN MORE TYPES OF FOOD IN LEXINGTON

Slicechevron right iconSouth Carolinachevron right icon Pizza Places in Lexington, SC